On the Textus Receptus

Some very helpful recent resources:

Ward also has written a brilliant article with a title worth asking anyone who wants to talk about ‘the Textus Receptus’: Which Textus Receptus?

See also this related article by Elijah Hixson which points out that there are at least 6 editions of the TR which lack the Comma Johanneum (1 John 5:7) – including the one that served as the basis for Luther’s German translation of the Bible.

I’ve previously linked to James White’s debate with Jeff Riddle. The discussion below with him and Stephen Boyce is also very helpful: they cover Luke 2:22; Eph 3:9; 1 John 5:7 and maybe one or two others.

Boyce also has some helpful articles:

Update: Some more resources:

The Joy of Hearing

The Joy of Hearing: A theology of the book of Revelation
Tom Schreiner
Crossway, 2021

This is the first book of a new series, which actually begins with the last book of the Bible. The editors of the series note that ‘there are remarkably few treatments of the big ideas of single books of the New Testament’. Schreiner’s book on Revelation is the first in a planned series of books aiming to remedy that for students, preachers and interested lay-people.

I’ve written a post elsewhere entitled ‘What to read before preaching a book of the Bible’, and one of my suggestions is to read ‘a monograph of manageable size’ – ie a book like this.

This series doesn’t seem like it will be overly technical – it’s maybe a step below the NSBT series (which is more focused on topics than single books of the Bible).

One of the books I suggested in my other post was Richard Bauckham’s The Theology of the Book of Revelation (almost exactly the same length as this, but a bit more technical). Schreiner quotes from it around 50 times here (most other quotations are from commentary introductions), and it’s still the one book on Revelation I would recommend for ministers. Schreiner’s would be more suitable to give to someone in the pew. That’s not to say this is flawed by any means – Schreiner is always a reliable guide – so if you can read both, do!

It’s certainly a series worth paying attention to, and for most NT books will fill an important gap in the market.

Be thou my vision: a liturgy for daily worship

Be thou my vision
Jonathan Gibson
Crossway, 2021

The worship of many Presbyterian churches has become more liturgical in recent years. Or as they would argue, everyone has a liturgy, and they’ve just started to think theirs through a bit more. So the ‘four-hymn sandwhich’ has been replaced by a Call to Worship, Confession of Sin, Assurance of Pardon, perhaps Recitation of a Creed etc. As Brian Schwertly points out in his article Are Liturgies Authorized by Scripture, historic Presbyterian opposition to liturgies wasn’t because prayers were written down, but because they were enforced.

This book came about because of a lockdown effort by the author to revitalise his own devotions by including these elements in his personal worship. The resulting effort gives you the opportunity to do the same. The book is structured for 31 days, which you can then repeat monthly. It’s a mix of Scripture readings, prayers from church history (occasionally from some surprising authors such as Samuel Johnson), creeds, catechisms, doxologies, and the Gloria Patri. For the catechisms, there’s the great realisation that if you do Heidelberg – Shorter Catechism – Heidelberg, it will give you questions for exactly 365 days. It is a pity however that rather than printing 3 questions for each day (or even just the first 31 days of the Heidelberg), you’re just directed to an appendix at the back of the book. This isn’t easy to do on a kindle, and even in the printed book will require you to remember which question you did the day before. Unless you tick them off, like an animal. For the Bible reading aspect, M’Cheyne’s reading plan is an appendix. There’s also an appendix with Collects from the 1552 (more Protestant than its predecessor) Book of Common Prayer.

As for the binding, it’s cloth over board, in a slipcase. There is a cowhide leather edition which is exclusive to WTS Books in the USA for some reason, which is a bit disappointing. All in all however it will make a good Christmas present for many, especially any with some Anglican sympathies!

The Qualifications and Duties of Elders (J. A. Chancellor)

The Church is a spiritual society composed of all who are, in Christ Jesus, and is embraced as a perfect whole, in the Eternal Purpose and Covenant of Jehovah. The Church Visible consists of those who profess the true religion, with their children. The word is applied in the New Testament to the κλητόί, the ἐκκλησία, the called and gathered of any particular place, who avow their faith in Christ and obedience to Him, and who, separating themselves from the world, statedly assemble for His worship and service. It is also applied to the aggregate of such assemblies throughout the country or throughout the world. To enable this Church to secure the ends of her existence, office-bearers exist by direct Divine appointment, to whom a variety of names, indicating diversity of work, is given.

The office of Teaching, being the most important, embraces within itself all the offices. Hence the names Pastor, Bishop, Presbyter, Deacon, are all given to the Teacher. After the Teacher, all the officers given to the Church are officers of administration. The word Pastor designates the officer whose business it is to take care of all the spiritual interests of the flock. The Greek word επισκοπος, “overseer” or “bishop,” represents the same office in its application to different kinds of work, as illustrated by its use in the Roman Empire. The term πρεσβύτερος, elder, was the title of an officer which existed from time immemorial in the Jewish Church, subsidiary to the higher functionaries of the Temple and Synagogue, one to whom was committed the administration of ecclesiastical law throughout the community. As effective teaching is due largely to personal and authorative administration, the Teacher must be invested with full power in this department also; and, therefore, he is not only Pastor, Overseer, Presbyter, but by reason of his higher office, he presides in the meetings of the Presbyters, and is called by way of eminence, the Pastor or Bishop of the congregation. But the single Teacher is never the sole ruler in any congregation, and his office of teaching confers upon him no superiority of rank or power in administration, over his fellow elders.

Specially is there needed a class of officers belonging to and mingling with the people, who shall exert, not merely a personal, but an official influence and power, as the appointed administrators of the law of Christ. Now this is just what the constitution has provided, when it requires the existence of a number of Ruling Elders in every congregation (see Rom. xii. 8., 1 Cor. xii. 28., 1 Tim. v. 17.) It is now conceded that the πρεσβύτερος and the επισκοπος in the Apostolic Churches were the same, the words being used interchangeably. A number of these were ordained in every church and it was to the whole, in their joint capacity as a Session of Presbyters, that the power of government and the Pastoral oversight of the members were committed. Whether the teaching was stated or occasional, the provision for the exercise of discipline and the administration of affairs was, from the beginning, an integral and abiding part of the local organisation. Teachers at first came from without, as the messengers of the Churches—the ambassadors of Christ. When settled in a particular sphere, they became Pastors as well as Teachers. But even in their absence, the flock was not left without pastoral instruction—elders being selected, because they were “apt to teach,” as well as fit to rule. All rule and administration in the Church involves a measure and kind of instruction, which, while it does not trench in the least upon the work of the official Teacher, is yet of the utmost value in giving character and efficiency to Church power. The late Baron Bunsen observes “The hypothesis of the Presbyterian Divines of the Sixteenth and Seventeenth centuries, that the elders form both an officiating and ruling body is quite correct.” (Hippolytus and His Age, Vol. III. 221.)

The recently discovered ” Teaching of the Apostles,” [a Greek copy of the Didache was found in 1873 and published in 1883, with an English translation following in 1884] shows conclusively, that the organisation and order sanctioned by the Apostles continued to prevail during the first half of the second century. Chapter XV. is as follows:—“Appoint therefore for yourselves bishops and deacons worthy of the Lord, men meek and uncovetous and true and approved, for they too minister to you the ministry of the prophets and teachers. Therefore despise them not, for they are the honoured among you with the prophets and teachers.” That the Elders continued to hold the same place of dignity and power during the later half of the second century and afterwards, despite the gradual encroachments of a clerical episcopacy, is admitted by Mr. Hatch. “It is clear from the exhortation of Polycarp to the presbyters of Philippi, that those presbyters had the supreme oversight of all matters of administration. It was their duty to visit the sick, to provide for the widows and orphans and poor, to turn back those who had gone astray from the error of their ways, to sit in merciful judgment on those who had committed wrong. The building in which they assembled came to be called a Basilica or court-house; the part of it in which they sat a Tribunal or judgment seat; they were chiefly courts of discipline. Nor does it appear that any of these duties ever wholly ceased to be the duties of the presbyterate. The presbyters were, in theory, the Council of the bishop, even after the bishop had asserted a virtual autocracy.” (Bampton Lectures, p. 66. [1880])

Having thus shown the original design of the Eldership and the place assigned to it, it will be the less needful now to enlarge upon its qualifications and duties; still, the following classified statements are submitted :—

Continue reading →

Nichol’s Series of Commentaries – Puritan Period

TLDR: I couldn’t find a complete list anywhere, so have tried to make one.

In the mid-1800s, James Nichol, after reprinting the Works of some of the most well-known Puritans (The Standard Divines – Puritan Period), undertook to republish Puritan commentaries on many books of the Bible. (The closest equivalent today would be Banner’s Geneva series, or the Crossway Classic Commentaries).

J. C. Ryle wrote an endorsement of the series where he said: ‘it deserves the cordial support of all lovers of sound scriptural theology…Mr Nichol’s reprints of Goodwin, Sibbes, Adams, &c., are undoubtedly an admirable addition to our theological literature. But, if I may venture an opinion, I think his new series is even more valuable than his old one’. (Charnock’s Works, ii, 1)

Ryle stated in 1864 that in the past 30-40 years, some Puritan expositions had been republished, but others hadn’t. The examples he gives of expositions that had been republished are:

Ezekiel: Greenhill
Hosea: Burroughs (and Hall and Newton)
2nd Peter: Adams
Jude: Jenkyn

Nichol had previously reissued some of these earlier republications, building on work done by James Sherman:

“The books were edited with great care by the late James Sherman; who, in July 1861, being then within a short time of his death, made over the stereotype plates of the three volumes as a free gift to Mr Nichol, for republication in the present form. The third of these [Daille on Philippians & Colossians] is as yet unknown to us, but Adams’ is inestimable, and Burroughs on Hosea is of sterling worth.” (Macphail’s Edinburgh ecclesiastical journal, 1862, p. 356).

Nichol’s series isn’t that well known as most of them haven’t been republished since (some were by Tentmaker) – however most of them have been digitised and are available online, and some are also available in Logos.

As a complete list of the series doesn’t seem to exist anywhere, this is an attempt at one.

This list from 20 years later (listing the authors but not the books) comprises 15 volumes, though some of the volumes contain more than one commentary. It also provides the dates 1864-69

Ruth: Richard Bernard [1628] and Thomas Fuller [1654] (bound with Stock & Torshell on Malachi) (1865)
Psalms: Samuel Smith on Psalm 1; Thomas Pierson on Psalms 27, 84, 85, 87; William Gouge on Psalm 116 (1868)
Proverbs: Peter Muffet (1868)
Ecclesiastes: John Cotton (bound with above)
Song of Solomon: John Cotton (bound with above)
Isaiah ch 5 – ‘A strange vineyard in Palestina’: Nehemiah Rogers (1867)
Obadiah and Habakkuk: Edward Marbury (1865)
Obadiah and Haggai: John Rainolds (late President of Crop. Chri. Coll.) (1613)
Jonah: John King (Bishop of London) (1618)
Malachi: Richard Stock and Samuel Torshell [1641] (bound with Bernard & Fuller on Ruth) (1865)
Matthew ch 5 (Beatitudes) – ‘The Saints’ Happiness’ (1867
John 17: George Newton (1867)
Romans 8:1-4: Thomas Jacomb (1868)
Ephesians: Paul Bayne (1866)
Philippians: Henry Airay (bound with Cartwright on Colossians) (1864) [1618]
Colossians: Byfield (1869)
Colossians: Thomas Cartwright (bound with Airay on Philippians) (1864) [1612]
Hebrews: Gouge
1st John: Hardy

Not included but similar:

2nd Timothy: Hall
Titus: Thomas Taylor
1st Peter: John Rogers
[Ryle says ‘his scheme embraces such works as Rogers on 1st Peter’ etc, but I can’t find any evidence that Rogers’ ‘godly and fruitful exposition’ (first? published posthumously in 1650) was ever republished. Same for the others above.]

Nichol states: ‘It is not contemplated that this Supplemental Series shall include all the Commentaries of the Puritan period, but that it shall extend,—if it is sufficiently supported,—to the republication of those works which, by common consent, are prized as precious legacies to the Church, valuable to the modern theological student, and which, from their high price and rarity, are not easily obtainable.’

The council of publication was:

W. Lindsay Alexander
James Begg
Thomas J. Crawford
D. T. K. Drummond
William H. Goold
Andrew Thomson

General editor: Thomas Smith

See also:

Only slaves work 7 days

Exodus 31:12-17, especially verses 13 and 17, indicates that the Sabbath is a “sign.” It marked out Israel as unique, for other peoples did not have the Sabbath. Strangely, perhaps in reaction to later scribal details/legalism, there is a negative view of the Sabbath in the contemporary church. Even evangelicalism, though holding a kind of tolerance for the Sabbath, has more interest in bolstering the case for why we don’t need to adhere to the fourth commandment.

But note Exodus 20:8-11. The Sabbath is a gift because they shabat on it, they stop work (Exod. 34:21). Only a free people does that. In Egypt they didn’t dare stop work! But when Yahweh freed them from bondage, he enabled them to cease from work – every week! The Sabbath is a sign of grace and freedom, not of bondage. Slaves work all the time, but free people have the liberty of rest — including servants and livestock and sojourners! Here is the social benefit of the commandment. So, when you insist on cluttering the Sabbath with work:

1. It is a failure of faith, because by your working and not resting, you are saying that you cannot trust Yahweh to provide for you but must keep working because all your life rests on your efforts.

2. It is a failure of compassion, because then your dependents (family, servants, livestock) will not enjoy rest. See Deuteronomy 5:14 for this social argument.

3. It is a choice of bondage, for you are deifying work,subjecting yourself to a continuous treadmill which Yahweh meant to interrupt weekly. But you are saying, “No, I want to be a slave, I want to return to Egypt; I want to run, frustrated and exhausted, to Wal-Mart and Target, to Dillards and McRaes, on the Lord’s Day. I want to pay bills then, I want to complete seminary assignments then, I want to wash my cars and mow my lawn and work on my income tax and go to the video store. I want to be a slave! I do not want rest or quietness or solitude — I might meet God.”

Yahweh’s pattern is: work six days and stop for one day. It is a way of saying that work is not your god. These principles remain for the people of God, even though our culture and government is non-covenantal and pays no attention to them.

Dale Ralph Davis on Nehemiah 13