Owen on those who ‘do not hurt, though they do no good’

When men live to themselves, and are satisfied that they do no hurt, though they do no good; are secure, selfish, wrathful, angry, peevish, or have their kindness confined to their relations, or are otherwise little useful but in what they are pressed unto, and therein come off with difficulty in their own minds; who esteem all lost that is done for the relief of others, and the greatest part of wisdom to be cautious, and disbelieve the necessities of men; in a word, that make self and its concernments the end of their lives;—whatever otherwise their profession be, or their diligence in religious duties, they do very little either represent or glorify God in the world.

If we, therefore, design to be holy, let us constantly, in our families, towards our relations, in churches, in our conversation in the world, and dealings with all men; towards our enemies and persecutors, the worst of them, so far as they are ours only; towards all mankind as we have opportunity,—labour after conformity unto God, and to express our likeness unto him, in this philanthropy, goodness, benignity, condescension, readiness to forgive, to help and relieve; without which we neither are nor can be the children of our Father which is in heaven.

3:587-8.

An Introduction to John Owen

An Introduction to John Owen: a Christian vision for every stage of life
Crawford Gribben
Crossway, 2020

Do we need another book about John Owen on the Christian life you might ask? Sinclair Ferguson did it way back in 1987. Matthew Barrett and Michael Haykin did it as recently as 2015. To be honest, I was dubious – but watching an interview Crawford did with the Evangelical Bookshop in Belfast (above) convinced me.

Crawford is quickly becoming the world expert on Owen, and this book follows his 2016 John Owen and English Puritanism. He draws not only on Owen’s published works, but on manuscript sources, including notes of sermons – which give us gems like ‘Some say God kist his soule out’ (commenting on the death of Moses). An appendix includes a ‘Primer’ Owen published for children that wasn’t republished by Goold/Banner.

The main part of the book divides into four sections – Childhood, Youth, Middle Age and Death & Eternal Life. It gives a mix of biographical information on Owen (where we have it), as well as his teaching on each stage.

I always have a question mark as to whether I should read a book like this, or just read Owen himself. But this is the sort of book that gives you a taster of the broad sweep of someone’s writings and leaves you wanting to read more. One thing which might have helped familiarisation with Owen’s corpus was footnotes that referenced the title of the work cited, rather than simply what volume of his works they are found in. Curiously for books with the same author, one footnote (p. 128) reads ‘Quoted in Crawford Gribben, John Owen and English Puritanism‘.

At just over 150 pages long, the book is a quick and very enjoyable read – even if Crawford clearly enjoys trolling Presbyterians (especially on the section on baptism – including a couple of Owen’s very strong quotes in favour of paedobaptism from his Hebrews commentary might have provided a bit more balance).

The book serves as a fitting introduction to the forthcoming 30-volume critical edition of Owen’s works being prepared by Crossway (which Crawford says will have modernized language!)

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

The Holy Spirit (John Owen) 2018 Reading Plan

Last year’s Church of Christ reading plan proved pretty successful, so this year we’re going to give John Owen a go. 12.5 pages a week will take us through volume 3 (‘The Holy Spirit’) in a year.

Making a reading plan was a lot easier this year, as the pagination in Logos is the same as the Banner edition.

Again, I’m sharing it here in case anyone else wants to join in, or finds it useful at a later date.

You can download the reading plan here.

Whitla edits new Reformation Heritage Owen book

Reformation Heritage Books have just published a modernised version of John Owen’s Rules for Walking in Fellowship, edited by our very own David Whitla. (The original title was: Eshcol; A Cluster of the Fruit of Canaan, brought to the borders for the encouragement of the saints traveling thitherward, with their faces towards Zion or Rules of Direction for the Walking of the Saints in Fellowship According to the Order of the Gospel and is found in volume 13 of Owen’s works).

As Whitla writes in the introduction (PDF):

“It takes no great insight to discern that the biblical doctrine of the church has fallen on hard times. Several contemporary trends illustrate this. The church of the living God is no longer respected as “the house of God…the pillar and ground of the truth” (1 Tim. 3:15), but is instead redefined as an “emergent” phenomenon writing its own story. Many people exchange the ministerial authority of godly pastors and elders for the unaccountability of the home church or the well-meaning pursuit of an every-member ministry. They see making a commitment to a particular local congregation by vows of
church membership as an antiquated practice at best, and an infringement of Christian liberty at worst.

And yet, ironically, in this present atmosphere there is one aspect of the church that advocates of all these positions generally agree upon: that Christians ought to live in fellowship with one another. “Community” is a buzzword that finds ready expression in all parts of Western society, and yet the church is frequently assumed to be merely a voluntary society that one may drift in or out of, with no strings attached. How curious the assumption that the fellowship of the members of the body of Christ can take place in a dismembered body, eviscerated of the elemental structures of church government, church discipline, and church membership established by its glorious Head! It was not always so…”

Carl Trueman gives the following endorsement:

“Everything Owen wrote is worth reading, but some of his books are more accessible than others. This little practical treatise is a great way to meet a great Christian mind as it deals with the most basic elements of the Christian’s life in his church. I have loved reading Owen for nearly thirty years now and return to him again and again, never without profit. Enjoy this book. And learn from it.”

Reading God’s Words or Man’s Words?

A Satirical Response to Mark Jones’s Post on the Reformation 21 Website Entitled:
“Singing God’s Words or Man’s Words?”

by Pastor Dave Reese (Springs Reformed Church, RPCNA)

Years ago I was asked the following question by someone who holds to exclusively using the Bible alone for public readings in worship: “Do you think it is better to read God’s words or man’s words?” My answer: we should never read man’s words. But I say this as someone who would read sections of great Christian literature as public readings in worship (i.e. Calvin’s Institutes).

As much as I love Douglas Bond novels or Eugene Peterson devotionals many Christian novels and inspirational books simply cannot be compared to God-breathed Scriptures! When I am depressed or miserable, I turn to the Bible. It is the marrow of my never-dying soul.

Nonetheless, with some trepidation, I believe that exclusively using the Bible for the public readings in worship has certain limitations. Believe me, you do not want to walk down a dark alley with a book by Francis Chan or the PCA’s BCO in your hand and bump into a couple of guys who hold that you should only be reading from the Bible in public worship! They are as zealous for the Bible in worship as the TRs in the PCA are for blue blazers and Banner of Truth conferences.

So are the inspired words of God in the books of the Bible to be preferred over man-made texts in corporate worship? Should we give up reading Into the Word in worship and replace it by just limiting ourselves to the Word?

Quite apart from the fact that many Christians in the past and present do not hold that you should use only the Bible for public readings in worship, I believe John Owen allows us to answer the first question I raised above in a manner that might enable those opposed to reading just the Bible in worship to understand why we have readings from other sources outside of the Bible.

We do not only believe that the Word of God is binding on us, but the inferences and meaning are also binding. Not only what the Scripture says, but also what it means is infallible.

Here is Owen’s argument:

“For if it is unlawful for me to speak or write what I conceive to be sense of the words of the Scripture, and the nature of the thing signified and expressed by them, it is unlawful for me, also, to think or conceive in my mind what is the sense of the words or nature of the things; which to say, is to make brutes of ourselves, and to frustrate the whole design of God in giving unto us the great privilege of his word.”

Thus, for Owen, as we declare the truth of the Trinity, “we may lawfully, nay, we must necessarily, make use of other words, phrases and expressions, than what are literally and syllabically contained in the Scripture, but teach no other things.”

Words such as “substance”, “essence”, “person”, and “trinity” are all words that are lawful to use. But Owen goes further. If these words convey the sense or meaning of the Scriptures, including the nature of God, may we express the truth of God in the following words, “God is one essence in three persons”? If so, then this sentence is God’s truth.

This is where Owen’s argument becomes hugely important:

“For howsoever the lines be drawn and extended, from truth nothing can follow and ensue but what is true also; and that in the same kind of truth with that which it is derived and deduced from. For if the principal assertion be a truth of divine revelation, so is also whatever is included therein, and which may be rightly from thence collected. Hence it follows, that when the Scripture reveals the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost to be one God, seeing it necessarily and unavoidably follows thereon that they are one in essence (wherein alone it is possible they can be one), and three in their distinct substances (wherein alone it is possible they can be three), this is no less a divine revelation than the first principle from whence these things follow.”

Those words, “this is no less a divine revelation than the first principle from whence these things follow,” are hugely significant for me in my own thinking about the way one does theology. Perhaps “divine truth” would be more appropriate than “divine revelation,” but I agree with his general point.

Are there readings that are divinely true because they convey the accurate meaning of God’s word? If they accurately capture the sense of Scripture then we are dealing with God’s truth, and not merely “man’s words.” The truth of God’s word gives rise to truth:

“I think God is really way bigger than all other powers in the whole wide world. I think He could snuff every bad guy on the planet if He wanted to right now. And Jesus is God also so He could too.”

Or:

“God is the holy Creator. He created donkeys and every rock that is in existence. He picked the color of the sky and therefore it is blue because He wanted it to be blue. Jesus and the Holy Spirit also participated in creation and they wanted to the sky to be blue also.”

What shall we say about these readings?

  1. Saying things like those that are said in the paragraphs above, which contain God’s truth (not merely man’s words) enables me to distance myself from a Jew or a Mormon who would likely read the Bible with me. But, they cannot affirm the last line of those two paragraphs above, which is why the Mormons have their own readings.
  1. Publicly reading things like Calvin’s Institutes provides the church with an excellent tool to convey, state, defend, and enjoy the truth of God’s word in a manner that even preaching and praying cannot. There is far less chance for error in selecting a biblically true section of Knowing God than a sermon and prayer. After all, how many “pastoral prayers” ask God to “just” do this or “just” do that, and then go on to ask a whole bunch of other things he can “just” do. And how many sermons are riddled with some interpretative error?
  1. I think we can refer to public readings of Antinomianism: Reformed Theology’s Unwelcomed Guest? during the worship service as reading the “words of God” on the same grounds that Paul referred to his own preaching as the word of God (1 Thess. 2:13).

Of course, there are words in many Christian books that are untrue. “Justified on the basis of the whole life lived” from the book, What Saint Paul Really Said is not read in our church. There are many imperfect older theological works and in modern Christian literature. Quite what “That isn’t to say my wife writes the pastoral prayers, by the way, since I allow myself to be ‘blown by the Spirit’” means, I have no idea. Good Morning, Holy Spirit by Benny Hinn has words that make me want to vomit. And John Owen’s point about the truths of Scripture being able to be stated in words other than biblical words: What does “this is no less a divine revelation than the first principle from whence these things follow,” mean? Theological statements are to give the true meaning of Scripture, not leave us needing another statement to interpret the statement.

Fortunately, I can deal with these errors by not allowing them in the order of worship. (That isn’t to say my wife writes the pastoral prayers, by the way, since I allow myself to be “blown by the Spirit”).

In summary, the first question raised above puts us on the horns of a false dilemma. The real question should be:

Must we confine ourselves to only God’s words in the public readings during worship or can we also read uninspired men’s writings, which articulate the true meaning of God’s words?

I’m off now to a worship service with my congregation in which I will read Morning and Evening, Pilgrim’s Progress, and Charles Hodge’s Systematic Theology as the “infallible”, “words of God” for the public readings (1 Tim. 4:13).

Owen Goal

Reformation 21 have added quite a few new authors recently, which has resulted in an increase in the number of posts, if not in quality. Bucking the trend however has been Mark Jones. After a slightly embarrassing early post in which he claimed to be a football fan but talked about the ‘FIFA’ World Cup, his contributions have been top notch.

That is, until the other day when he posted what I would lovingly and respectfully call unadulterated twaddle – arguing that the fact that something you’re singing is true means it makes the song ‘God’s Words’. I was just going to leave it as another example of people who should know better embarrassing themselves when trying to argue against Exclusive Psalmody. However a former classmate emailed me the link the other day with the subject ‘Shall We Sing must respond!’ – so how could I resist?!

Rather than attempting to take such a gifted theologian to task on something like the doctrine of Scripture, I’ll just give John Owen himself the chance to respond. After all, we all know it’s a schoolboy error to try and take something someone has said in another context and quote them against themselves.

Starting at the end, Jones finishes with the cheap dig: “I’m off now to sing with my family psalms, psalms, and psalms (Col. 3:16)”. Ironically, by doing this he’s actually having a go not primarily at poor, maligned C21st exclusive psalmists, but some obscure C17th century figures. In fact, some of them signed their names to a document for such a time as this – including a Mr Thomas Manton, Thomas Watson, Matthew Poole, Thomas Vincent, Edmund Calamdy…and a certain John Owen, D. D. They say:

“Now though spiritual songs of mere human composure may have their use, yet our devotion is best secured, where the matter & words are of immediately Divine inspiration; and to us David’s Psalms seem plainly intended by those terms of Psalms and Hymns and Spiritual Songs, which the Apostle useth, Ephes. 5.19. Col.3.16.”

preface to smv - owen watson etc big - rouse 1673
Preface to a 1673 edition of the Scottish Metrical Version

In one sentence Owen et al destroy both Jones’s attempt to put uninspired hymns on the same level as the psalms, and state that the interpretation he mocks is the one they see as ‘plainly intended’ by the Apostle Paul. Oh dear.

Just in case we feel that Owen was giving in to peer pressure there, I’ll post some relevant quotations from his own Works later.