The Pastor’s Justification (book review)

The Pastor’s Justification: Applying the Work of Christ in Your Life and Ministry
Jared C. Wilson
Crossway, 2013

pastors justification

I would probably have given this book a miss if Mez McConnell hadn’t listed it as his top book of 2014 and said ‘It should be required reading for seminary students’. As the subtitle says, Wilson’s aim is to apply the truth of who we are in Christ to all aspects of ministry. In doing so he seeks to save pastors from self-pity and bitterness at one extreme and pride and self-sufficiency at the other. It’s a refreshing read, but will make you wince at times – many of the negative tendencies he picks out are all too close to home. The first half of the book, on ‘The Pastor’s Heart’, is especially helpful. Wilson writes powerfully and is eminently quotable. On what prayerlessness says about us: ‘Prayer is essentially acknowledged helplessness’. On the importance of theology: ‘A pastor not interested in theology is like a computer programmer not interested in technology’. On those who complain about church discipline: ‘We do not say to a surgeon that he is harming a body by cutting a tumour out of it’.
In the second half of the books he applies the Five Solas to ministry. This part isn’t perhaps as consistently strong, and occasionally repeats things already covered in the first section, but is still very helpful.
Overall this is an honestly written, realistic yet hope-filled and encouraging book, which would doubtless be helpful both to seminary students and those in ministry. Nor is it just a book to be read once, because we’re always in need of the gospel that it seeks to bring home to the ministry setting. It lifts the broken and brings down the proud becomes it reminds us that it’s not about us and our personal success or failure – it’s all about Jesus. As Wilson concludes: ‘Let’s pastor in this reality, brothers, until our hearts burst with joy.’

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

Paul Tripp – New Morning Mercies (book review)

New Morning Mercies: A Daily Gospel Devotional
Paul David Tripp
Crossway, 2014 (IVP in the UK)

fesko theology of the westminster standards

If you’re looking for a devotional book for the New Year, it’s worth checking out Paul Tripp’s New Morning Mercies.

These devotions started off as tweets from Tripp that others saw and encouraged him to do something with. Each day starts with a lightly edited tweet-length thought, and then a 2/3 of a page meditation based on it. The book is classic Tripp – focusing not on the surface problems of our lives, but the underlying thoughts and attitudes at the root of them. Each day’s devotion ends with a Bible reference the reader can look up for further study and encouragement. The majority of these are from the New Testament, though Isaiah, and especially the Psalms, feature heavily too.

The short length of each day’s reading makes this book an ideal pump-primer before coming to God’s Word. The book is published by IVP in the UK, whose blurb states: ‘Focused less on behaviour modification and more on helping people encounter the living God’. That dichotomy may not be the most helpful in light of the recent debates on sanctification and antinomianism (with the man at the heart of it, Tullian Tchividjian, providing an endorsement of the book), but given his counselling role, we can be sure that Tripp’s concern is that as people encounter the living God each day, it would lead to changed lives.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

The Theology of the Westminster Standards (book review)

The Theology of the Westminster Standards: Historical Context and Theological Insights
J. V. Fesko
Crossway, 2014

fesko theology of the westminster standards

Those wanting to study the Westminster Standards in their historical context are living at an exciting time. The publication of Chad Van Dixhoorn’s monumental Minutes and Papers of the Westminster Assembly, 1643-1652 has been accompanied by 3 new series of books from Reformation Heritage: The Westminster Assembly Principle Documents series, Studies on the Westminster Assembly Series (the initial publications of which are by Wayne Spear and John Bower of the RPCNA) and The Westminster Assembly Facsimile Series. Making use of those, along with many of the primary sources now so easily available online, comes John Valero Fesko’s The Theology of the Westminster Standards (released just a month or so before Van Dixhoorn’s own Confessing the Faith).

Fesko’s thesis is that while there is still a lot of use made of, and commentaries published on the Westminster Standards, much of this study is divorced from their seventeenth century historical context. Even having the minutes is not enough as ‘the Westminster Assembly was part of a broader ongoing conversation with Patristic, medieval, Reformation and contemporary’ theologians. Fesko contends that there is no way one book could properly contextualise every part of the confession, so he picks out ten key themes such as the Doctrine of Scripture, Justification and the Church – and aims to inspire others to do more. His thesis serves as an important reminder not just to read the Standards and assume that how we use certain terms, or understand certain concepts, is the same way the Divines used them and understood them. The negative side of this is that if certain statements are unpalatable to the modern reader, Fesko can just write them off as an inevitable result of the historical context. This doesn’t happen much, but repeatedly comes up in regard to the teaching that the Pope is the anti-Christ, and at the expense of Fesko discussing any of the exegesis that got them there.

Rather than being the straitjacket they are often portrayed as, Fesko also does a good job of showing how Confessions of faith were ‘typically written to define truth and fence of heterodoxy and heresy while allowing a degree of doctrinal latitude within the boundaries of the confession’. Some of these are so obvious that they don’t really need much context to explain, but it does helps to see not just what we do believe but what we don’t.

The chapter on ‘Worship’ contains a couple of disappointments. Firstly, while Fesko includes some quotes as to the divines’ belief that the Lord’s Day is permanent and moral, he doesn’t give any of their arguments and rather brushes over a topic sorely needing more attention in a book written primarily for a North American audience. His sections on Psalmody and Instruments are particularly poor. He seems to list Calvin as an advocate of uninspired songs (unsupported by the footnotes he provides). He also fails to provide much support for his contention that while ‘At first glance the Confession appears to support the views of exclusive psalmody’, it actually doesn’t. While quoting David Dickson arguing for exclusive psalmody, he doesn’t reference any divine who didn’t, and the only scholarship he can point to is Nick Needham’s attempt to prove the divines weren’t against hymns and instruments, which has been refuted by Matthew Winzer. When it comes to instruments, Fesko can only muster a paragraph, which claims that the issue of musical instruments was ‘apparently avoided’ by the Standards! Again the only ‘scholarship’ he can cite is Needham, and the only theologian he can list in favour of instruments is the Jesuit Robert Bellarmine. Finally, Fesko’s section on ‘two kingdoms’ in his section on ‘The Church’ should probably be read with caution, not just because he comes from Westminster Seminary California, but because of his reliance on the work of his colleague David VanDrunen.

For all the recent resources Fesko has utilised, he seem to be unaware of the newer Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (2004), but relies on its predecessor which was published over a century earlier, leaving him unnecessarily scratching his head occasionally (eg p. 59, n. 73). While his annotated bibliography mentions the fact that PDFs of primary sources can be downloaded to your computer or tablet from the PRDL, he doesn’t mention that a number of works he lists can also be downloaded in a much more readable and searchable format from Logos Bible Software.

Those caveats aside, Fesko succeeds not just in providing an illuminating book for those with an interest in historical theology, but in showing that any serious study of these important documents must be done with the historical context in mind. Thanks to the resources that have become available over the last few years, it has never been easier to do so.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

Taking God at His Word (book review)

Taking God at His Word: Why the Bible Is Knowable, Necessary, and Enough, and What That Means for You and Me
Kevin DeYoung
Crossway, 2014 (looks to be published by IVP in the UK – with a much worse cover!)

taking God at his word

There was a lot of hype over this book when it came out in April – and I’m glad to say that on this occasion it was justified! If you looked at the price (£8.99 on Amazon) you might think this was a normal-sized book, but in actual fact it’s only 130 pages (including a helpful annotated bibliography) . The book’s brevity is one of its strengths though – this is the sort of book that, as Don Carson notes on the back, is worth buying ‘by the case’ and giving away. It would be great for going through with a new/young Christian to ground them in the importance of the Bible.
DeYoung starts where he wants to end with Psalm 119 – a love poem to the Bible. After two introductory chapters he uses the acronym SCAN to set the agenda for the rest of the book – showing the Sufficiency (which he notes evangelicals particularly struggle with), Clarity, Authority and Necessity of the Scriptures. He notes that our attitude to the Bible doesn’t just affect what we read but what we sing and in light of all this he asks ‘Why would we sing songs bereft of biblical substance?’. In a healthy corrective to many current views on what a ‘spiritual’ person is, he shows that true spirituality is to be rooted in the Bible. DeYoung is unswayed by Higher Criticism, which he summarises well. He notes in a chapter on Jesus attitude to Scripture that if Jesus handled the Bible in a certain way then ‘boatloads of higher biblical criticism must be wrong’. Even on areas some evangelicals have capitulated on like the historicity of Jonah, DeYoung stands firm. He has a great quote from T. T. Perowne about imaginary people repenting at the preaching of an imaginary prophet rising up to condemn Jesus’ actual hearers.
His final chapter, encouraging us to ‘Stick with the Scriptures’, is covenantal and brilliant. He reminds us that we’ll not just face attacks on the Scriptures from outside but will be tempted to unbelief ourselves. He attributes holding onto his own faith at a liberal college to the grounding he had received from his parents – and the chapter is a great encouragement for today’s parents to do the same. Finally, how could I not love a book in which he call us to get ‘rid, once and for all, of this “red letter nonsense”‘ which he describes as incompatible with an evangelical understanding of inspiration.
Satan will never stop attacking the doctrine of Scripture so this is a book to read regularly and to give to others.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

The Final Days of Jesus (book review)

The Final Days of Jesus: The Most Important Week of the Most Important Person Who Ever Lived
Andreas J. Köstenberger and Justin Taylor, with Alexander Stewart
Crossway, 2014

Of all the weeks that have been lived out on this earth, it doesn’t get any more significant than the last week of Jesus Christ on the earth. Taking that as their focus, Andreas Köstenberger and Justin Taylor have come up with a great title for a great concept – which is just a little lacking in the execution.
The book’s real strength is its harmonisation of the gospel accounts of the last week of Jesus’ (they would add an extra ‘s’) life, beginning on 29 March, 33 AD. It is a difficult task to try and sit down and work out exactly what happened in what order, so if you want to get the events straight in your head, this is a great resource. It is also helpful in explaining apparent contradictions between the different gospel accounts. The authors bring commentary-level detail but without the technical language. By doing so they bring out important details that it would be easy to miss in your own Bible reading, such as the fact that Jesus cursing the fig tree is not as random as it may first appear but ‘symbolizes the judgment of God upon a nation that has the outward appearance of life but fails to bear fruit’.
In an interview about the book, the authors said that they were trying to transcend any conflict between the academic or devotional and in the book itself they state that their aim is ‘to provide an aid to informed worship’. It’s a great aim to have, however I felt that the emphasis of the book still lay more on the ‘informed’ than the ‘worship’. Furthermore, on the academic level, the reader may be left feeling slightly uncomfortable with their somewhat dispensational approach to the Holy Spirit and the Old Testament. In the most blatant example of this, they state that the 11 disciples (apart from Judas) were converted ‘though not yet regenerated’ during Jesus’ final week. This is a position, which John Piper in another context calls ‘theologically impossible’. Elsewhere they state that ‘No one at that time could possibly comprehend’ that there was a third outcome possible for Jesus than earthly rule or death. While it’s true that no-one at the time did comprehend it, Jesus’ disciples are rebuked for their failure to do so a number of times in Luke 24.
Those quibbles aside, this is still a very helpful book which is given added value by some very useful charts, maps and diagrams. It will certainly be my go-to resource if I’m struggling to remember just how all the events of that momentous week fit together.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

How to stay Christian in Seminary (review)

How to Stay Christian in Seminary
David Mathis and Jonathan Parnell
Crossway, 2014

If the title of this book might have sounded over-dramatic to me 3 years ago, it just seems grimly realistic now. Theological education (especially full time) is a great privilege, but it also comes with unique challenges. And that’s the case even in a conservative, orthodox theological college. Being immersed day in, day out in the things of God is an amazing opportunity – but it can easily stay in the realm of the theoretical. Translation, essays and exams can become just another thing you have to get done. As Mathis and Parnell note in the introduction, “students’ heads often pick up on theology faster than their hearts and lives”. If we don’t live out what we’re learning (whether we’re in the pew or the seminary classroom) it can lead to, as one commentator puts it, ‘a toxic build-up of religious knowledge’.
This 80 page book aims to help seminary students fight that danger. In the forward, John Piper identifies this toxic danger and exhorts theological students to give out what they learn. It’s an age-old danger of the 3 year academic approach – taking men out of contexts where they’re already ministering to teach them how to minister better. Perhaps we should be asking not just ‘Are our students learning the right things?’, but ‘In what contexts are they putting it into practice?’
In chapter 2 Mathis takes on another key danger: ‘At the heart of the danger of seminary is coming to treat the grace of God lightly’. The answer, for seminarians and everyone else, is to ‘Be fascinated with grace’. Like all the chapters, it’s brief and can only flag up the problem and point to some correctives. But the chapters can be taken as jumping-off points. Perhaps a student could take one a week and pray over it. As there are only 7 chapters an oversight committee could work through one with their students each time they meet both during the college years and prior to licensing. The next chapters address the very practical issue of daily Bible intake and the central issue of prayer. Our chief goal, Parnell reminds us, isn’t to complete assignments and get through books, but to encounter God.
Chapter 5 is a call, based on Piper’s exhortation to his students to ‘be more like John Newton than John Knox’, to remember that Jesus calls the weak. We fall into thinking that somehow theological education makes us stronger and better – but in fact we should always be amazed that God could use someone weak like us. Piper’s comparison may grate slightly with those who hold the Scottish Reformation in the regard that we do – but the overall point holds. Don’t make the mistake of regarding seminary graduates as anything other than deeply flawed individuals God may have chosen to use.
The exhortation of the penultimate chapter to ‘Be a real husband and dad’ is vital. One area which is conspicuous by its absence however is the role of the church. I didn’t expect anything on the role of the Presbytery/denomination given where the authors are coming from, but I would have expected a chapter on the importance of remaining rooted in the local church.
This is still an excellent, and probably unique, book. It should be absolutely essential reading for theological students – and of course the dangers associated with handling God’s word full-time don’t magically end at ordination. And if you’re just a normal Christian who wants to know how better to pray for your theological students – this short book would be a great place to go.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.