The censuring of corrupt unsent Ministers, is a most difficult task, what from their nature, and sometimes from their parts; what from the addictednesse of many unto them. Yet it is a speciall duty: and although it be often difficult to follow, and be mistaken by many others; Yet that it’s acceptable before Jesus Christ, may appear from these considerations:
1. That the Scripture holdeth forth no kind of persons as more abominable in themselves, and more hatefull to Him; for which cause, they are called dogs, and dumb dogs that cannot bark, Isa. 56:10. Salt without favour, wolves, idol shepherds, such as feed themselves, and kill his flock, blind guids, &c. Hence it is that there are not more sad expostulations with complaints of, or threatnings pronounced against any, than against these: Our blessed Lord Jesus multiplies woes unto such in a more terrible manner than was usuall to Him, Mat. 23.
2. There is no kind of persons that prove more dishonourable to our Lord Jesus, and to His Gospel than such: these make the Law to be despised, Mal. 2 and the Sacrifices and Ordinances to be counted vile and contemptible, 1 Sam. 2. Such especially open the mouths of profane men against Religion, and the Author thereof, and exceedingly derogate from the authority of Him they pretend to have sent them, and to the Ambassage they are sent with, while as they look so unlike Him. And upon this account it is amongst others, that luch particular directions for the singular qualifying of Church-Officers, are given in Scripture: and the censuring of such, and that by Christs own Authority, vindicateth Him, which cannot be but honourable and acceptable to Him.
3. The scandalous miscarriages and unfaithfulnesse of Ministers bring a speciall blot upon all Religion, as if it were but meer hypocrisie and tended to the fostering of such ills: and profane men are exceedingly strengthened in such Atheisticall apprehensions, when these ills are not taken notice of, and censured by Church-Authority: Whereas by this severity in the exercise of Discipline, the faults are seen to be in persons and not in Religion, or the Ordinances thereof.
4. There is no such contempt done to our Lord Jesus, as for one to pretend to have Commission from Him; and yet to be running unsent by Him; or, having gotten Commission, to miscarry by unfaithfulnesse init: this is a betraying of trust, and cannot but be looked on as a high contempt against Him.
5. As there is a suitablenesse in the censuring of such Church-officers to Christs mind, so there doth appear in the same attenderness of, and zeal unto His Glory. Hence it is, that His most zealous. servants, as Elias, Paul, (yea, and Himself when on earth) did set themselves most against that generation.
6. There is no sort of men more hurtfull to the Church, by obstructing Christs end in His Ordinances, to wit, the edification of His People: for, such profit them not at all, Jer. 23 yea, they stand in the way of their profiting, sometimes by corrupt Doctrine; sometimes by example; sometimes by sadning and weakening of these who look more tenderly to the practice of Godlinesse: and if no other way; yet by filling the room, and so standing in the way of the peoples being provided with such as might be helpfull and faithful. Now, considering the great respect that our Lord Jesus hath to the edification of His People; and considering the weight that He hath placed upon this Ministery, as a mean for promoving of that end, and with all, the great obstruction that followes to that end, when this mean disappoints. It cannot but be accounted acceptable to Him to remove such an obstruction.
Yea, 7. Considering that there is nothing He commends more than mutuall love to His Disciples, and there is nothing wherein love can appear more to them, than in seeking their spirituall edification, which was that wherein His own love eminently kythed; and there is nothing wherein this kind of love kythes more to Him or them, than that they be fed with knowledge and understanding by Pastors according to His own heart, according to His word to Peter, Peter, loves thou me? then feed my lambs: it cannot therefore but be looked on by Him as acceptable service. And indeed, if it be commendable to relive a neighbours beast from hazard, when there is a slothfull shepherd; or to relieve the bodily life from temporall hazard, how much more must it be commendable to prevent the eternall hazard of immortall souls, which by corrupt Ministers cannot but be in hazard?
8. There is nothing that more rejoyceth and hardneth corrupt men, than when they are like People, like Priest, and have Pastors according to their own heart; and there is nothing that they are more provoked and displeased with, than the censuring of such: yea, even men who have no respect almost to Religion at all, yet abhorr and oppose the censuring of such, as if it were a peece of Religion (or rather of opposition to Religion) to do so; which certainly sheweth that the following of this triall, must be a main furtherance to Godlinesse, and cometh near the Kingdom of Christ.
9. Not only if there an obstruction to Godlinesse by such, but they have a main influence upon the advancing of propnanity, and the kingdom of the devil, as if professedly they had confederated with him against Christ. Hence it’s said, that from them doth prophanity go out to the whole Land, Jer. 23. And they are called Ministers of Satan, 2 Cor. 11 as Ambassadors employed by him in his service And where it’s thus, not only are scandalous practices committed, but avowed, as it were in contempt of Godlinesse, and of faithfull Ministers, who seriously study the promoving of it. Hence it is, that often there is a kind of started enimity against faithfulnesse and faithfull men, not only amongst such Ministers themselves, but in their Congregations and Followers, which sheweth the prejudice that cometh by them, and so the necessity of removing them.
It may now look like cruelty (it may be) rigidly to pursue such, and like pity to spare them which may much be applauded unto by many: yet is we could consider what hazard may come to immortall souls in a short time by the want of a powerfull Ministery, much more by the having of corrupt men, either in Life or Doctrine in that station, and what thoughts souls will have of that cruel pity in the day of Judgement: we are perswaded horrour would affect the hearts of those who are concerned; considering how many are palpably in hazard through defect in this: Can it be thought that Christs ordaining of a Ministery was only to have men bearing such a name, and not to have such as effectually and seriously would promove His design? and can that be expected, whilst men unfit for it, or unworthy of that calling possesse the room? and if it be a deplorable condition to have Congregations desolate without the Ordinances, and living like Heathens, or as sheep without a Shepherd, or blind men without a Guide, is it any lesse, yea, is it not much more lamentable to have such as rather marr than further the man design? which breedeth confidence and security in some naturall men, occasioneth prophanity and loosnesse in others, and almost serveth to no end, but to keep such a Congregation from one that may guide them, and them from knowing their want, or hazard: and in sum to obstruct, and put in a non-entry, their edification, more than is none were there at all; for, Christs way appointed for edifying of His Church, is not only to have the form or Ordinances, by men supplying these places; but to have such as may by His approbation follow His way of attaining his end. We conceive that the regulating of the entry of Church-officers, so may none but such as are thereby approven may be admitted, and of the tryall of these who are in, that such who carry themselves unworthily maybe removed, is one of the main ends why Church-authority is given by Jesus Christ for the edification of His Body, as the speciall directions to Timothy and Titus, which do regulate Church-officers, especially in the admission and accusation of Elders, do demonstrate; and if this main point be neglected by Church-officers, it may justly provoke God to weaken, if not to break that Authority to them, and to make them and it in their hands justly to become despiseable, which nothing furthers more than the admitting and permitting of corrupt and unmeet Officers to be in the Church. And if people delight to have it so, and fret at anything which may amend it, much more if they affect the continuance thereof, and concur to the supporting, of such, it may be that the Lord give them a fill of their own wayes; and by errour, contusion, or some other way, so bring it about in his just Judgement, that either they shall have no face of Ordinances at all, or have the carcasse of them as a snare and a curse unto them, who received not the love of the Truth, that they might be saved, but contented themselves to have the shape and form of Christ’s Ordinances only among them without respect to the end for which He appointed them. That zealous and pungent discourse, which Mr. Baxter hath to this purpose in the close of his Agreement, is most weighty and convincing; and the matter thereof, so far as concerns this, worthy to be considered. All which is still to be understood of such legall trialls as are followed on solide grounds, and in an orderly circumspect manner; for such was this triall of the false Apostles, by the Angel or Elders of the Church of Ephesus, which usually is cited by Divines to confirm the power of the Church in censuring her Officers.
James Durham – Commentary on Revelation [2:1-3]