Sewing up the Paraphrases

“This Calvinistic Methodist [Thomas Snell Jones] and the old Marrowman [John Colquhoun], whose funeral service he lived to preach, were knit together. Though a Welshman and accustomed to the laxer psalmody that prevailed in the great Methodist movement to the south of the Tweed, Thomas Jones came to be so satisfied with the exclusive use of the Paslter as the Church’s hymnbook that he put the Paraphrases which were bound up with it out of action. In this he was at one with Colquhoun. The one had the Paraphrases sewn up, the other had them cut out.”

‘John Colquhouon on The Covenant of Grace’ in John Macleod, Some Favourite Books (Edinburgh; Banner of Truth, 1988), p. 62

Not seeing the Wode for the trees: Duguid responds to Denlinger

Duguid book

In December my response to Aaron Denlinger’s rehashing of long-disproved arguments against exlusive psalmody on Reformation 21 received a link from everyone’s favourite London Welshman. Ref 21 however declined the opportunity of posting the response of a leading Wode Psalter scholar to Denlinger’s claim that the uninspired songs the psalter includes were sung in public worship.

Dr Timothy Duguid, author of Metrical Psalmody in Print and Practice: English ‘Singing Psalms’ and Scottish ‘Psalm Buiks’, c. 1547-1640, has therefore made his response available online. He concludes:

‘Denlinger admits, “I’ve never been hugely impressed by the biblical and/or theological arguments for exclusive psalmody…” That is where the discussion should have ended, but he instead insists on finding rest and comfort in a suspect historical precedent. Neither Calvin nor the early Reformed Scottish Kirk promoted the singing of any non-Scriptural texts in their respective liturgies. Therefore, Denlinger is errant in his concluding remarks: “I’m comforted, then, to think that as I worship this Sunday and join my fellow Reformed believers in singing uninspired hymns, I’ll do so in the company of those Scottish Christians who peopled the Reformed Kirk in its earliest decades.” There is no spiritual comfort to be had in any extra-Biblical historical precedent, let alone one that never existed.’

Read the whole thing

The Theology of the Westminster Standards (book review)

The Theology of the Westminster Standards: Historical Context and Theological Insights
J. V. Fesko
Crossway, 2014

fesko theology of the westminster standards

Those wanting to study the Westminster Standards in their historical context are living at an exciting time. The publication of Chad Van Dixhoorn’s monumental Minutes and Papers of the Westminster Assembly, 1643-1652 has been accompanied by 3 new series of books from Reformation Heritage: The Westminster Assembly Principle Documents series, Studies on the Westminster Assembly Series (the initial publications of which are by Wayne Spear and John Bower of the RPCNA) and The Westminster Assembly Facsimile Series. Making use of those, along with many of the primary sources now so easily available online, comes John Valero Fesko’s The Theology of the Westminster Standards (released just a month or so before Van Dixhoorn’s own Confessing the Faith).

Fesko’s thesis is that while there is still a lot of use made of, and commentaries published on the Westminster Standards, much of this study is divorced from their seventeenth century historical context. Even having the minutes is not enough as ‘the Westminster Assembly was part of a broader ongoing conversation with Patristic, medieval, Reformation and contemporary’ theologians. Fesko contends that there is no way one book could properly contextualise every part of the confession, so he picks out ten key themes such as the Doctrine of Scripture, Justification and the Church – and aims to inspire others to do more. His thesis serves as an important reminder not just to read the Standards and assume that how we use certain terms, or understand certain concepts, is the same way the Divines used them and understood them. The negative side of this is that if certain statements are unpalatable to the modern reader, Fesko can just write them off as an inevitable result of the historical context. This doesn’t happen much, but repeatedly comes up in regard to the teaching that the Pope is the anti-Christ, and at the expense of Fesko discussing any of the exegesis that got them there.

Rather than being the straitjacket they are often portrayed as, Fesko also does a good job of showing how Confessions of faith were ‘typically written to define truth and fence of heterodoxy and heresy while allowing a degree of doctrinal latitude within the boundaries of the confession’. Some of these are so obvious that they don’t really need much context to explain, but it does helps to see not just what we do believe but what we don’t.

The chapter on ‘Worship’ contains a couple of disappointments. Firstly, while Fesko includes some quotes as to the divines’ belief that the Lord’s Day is permanent and moral, he doesn’t give any of their arguments and rather brushes over a topic sorely needing more attention in a book written primarily for a North American audience. His sections on Psalmody and Instruments are particularly poor. He seems to list Calvin as an advocate of uninspired songs (unsupported by the footnotes he provides). He also fails to provide much support for his contention that while ‘At first glance the Confession appears to support the views of exclusive psalmody’, it actually doesn’t. While quoting David Dickson arguing for exclusive psalmody, he doesn’t reference any divine who didn’t, and the only scholarship he can point to is Nick Needham’s attempt to prove the divines weren’t against hymns and instruments, which has been refuted by Matthew Winzer. When it comes to instruments, Fesko can only muster a paragraph, which claims that the issue of musical instruments was ‘apparently avoided’ by the Standards! Again the only ‘scholarship’ he can cite is Needham, and the only theologian he can list in favour of instruments is the Jesuit Robert Bellarmine. Finally, Fesko’s section on ‘two kingdoms’ in his section on ‘The Church’ should probably be read with caution, not just because he comes from Westminster Seminary California, but because of his reliance on the work of his colleague David VanDrunen.

For all the recent resources Fesko has utilised, he seem to be unaware of the newer Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (2004), but relies on its predecessor which was published over a century earlier, leaving him unnecessarily scratching his head occasionally (eg p. 59, n. 73). While his annotated bibliography mentions the fact that PDFs of primary sources can be downloaded to your computer or tablet from the PRDL, he doesn’t mention that a number of works he lists can also be downloaded in a much more readable and searchable format from Logos Bible Software.

Those caveats aside, Fesko succeeds not just in providing an illuminating book for those with an interest in historical theology, but in showing that any serious study of these important documents must be done with the historical context in mind. Thanks to the resources that have become available over the last few years, it has never been easier to do so.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

Ref 21’s historically flawed attack on Exclusive Psalmody continues

The contributors over at Reformation 21 must really have a bee in their bonnets about Exclusive Psalmody, with Aaron Denlinger (who?) laying into it just a few months after Mark Jones (refuted here, here and here) started the trend.

As Sean McDonald (RPCNA) notes (paraphrasing Trueman):

“What world are these guys coming from, when they think that exclusive psalmody is dangerous enough to the church that they devote actual time and energy to attacking it? How many people are going to read such an article, and simply be confirmed in their views/practices of omitting any Psalms at all from their worship services?”

For those wanting a refutation of yet more ahistorical clutching at straws, there’s a handy thread on Facebook. Various contributors point out that Denlinger’s argument is an old one which has been refuted time and time again in the past. For example, Chris Coldwell of Naphtali Press writes:

“This is OLD news; the Scottish Antiquary David Hay Fleming destroyed similar ideas of Scottish hymn singing advanced by Bonar over a 100 years ago. Hymn singing advocates were rare. Robert Boyd who wrote a massive theology based upon the book of Ephesians in Latin proves that only psalms were sung; he bemoans that fact. He lived during the period in question. See DHF’s Hymnology of the Scottish Reformation.”

[available to buy here and download here]. Originally published in the Original Secession Magazine in 1884 (searchable Google stub here, quite a few issues of the OS magazine are on archive.org but seemingly not this one) – SS]

Someone else provides a very helpful link to an article in the Princeton Theological Review (1912, Vol 10, no. 1) by Louis F. Benson on The Development of the English Hymn. Benson writes that the very fact that the inclusion of hymns went unchallenged did not mean that they were sung in church:

“The probablities seem to point in a direction precisely opposite. They suggest that the addition of hymns was made so easily simply because their use in church worship was not proposed, and because the singing of spiritual songs by the people or their use as means for instructing the young was acceptable to all. That no one of these hymns was ever used in any Scottish church cannot be affirmed, but if so there is no record of it. But that the appendix of hymns did not constitute a church hymn book, and that the hymns were not used continuously or generally can be affirmed with confidence and proved by reference to successive editions of the Psalter itself”

As another Facebook commenter notes:

“The problem is that the anti-EP side continually resurrect bad arguments that have been addressed and refuted many times before. Not to say there aren’t some good arguments on their side, but the person who has thought carefully enough about the issue to make them is rare.”

R. Scott Clark on hymns and instruments

A mass of evidence from the Heidelblog to show that unaccompanied psalm singing has been the majority position of the church, and especially the Reformers.

Hymns

What Did the Divines Mean By “Psalms”?
“In [Calvin’s] treatises, including his 1559 Institutes, where the word psalm occurs about 500 times, the word psalm seems to refer almost invariably to a canonical psalm…I searched about 114 orthodox Reformed texts (from Junius, Perkins, Bucanus, Cartwright, Twisse, Gilespie, Diodati, Paraeus) from 1600 to 1640 and found no obvious evidence of psalm used to include an extra-canonical song.”

Calvin: We Sing Psalms In Public Worship
“Only let the world be well advised, that instead of songs partly vain and frivolous, partly foolish and dull, partly filthy and vile, and consequently wicked and hurtful, which it has heretofore used, it should accustom itself hereafter to sing these heavenly and divine songs, with good king David.”

Gavin Beers (!): Of Psalms, Hymns, And Spiritual Songs And The RPW
“But why does Paul employ three terms in Ephesians 5:19, if what you are saying is that all three refer to the Book of Psalms? Is that not a bit redundant, a bit like saying Psalms, Psalms and Psalms?’ In answer to this objection we have already seen that the Psalms themselves do this, eg the title of Psalm 76, Psalm 65 in the title and v1. In addition to this we should also note how frequently in Scripture God employs a three-fold statement to refer to the same thing, a Biblical triplet of terms. So laws can be ‘commandments, statutes and laws’ (Gen.26:5), miracles can be ‘Miracles, wonders and signs’ (Acts 2:22), and prayers can be ‘Prayers, supplications and intercessions’ (1Tim.2:1). So why should it be thought a strange thing that God should use three terms in the one verse to refer to His divinely inspired book of Psalms?”

Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual Songs in the Septuagint
“At the top of the Psalms in the LXX were titles or superscriptions. Those superscriptions described each Psalm, they categorized the psalms in 4 classes or groups:

  • ψαλμος [Psalms] (2-8, 10-14, 18-24, 28-30, 37-40, 42-43, 45-50, 61-67, 72, 74-76, 78-84, 86-87, 91, 93, 97-100, 107-109, 138-140, 142)
  • [συνεσις; understanding (31, 41, 43-44, 51-54, 73, 77, 87-88, 141)]
  • υμνος [Hymns] (5, 53-54, 60, 66, 75)
  • ωδη [Ode/Song] (3, 17, 29, 38, 44, 47, 64-67, 74-75, 82, 86-87, 90-92, 94-95, 107, 119-133)

…Arguably, even though the nouns for “wisdom” or “understanding” are different, we can say that here [Col 3:16] Paul invokes not just three of the categories but all 4: wisdom, psalms, hymns, and [Holy Spirit-given] songs.”

Instruments

The 1559 Geneva Bible On Musical Instruments
“Psalm 150:3: Exhorting the people only to rejoice in praising God, he maketh mention of those instruments which by God’s commandment were appointed in the old Law, but under Christ the use thereof is abolished”

The Church Fathers Reject Instrumental Music In Public Worship
“The vehement and unanimous objections of the Church Fathers to musical instruments apparently succeed in suppressing their use in Christian worship for many centuries. Indeed…at least one instrument, the Greek hydraulic organ, appears to have been largely forgotten in the West…..The demise of the organ as a common instrument in the West was so complete that when one arrived as a gift at the court of the Franks in 757 it was regarded as a great novelty.”

Calvin: Diligently To Inquire What Worship God Approves
“…But the Chaldeans thought to satisfy their god by heaping together many musical instruments. For, like other persons, they supposed God like themselves, for whatever delights us, we think must also please the Deity.”

Dabney: Moral Courage in Defence of that Vital Truth
“Hence such instruments are excluded from Christian worship. Such has been the creed of all churches, and in all ages, except of the Popish communion after it had reached the nadir of its corruption at the end of the thirteenth century, and of its prelatic imitators.”

Aquinas: The Use Of Instruments In Public Worship Is Judaizing
“In the Old Testament instruments of this description were employed, both because the people were more coarse and carnal—so that they needed to be aroused by such instruments as also by earthly promises—and because these material instruments were figures of something else.”

Calvin On Instruments: Not Given For Us To Imitate

Bit a both!

Psalms, Hymns, Spiritual Songs, and Instruments In The Latin Bibles
“Most of the time the shift from the original Reformed practice to our practice is either accepted without question or ignored. Sometimes we assume (as I did for a number of years) that our current practice is the historic practice. Sometimes, however, the original Reformed understanding of worship is ridiculed. One sees this in the discussion of the proper interpretation of the expression in Colossians 3:16 and Ephesians 5:18: “psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs.” The older Reformed writers tended to interpret this phrase as a reference to the 150 Psalms…
…The Reformers knew their history, that the early church accepted these principles and worshipped without musical instruments for the first 7 centuries—8 if we count the Apostolic church. They knew that the reintroduction of musical instruments mean the return to types and shadows, to the priesthood and that is exactly what happened. By the 9th century medieval theologians were theorizing about the transformation of the elements of the Supper into the body and blood of Christ. After that, increasingly ministers became regarded as priests who were making offerings. Indeed, by the 9th century the Holy Roman Emperor is increasingly being seen as a new Davidic king. What had expired on the cross was being resurrected and the church was returned to types and shadows. The Reformers rejected the new priesthood, the new (memorial, propitiatory) sacrifices just as they rejected the medieval neo-levitical reintroduction of instruments.”

Psalms, Hymns, Spiritual Songs, and Instruments In The Latin Bibles (2)
In short, the Reformed orthodox would not have understood the objection against interpreting Colossians 3 and Ephesians 5 against the background of the Psalter. In their minds, the two were bound together.
…Second, it would have been very difficult for the Reformed orthodox, for whom the Junius/Tremellius/Beza Latin Bible became the study Bible (apart from the original text), not to think of musical instruments as inextricably tied to the typological period of redemptive history and to the sacrificial ministry of the Levites. Where our translations sometimes encourage us to thing of a vocal choir, their translation encouraged them to think of the use of musical instruments in the psalms.
…It is useful to know that most (but not all!) of us no longer agree with our Reformed sources. We need to wrestle honestly with the facts. It is simply not satisfactory to say, “Well they were wrong.” That might be the case but we cannot simply assert that. We must show why they were wrong. Why were they wrong to read “psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs” in light of the superscriptions in the psalter? Why were they wrong to see the cultic (i.e., the use in public worship as distinct from the general, cultural) use of musical instruments as inextricably bound up with the types and shadows of the temporary, Israelite, national cultus and polity? It is an a fact of redemptive history that Levites played musical instruments so long as the burnt offerings were being made (2 Chron 29). They stopped with the sacrifices stopped. It is a fact of redemptive history that the same psalms that exhort us to dance and play musical instruments also exhort us to holy war against God’s national enemies.
When our theologies were being written and when our confessions were being framed, this was the understanding that informed them as they confessed that we may do in worship only that which God has commanded. In light of their understanding of redemptive history they removed instruments from the churches and sang only God’s Word (usually psalms) in response to God’s Word. They did not see musical instruments as circumstances. They saw them as elements just as the sacrifices were elements.

Podcast: Heidelcast: The Psalms in Worship and Living

Reading God’s Words or Man’s Words?

A Satirical Response to Mark Jones’s Post on the Reformation 21 Website Entitled:
“Singing God’s Words or Man’s Words?”

by Pastor Dave Reese (Springs Reformed Church, RPCNA)

Years ago I was asked the following question by someone who holds to exclusively using the Bible alone for public readings in worship: “Do you think it is better to read God’s words or man’s words?” My answer: we should never read man’s words. But I say this as someone who would read sections of great Christian literature as public readings in worship (i.e. Calvin’s Institutes).

As much as I love Douglas Bond novels or Eugene Peterson devotionals many Christian novels and inspirational books simply cannot be compared to God-breathed Scriptures! When I am depressed or miserable, I turn to the Bible. It is the marrow of my never-dying soul.

Nonetheless, with some trepidation, I believe that exclusively using the Bible for the public readings in worship has certain limitations. Believe me, you do not want to walk down a dark alley with a book by Francis Chan or the PCA’s BCO in your hand and bump into a couple of guys who hold that you should only be reading from the Bible in public worship! They are as zealous for the Bible in worship as the TRs in the PCA are for blue blazers and Banner of Truth conferences.

So are the inspired words of God in the books of the Bible to be preferred over man-made texts in corporate worship? Should we give up reading Into the Word in worship and replace it by just limiting ourselves to the Word?

Quite apart from the fact that many Christians in the past and present do not hold that you should use only the Bible for public readings in worship, I believe John Owen allows us to answer the first question I raised above in a manner that might enable those opposed to reading just the Bible in worship to understand why we have readings from other sources outside of the Bible.

We do not only believe that the Word of God is binding on us, but the inferences and meaning are also binding. Not only what the Scripture says, but also what it means is infallible.

Here is Owen’s argument:

“For if it is unlawful for me to speak or write what I conceive to be sense of the words of the Scripture, and the nature of the thing signified and expressed by them, it is unlawful for me, also, to think or conceive in my mind what is the sense of the words or nature of the things; which to say, is to make brutes of ourselves, and to frustrate the whole design of God in giving unto us the great privilege of his word.”

Thus, for Owen, as we declare the truth of the Trinity, “we may lawfully, nay, we must necessarily, make use of other words, phrases and expressions, than what are literally and syllabically contained in the Scripture, but teach no other things.”

Words such as “substance”, “essence”, “person”, and “trinity” are all words that are lawful to use. But Owen goes further. If these words convey the sense or meaning of the Scriptures, including the nature of God, may we express the truth of God in the following words, “God is one essence in three persons”? If so, then this sentence is God’s truth.

This is where Owen’s argument becomes hugely important:

“For howsoever the lines be drawn and extended, from truth nothing can follow and ensue but what is true also; and that in the same kind of truth with that which it is derived and deduced from. For if the principal assertion be a truth of divine revelation, so is also whatever is included therein, and which may be rightly from thence collected. Hence it follows, that when the Scripture reveals the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost to be one God, seeing it necessarily and unavoidably follows thereon that they are one in essence (wherein alone it is possible they can be one), and three in their distinct substances (wherein alone it is possible they can be three), this is no less a divine revelation than the first principle from whence these things follow.”

Those words, “this is no less a divine revelation than the first principle from whence these things follow,” are hugely significant for me in my own thinking about the way one does theology. Perhaps “divine truth” would be more appropriate than “divine revelation,” but I agree with his general point.

Are there readings that are divinely true because they convey the accurate meaning of God’s word? If they accurately capture the sense of Scripture then we are dealing with God’s truth, and not merely “man’s words.” The truth of God’s word gives rise to truth:

“I think God is really way bigger than all other powers in the whole wide world. I think He could snuff every bad guy on the planet if He wanted to right now. And Jesus is God also so He could too.”

Or:

“God is the holy Creator. He created donkeys and every rock that is in existence. He picked the color of the sky and therefore it is blue because He wanted it to be blue. Jesus and the Holy Spirit also participated in creation and they wanted to the sky to be blue also.”

What shall we say about these readings?

  1. Saying things like those that are said in the paragraphs above, which contain God’s truth (not merely man’s words) enables me to distance myself from a Jew or a Mormon who would likely read the Bible with me. But, they cannot affirm the last line of those two paragraphs above, which is why the Mormons have their own readings.
  1. Publicly reading things like Calvin’s Institutes provides the church with an excellent tool to convey, state, defend, and enjoy the truth of God’s word in a manner that even preaching and praying cannot. There is far less chance for error in selecting a biblically true section of Knowing God than a sermon and prayer. After all, how many “pastoral prayers” ask God to “just” do this or “just” do that, and then go on to ask a whole bunch of other things he can “just” do. And how many sermons are riddled with some interpretative error?
  1. I think we can refer to public readings of Antinomianism: Reformed Theology’s Unwelcomed Guest? during the worship service as reading the “words of God” on the same grounds that Paul referred to his own preaching as the word of God (1 Thess. 2:13).

Of course, there are words in many Christian books that are untrue. “Justified on the basis of the whole life lived” from the book, What Saint Paul Really Said is not read in our church. There are many imperfect older theological works and in modern Christian literature. Quite what “That isn’t to say my wife writes the pastoral prayers, by the way, since I allow myself to be ‘blown by the Spirit’” means, I have no idea. Good Morning, Holy Spirit by Benny Hinn has words that make me want to vomit. And John Owen’s point about the truths of Scripture being able to be stated in words other than biblical words: What does “this is no less a divine revelation than the first principle from whence these things follow,” mean? Theological statements are to give the true meaning of Scripture, not leave us needing another statement to interpret the statement.

Fortunately, I can deal with these errors by not allowing them in the order of worship. (That isn’t to say my wife writes the pastoral prayers, by the way, since I allow myself to be “blown by the Spirit”).

In summary, the first question raised above puts us on the horns of a false dilemma. The real question should be:

Must we confine ourselves to only God’s words in the public readings during worship or can we also read uninspired men’s writings, which articulate the true meaning of God’s words?

I’m off now to a worship service with my congregation in which I will read Morning and Evening, Pilgrim’s Progress, and Charles Hodge’s Systematic Theology as the “infallible”, “words of God” for the public readings (1 Tim. 4:13).