Nichol’s Series of Commentaries – Puritan Period

TLDR: I couldn’t find a complete list anywhere, so have tried to make one.

In the mid-1800s, James Nichol, after reprinting the Works of some of the most well-known Puritans (The Standard Divines – Puritan Period), undertook to republish Puritan commentaries on many books of the Bible. (The closest equivalent today would be Banner’s Geneva series, or the Crossway Classic Commentaries).

J. C. Ryle wrote an endorsement of the series where he said: ‘it deserves the cordial support of all lovers of sound scriptural theology…Mr Nichol’s reprints of Goodwin, Sibbes, Adams, &c., are undoubtedly an admirable addition to our theological literature. But, if I may venture an opinion, I think his new series is even more valuable than his old one’. (Charnock’s Works, ii, 1)

Ryle stated in 1864 that in the past 30-40 years, some Puritan expositions had been republished, but others hadn’t. The examples he gives of expositions that had been republished are:

Ezekiel: Greenhill
Hosea: Burroughs (and Hall and Newton)
2nd Peter: Adams
Jude: Jenkyn

Nichol had previously reissued some of these earlier republications, building on work done by James Sherman:

“The books were edited with great care by the late James Sherman; who, in July 1861, being then within a short time of his death, made over the stereotype plates of the three volumes as a free gift to Mr Nichol, for republication in the present form. The third of these [Daille on Philippians & Colossians] is as yet unknown to us, but Adams’ is inestimable, and Burroughs on Hosea is of sterling worth.” (Macphail’s Edinburgh ecclesiastical journal, 1862, p. 356).

Nichol’s series isn’t that well known as most of them haven’t been republished since (some were by Tentmaker) – however most of them have been digitised and are available online, and some are also available in Logos.

As a complete list of the series doesn’t seem to exist anywhere, this is an attempt at one.

This list from 20 years later (listing the authors but not the books) comprises 15 volumes, though some of the volumes contain more than one commentary. It also provides the dates 1864-69

Ruth: Richard Bernard [1628] and Thomas Fuller [1654] (bound with Stock & Torshell on Malachi) (1865)
Psalms: Samuel Smith on Psalm 1; Thomas Pierson on Psalms 27, 84, 85, 87; William Gouge on Psalm 116 (1868)
Proverbs: Peter Muffet (1868)
Ecclesiastes: John Cotton (bound with above)
Song of Solomon: John Cotton (bound with above)
Isaiah ch 5 – ‘A strange vineyard in Palestina’: Nehemiah Rogers (1867)
Obadiah and Habakkuk: Edward Marbury (1865)
Obadiah and Haggai: John Rainolds (late President of Crop. Chri. Coll.) (1613)
Jonah: John King (Bishop of London) (1618)
Malachi: Richard Stock and Samuel Torshell [1641] (bound with Bernard & Fuller on Ruth) (1865)
Matthew ch 5 (Beatitudes) – ‘The Saints’ Happiness’ (1867
John 17: George Newton (1867)
Romans 8:1-4: Thomas Jacomb (1868)
Ephesians: Paul Bayne (1866)
Philippians: Henry Airay (bound with Cartwright on Colossians) (1864) [1618]
Colossians: Byfield (1869)
Colossians: Thomas Cartwright (bound with Airay on Philippians) (1864) [1612]
Hebrews: Gouge
1st John: Hardy

Not included but similar:

2nd Timothy: Hall
Titus: Thomas Taylor
1st Peter: John Rogers
[Ryle says ‘his scheme embraces such works as Rogers on 1st Peter’ etc, but I can’t find any evidence that Rogers’ ‘godly and fruitful exposition’ (first? published posthumously in 1650) was ever republished. Same for the others above.]

Nichol states: ‘It is not contemplated that this Supplemental Series shall include all the Commentaries of the Puritan period, but that it shall extend,—if it is sufficiently supported,—to the republication of those works which, by common consent, are prized as precious legacies to the Church, valuable to the modern theological student, and which, from their high price and rarity, are not easily obtainable.’

The council of publication was:

W. Lindsay Alexander
James Begg
Thomas J. Crawford
D. T. K. Drummond
William H. Goold
Andrew Thomson

General editor: Thomas Smith

See also:

Psalms commentary recommendations

I’ve come across a few psalm commentary recommendations lately and thought I’d share them here. David Murray’s new Jesus on Every Page podcast features commentary reviews in each episode and he began with the psalms. His recommendations were as follows:

Intros:
Hassell Bullock, Encountering the Book of Psalms
Geoffrey Grogan, Prayer, Praise & Prophecy: A Theology of the Psalms
James Adams, War Psalms of the Prince of Peace

Older commentaries: Spurgeon, Gill, William Plumer, Bonar

Newer: Hengstenberg, Leupold

Modern: Kidner, Harman, Van Gemeren (EBC), Gerald Wilson (NIVAC)

A request for recommendations on Craig Scott’s facebook page saw lots of votes for Spurgeon, a couple for Plumer, and also Alexander MacLaren (The Expositor’s Bible, volume 3 – from Mark L), David Dickson and George Horne.

In terms of commentary recommendations, my current go to resources are:
– Tremper Longman’s Old Testament Commentary Survey (Fifth edition, April 2013).
– Don Carson’s New Testament Commentary Survey (new edition due out in November).
– Keith Mathison – Top Commentaries on Every Book of the Bible. Worth checking as more preaching-focused than Carson and (especially) Longman.
– Challies – Best Commentaries on Each Book of the Bible (in progress). Basically just a rehash of the above 3. The comments from his readers are useful though and help identify newer commentaries and warn if something Carson/Longman wax lyrical about is overkill for the average busy pastor.
– Detroit Baptist Theological Seminary – Basic Library Booklist. Includes their top 5 commentaries on each book.

Any other commentary recommendations I come across, particularly on inidividual books, go here.

Update: Meant to link to my recent post on Medium: The peculiar idea that Christ is in every Psalm