Special Revivals v. Ordinary Means of Grace (1881)

“…It is not necessary to prove that a continuous Divine blessing on the ordinary means of grace is likely to promote a healthy religious condition. The Head of the Church alone has authority to institute ordinances, and He alone can make them effectual. He has appointed the ordinary means of grace, and the Sabbath as the time when public ordinances are to be dispensed, and our attention wholly given to spiritual things.

The Apostles embraced every opportunity of preaching the Gospel on week-days, and we find Paul disputing daily in the school of Tyrannus, and yet it is remarkable how often we read of him addressing the worshippe[rs], in the synagogue on the Sabbath, and then of a whole week intervening before the people again assembled. And when he reached Troas on one of his journeys, though he was hastening to Jerusalem, he tarried seven days that he might join the disciples there in their communion on the Christian Sabbath.

There are several circumstances which seem to render occasional series of continued services less desirable than a faithful plying of the ordinary means of grace. When they are frequently employed as the means of producing an interest in religion, people come to regard them as the only seasons when conversions need be expected, and they do not look and pray for conversions and an abundant blessing at the ordinary services of the sanctuary. They do not value these services as they ought, and neglect to make self-application of the truth preached in them. Ministers get into the habit of being more pointed and searching and earnest at the special services. They cease to expect a blessing at the ordinary services, and do not aim directly at immediate results. Thus the ordinary services are allowed to become perfunctory and uninteresting. They lose their hold on the people, and lukewarmness and deadness spread slowly, but surely, among them.

…If we expect that the world will be converted by great movements, produced by the labours of great evangelists, an injurious result is very likely to follow. It is easier for ministers to cherish the idea that many conversions are only to be looked for under the preaching of such evangelists, and to bring them, and crowd round them, than to put forth constant and strenuous efforts in the cultivation of their own personal piety, in manifesting on all occasions a Christ-like spirit, in prayer and preaching, and thus to constrain success. And it is easier for the people to make spasmodic effort when such evangelists are among them, and loll in spiritual indolence all the rest of the time, than to stir themselves up continuously to earnest prayer and self-denying effort. When occasional revivals occur and come to be regarded as the great means of quickening Christians, and converting sinners, the periods which intervene are generally seasons of great spiritual deadness when the coldness and declension which prevail are often in proportion to the excitement, which has gone before…”

Continue reading →

Fasting turned to Feasting: The Lord’s Day

“As the Lord’s Supper leads the way in that direction, I may say that every other fast of the Christian has been transfigured in the same manner. The Sabbath is to many people a very dreary day; but to many of us it is a fast which has been turned into a feast. I am often amused when I read the accounts that are given by some people of an English Sabbath-day. In all soberness it is set forth what we Puritans do on this the first day of the week. We wake up in the morning, and say to ourselves, “Another dreadfully miserable day come round,” and then we go off to our places of worship, where we sit with frightfully long faces, and listen to terribly dismal sermons; we do not sing, or even smile; but we howl out some ugly psalm, and make ourselves as unhappy as ever we can be. When we come home, we draw down the blinds to keep the sun out. We never go into the garden to admire the flowers. Well, you know all the rest of the story. I think we are descendants of the people who killed the cat on Monday because it caught mice on Sunday—at least, so I have heard. But if I had not read all this, I should not have known it. Often, when I see in the paper some description of myself, I say, “Well, people somehow seem to know me better than I know myself; I never thought anything of the kind; it has never entered my head. Yet here it is in black and white.” O beloved friends! our idea of the Lord’s-day is altogether different from this hideous caricature of it. If I had to describe our Sabbaths, I should say that they are full of brightness, and joy, and delight. I should tell of our singing, with full hearts, of the happy prospect before us in that land—

“Where congregations ne’er break up,
And Sabbaths have no end.”

I am sure we should not be likely to wish to go to that heavenly country if our Sabbaths here were as dreary as some say they are. Why, here in this house, we have had our merriest times! Of old, when the prodigal came back, “they began to be merry,” and I have never heard that they have left off; at any rate, I do not think that we have. We have rejoiced with the joy of harvest as we have heard of sinners saved, and have known that we are saved ourselves. I grant you that, before we knew the Lord, it did sometimes seem to our young minds rather a dull thing to read the Bible, and hear sermons, and to keep Sabbaths; but now that we have come to Christ, and he has saved us; now that we are his; the first day of the week, which was a fast, has become a feast, and we look with eager delight for the Sundays to come round one after another. In fact, these Lord’s-days are the beds of flowers in our gardens. The week-days are only the gravel paths that yield us little but weariness as we walk along them. Happy Sabbath! we hail thy coming with delight, and sing—

“Welcome, sweet day of rest,
That saw the Lord arise;
Welcome to this reviving breast,
And these rejoicing eyes!

“The King himself comes near,
And feasts his saints to-day;
Here we may sit, and see him here,
And love, and praise, and pray.”

Spurgeon on Zechariah 8:19, Sad Fasts Changed to Glad Feasts

Only slaves work 7 days

Exodus 31:12-17, especially verses 13 and 17, indicates that the Sabbath is a “sign.” It marked out Israel as unique, for other peoples did not have the Sabbath. Strangely, perhaps in reaction to later scribal details/legalism, there is a negative view of the Sabbath in the contemporary church. Even evangelicalism, though holding a kind of tolerance for the Sabbath, has more interest in bolstering the case for why we don’t need to adhere to the fourth commandment.

But note Exodus 20:8-11. The Sabbath is a gift because they shabat on it, they stop work (Exod. 34:21). Only a free people does that. In Egypt they didn’t dare stop work! But when Yahweh freed them from bondage, he enabled them to cease from work – every week! The Sabbath is a sign of grace and freedom, not of bondage. Slaves work all the time, but free people have the liberty of rest — including servants and livestock and sojourners! Here is the social benefit of the commandment. So, when you insist on cluttering the Sabbath with work:

1. It is a failure of faith, because by your working and not resting, you are saying that you cannot trust Yahweh to provide for you but must keep working because all your life rests on your efforts.

2. It is a failure of compassion, because then your dependents (family, servants, livestock) will not enjoy rest. See Deuteronomy 5:14 for this social argument.

3. It is a choice of bondage, for you are deifying work,subjecting yourself to a continuous treadmill which Yahweh meant to interrupt weekly. But you are saying, “No, I want to be a slave, I want to return to Egypt; I want to run, frustrated and exhausted, to Wal-Mart and Target, to Dillards and McRaes, on the Lord’s Day. I want to pay bills then, I want to complete seminary assignments then, I want to wash my cars and mow my lawn and work on my income tax and go to the video store. I want to be a slave! I do not want rest or quietness or solitude — I might meet God.”

Yahweh’s pattern is: work six days and stop for one day. It is a way of saying that work is not your god. These principles remain for the people of God, even though our culture and government is non-covenantal and pays no attention to them.

Dale Ralph Davis on Nehemiah 13

Lord’s Day, Sabbath or Sunday?

‘Seing it gets this name to be called the Lords day: It may be questioned here concerning our manner of speaking of dayes, calling the Lords day Sunday, the next day after it Monday, &c. which hath the first rise from Superstition, if not from Idolatry: some of them being attributed to Planets, as Sunday and Monday; some of them to Idols, as Thursday, &c. But to speak to the thing it self, look to the Primitive times, we will find Sunday called the Lords day; and the dayes of the Week by the first, second, third, &c. But the names of dayes, being like the names of places and moneths, folks must speak of them, as they are in use, and Scripture warrands us so to do, Acts 17:22. Paul is said to stand in the midst of Mars hill. Acts 28:11 speaketh of a Ship, whose signe was Castor and Pollux. So, March, January, July and August, are from the Idols Mars and Janus; or, derived from men that appropriate more than ordinary to themselves. And though it was ordinary to Christians, in the primitive times, to call this day the Lords day among themselves; yet, when they had dealing with the Jew, they called it the Sabbath: and when they hid dealing with the heathen, they called it the Sunday. And so, though it be best to speak of days as Scripture nameth them; yet, it is agreeable with Scripture, to design or denominate them, as they are in use among a people, especially where no superstitious use is in naming of them.’

James Durham on Revelation 1:10

The Theology of the Westminster Standards (book review)

The Theology of the Westminster Standards: Historical Context and Theological Insights
J. V. Fesko
Crossway, 2014

fesko theology of the westminster standards

Those wanting to study the Westminster Standards in their historical context are living at an exciting time. The publication of Chad Van Dixhoorn’s monumental Minutes and Papers of the Westminster Assembly, 1643-1652 has been accompanied by 3 new series of books from Reformation Heritage: The Westminster Assembly Principle Documents series, Studies on the Westminster Assembly Series (the initial publications of which are by Wayne Spear and John Bower of the RPCNA) and The Westminster Assembly Facsimile Series. Making use of those, along with many of the primary sources now so easily available online, comes John Valero Fesko’s The Theology of the Westminster Standards (released just a month or so before Van Dixhoorn’s own Confessing the Faith).

Fesko’s thesis is that while there is still a lot of use made of, and commentaries published on the Westminster Standards, much of this study is divorced from their seventeenth century historical context. Even having the minutes is not enough as ‘the Westminster Assembly was part of a broader ongoing conversation with Patristic, medieval, Reformation and contemporary’ theologians. Fesko contends that there is no way one book could properly contextualise every part of the confession, so he picks out ten key themes such as the Doctrine of Scripture, Justification and the Church – and aims to inspire others to do more. His thesis serves as an important reminder not just to read the Standards and assume that how we use certain terms, or understand certain concepts, is the same way the Divines used them and understood them. The negative side of this is that if certain statements are unpalatable to the modern reader, Fesko can just write them off as an inevitable result of the historical context. This doesn’t happen much, but repeatedly comes up in regard to the teaching that the Pope is the anti-Christ, and at the expense of Fesko discussing any of the exegesis that got them there.

Rather than being the straitjacket they are often portrayed as, Fesko also does a good job of showing how Confessions of faith were ‘typically written to define truth and fence of heterodoxy and heresy while allowing a degree of doctrinal latitude within the boundaries of the confession’. Some of these are so obvious that they don’t really need much context to explain, but it does helps to see not just what we do believe but what we don’t.

The chapter on ‘Worship’ contains a couple of disappointments. Firstly, while Fesko includes some quotes as to the divines’ belief that the Lord’s Day is permanent and moral, he doesn’t give any of their arguments and rather brushes over a topic sorely needing more attention in a book written primarily for a North American audience. His sections on Psalmody and Instruments are particularly poor. He seems to list Calvin as an advocate of uninspired songs (unsupported by the footnotes he provides). He also fails to provide much support for his contention that while ‘At first glance the Confession appears to support the views of exclusive psalmody’, it actually doesn’t. While quoting David Dickson arguing for exclusive psalmody, he doesn’t reference any divine who didn’t, and the only scholarship he can point to is Nick Needham’s attempt to prove the divines weren’t against hymns and instruments, which has been refuted by Matthew Winzer. When it comes to instruments, Fesko can only muster a paragraph, which claims that the issue of musical instruments was ‘apparently avoided’ by the Standards! Again the only ‘scholarship’ he can cite is Needham, and the only theologian he can list in favour of instruments is the Jesuit Robert Bellarmine. Finally, Fesko’s section on ‘two kingdoms’ in his section on ‘The Church’ should probably be read with caution, not just because he comes from Westminster Seminary California, but because of his reliance on the work of his colleague David VanDrunen.

For all the recent resources Fesko has utilised, he seem to be unaware of the newer Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (2004), but relies on its predecessor which was published over a century earlier, leaving him unnecessarily scratching his head occasionally (eg p. 59, n. 73). While his annotated bibliography mentions the fact that PDFs of primary sources can be downloaded to your computer or tablet from the PRDL, he doesn’t mention that a number of works he lists can also be downloaded in a much more readable and searchable format from Logos Bible Software.

Those caveats aside, Fesko succeeds not just in providing an illuminating book for those with an interest in historical theology, but in showing that any serious study of these important documents must be done with the historical context in mind. Thanks to the resources that have become available over the last few years, it has never been easier to do so.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.