Luther on the Christian life (book review)

Luther on the Christian Life: Cross and Freedom
Carl Trueman
Crossway, 2015

Carl Trueman, the author of the latest in Crossway’s Theologians on the Christian Life series has, as he notes in the conclusion, spent his entire professional life reading and teaching Luther. Yet he has done so from a Reformed, rather than a Lutheran position, and in this book clearly relishes the challenge he has set himself to write with fairness and enthusiasm about someone with whom he disagrees.
Unlike Dane Ortlund’s very different book in the series on Edwards, Trueman sets Luther firmly in his historical context – showing what he took from it, as well as what he reacted against. One of the strengths of the book is that Trueman resists the pressure to try and turn Luther into a 21st century evangelical, and is at pains to show that on certain doctrines, especially the Lord’s Supper, Luther would struggle to recognise modern evangelicals as even Christian.
For preachers, the treatment in chapter 3 on Luther’s theology of the Word preached is a breath of fresh air. Trueman notes Luther’s ‘lasting hatred of anyone who talked about the Spirit rather than the Word’. For Luther, ‘the absence of God’s Word is the absence of God’ – and it’s no coincidence that in the Garden of Eden Satan attacked God’s word, because to do so is to strike at the character and power of God. Luther’s emphasis on the power of the preached Word wasn’t just because he lived in a largely illiterate culture, but because the Word mediated via another from outside ‘confronts me in a way that my own Bible reading can never do’.
The treatment of Luther on law and gospel is also very helpful. One interesting titbit hidden away in a footnote on Luther’s interpretation of the Bible is that although Luther is known as taking a more Christ-centred approach to the psalms than Calvin (and most moderns), he actually claimed to be breaking with all previous commentators by not seeing the psalms as first and foremost prayers offered by Christ.
Although the book would stand up as a rigorously academic treatment, its not just for theologians but for the ordinary person (Luther, by the way, saw the sacred secular divide as ‘pure invention’ – yet at the same time his teaching on the priesthood of believers didn’t mean ministers were now unnecessary). There is much that’s helpful when it comes to suffering. In one memorable illustration, Luther describes Christians complaining about minor suffering as ‘like a king who becomes frantic because he loses one pfennig [one-hundredth of a German mark]. Though he owns half the world, with countless money and possessions, he plays the martyr, throws a tantrum, curses, denounces God, and fulminates against Him’. In fact, the purpose of suffering is to drive anger, impatience and unrest out of someone until he reaches ‘such a pitch of peace…that he is no longer upset whether things go well or ill with him, whether he lives or dies, whether he is honoured or dishonoured’.
There is much here for doubting believers as well. The devil’s favourite tactic, according to Luther, is to make them doubt God’s favour. In complete contrast to the common idea that the Lord’s Supper is only for those who have it all together, for Luther communion is of little or no benefit to those who come without anxiety, timid hearts or terrified consciences.
One particular highlight is the section on the family, where Trueman shows how Luther’s theology affected his relationships with his wife and children. The evidence surely justifies Trueman’s conclusion that from such a study Luther emerges ‘as no less a great figure than his public ministry showed him to be, but as far more human’.
It is perhaps above all the humanity of Luther that comes across in this book. His was no ivory tower theology that didn’t touch down on real life – whether his own or his barber for whom he wrote a treatise on prayer. Nor was Luther a theologian who took himself too seriously. In a modern setting where people are all too quick to be ‘hurt’ or offended, ‘Luther’s robust mockery of pretension and pomposity is a remarkable theological contribution in and of itself’. Even if he sometimes had to be reproved by his wife.
Throughout the book Trueman criticises modern evangelicals for quoting the early Luther but ignoring the changes his theology underwent during his last 25 years. However although he seems in one place to have his sights firmly set on a Tullian Tchividjian’s book by the same name, his statement that ‘Jesus plus nothing was proving to be problematic’ is perhaps not the most helpful.
Those who have read or listened to Trueman on Luther before will find here much that is familiar, but this is still a great study on a magisterial figure who has much to teach us today.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

William Barclay (1907-1978) on J. P. Struthers

J P Struthers

Part 1 (of 2) in a series on what some of Scotland’s better known (if not the most robustly orthodox) theologians of the last 150 years or so made of J. P. Struthers (1851-1915) of Greenock. Struthers, through no fault of his own, is probably the only RP ever to have a Pentecostal denomination named after him!

“There have been many who have sacrificed their careers to what they took to be the will of God. J. P. Struthers was the minister of the Reformed Presbyterian Church in Greenock, a little congregation which, it is neither false nor unkind to say, had a great past but no future. Had he been willing to forsake this church, any pulpit in the land was open to him and the most dazzling ecclesiastical rewards were his; but he sacrificed them all for the sake of what he considered to be loyalty to God’s will.”
The New Daily Study Bible: The Letter to the Hebrews, (3rd edn, Louisville, KY; London: Westminster John Knox Press, 2002), p. 179

“Prestige is the last thing that the great teachers desire. J. P. Struthers was a saint of God. He spent all his life in the service of the little Reformed Presbyterian Church when he could have occupied any pulpit in Britain. People loved him, and the better they knew him the more they loved him. Two men were talking of him. One man knew all that Struthers had done, but did not know Struthers personally. Remembering Struthers’ saintly ministry, he said: ‘Struthers will have a front seat in the kingdom of heaven.’ The other had known Struthers personally, and his answer was: ‘Struthers would be miserable in a front seat anywhere.’ There are some teachers and preachers who use their message as a setting for themselves. False prophets are interested in self-display; true prophets desire self-obliteration.”
The New Daily Study Bible: The Gospel of Matthew (3rd edn, Edinburgh: Saint Andrew Press, 2001), pp 328-9.

“Real Christianity is a lovely thing. There are so many people who are good but who with their goodness possess a streak of unlovely hardness. J. P. Struthers, minister of the Reformed Presbyterian church in Greenock, used to say that it would help the Church more than anything else if Christians would from time to time do a bonnie thing. In the early Church, there was a charm about God’s people.”
The New Daily Study Bible: The Acts of the Apostles, (3rd edn, Louisville, KY; London: Westminster John Knox Press, 2003), p. 34

Gartmore 2014 videos

Larry Gladfelter has uploaded some videos from Gartmore 2014 – with lots more available to buy (Kenny Stewart’s talks, the Concert & Conference Reflections). Larry can be contacted via Facebook or on larry.gladfelter at gmail dot com. Here are some of the free ones:

Lord’s Day – Morning Worship

Lord’s Day – Evening Worship

Conventicle at the Grassmarket

Global Panel

Seminar: To the Least of These – Peter & Emma Loughridge

Seminar: Home is where the heart is – Carine McKenzie

Seminar: Media Addiction – Joel Loughridge

Edwards on the Christian Life (book review)

Edwards on the Christian Life: Alive to the Beauty of God
Dane C. Ortlund
Crossway, 2014

ortlund edwards

‘If all we know of Van Gogh’, writes Dane Ortlund, ‘is what we read in art history books without ever actually viewing a Van Gogh painting, we will have an impoverished appreciation of this great artist. We must go to the artistry itself’.
I tend to subscribe to the idea that it’s better to read the great theologians of the past themselves, rather than read books about them. And so, although Ortlund seeks to avoid that problem by quoting plenty of Edwards himself, he, along with the other authors of Crossway’s Theologians on the Christian Life series have to give us reasons to read their books rather than the giants they write about. While I hoped Ortlund’s book would succeed in this area, especially after it made third place on Desiring God’s 14 Best Books of 2014, I was in the end left disappointed by a book which tells the reader at least as much about Ortlund and New Calvinism as it does about Edwards.

The book starts rather jarringly, giving the reader no introduction or historical context to who Jonathan Edwards actually was, apart from a few scattered details – he was ejected from his church, died in 1758 and never watched the Super Bowl or Skyped. It feels like someone has just walked into your house without any greeting and begun talking theology. In fact that Ortlund feels he has to persuade Christians that they can still learn from someone who has never spent their Lord’s Day watching sport is an early indication of the angle that the author is coming from.

Those expecting an academic treatment like Sinclair Ferguson’s John Owen on the Christian Life are going to be disappointed. Ortlund tries to apply Edward’s theology to the lives of his readers, which is an admirable aim, but ends up turning the book into ‘Jonathan Edwards – and the random thoughts of Dane Ortlund – on the Christian life’. Ortlund’s sources include Doug Wilson’s blog, a Mark Driscoll interview and the film version of the Hobbit. He asks the reader to imagine people saying ‘Why so somber, Jonathan?’. Somehow a corny joke (‘The soul is not the bottom of your foot. That’s your sole’) which would be cringeworthy even at a youth group makes it into a published book. And Ortlund (a PhD and professional book editor) manages to mix up the verb ‘envelop’ with the noun ‘envelope’ as he points us towards the day that joy will do something to us that involves a flat rectangular piece of paper. Another evidence of poor editing is an Edwards quote which is cited twice in full (pp 132 and 174) with apparently no awareness that it’s already been used. It’s also filled with American illustrations and phrases (NASCAR, ‘ ‘picking up meds in Walgreens’, ‘where’s Waldo and castle Legos’) showing no awareness of a wider audience and meaning that this book will date a lot faster than Edwards. Ortlund also feels that a fairly straightforward quote from a recent academic book needs to be followed by his own ‘Translation’ (p. 168, n. 1). Sinclair Ferguson this is not. Perhaps it’s an unfair comparison (despite the similarities of the titles) and it may just be the approach this series is taking, but it’s difficult to imagine that this week’s release of Luther on the Christian Life (the latest in the series, authored by Carl Trueman) will be anything like Ortlund’s effort.

Apart from Edwards, Ortlund probably quotes or references C. S. Lewis the most (19 times on a rough count – quite a lot for a 195 page book). Now I’m a big Lewis fan, but a couple of times I was left wondering whether Ortlund was using Lewis as a further example of something Edwards taught, or whether he was forcing Edwards through a Lewis filter. This comes across particularly with his treatment of joy and desire, where he fails to provide much evidence that he’s starting with JE rather than CSL. I haven’t read enough Edwards to say for sure, but it doesn’t fill the reader with much confidence when Ortlund builds his entire case mainly on one quote, which could easily be taken another way. The same is true in the chapter on obedience, where Ortlund quotes starts off by quoting Lewis about true obedience as doing what we want to do, but doesn’t wrestle with texts like Romans 7 or Heb 12:4 (resisting to the point of shedding blood), or prove that Edwards and Lewis were in agreement.

Old Calvinists and anyone who treasures the Shorter Catechism will also be alarmed that for Ortlund it is just the soul that is united to Christ (contra WSC #37). There also seems to be a bit of a fascination with sex – reading it into Edwards the way Driscoll reads it into the Song of Solomon. And do we really need the o-word?

All of this isn’t to say there weren’t parts of the book I liked, and not just from Edwards. Some of Ortlund’s illustrations were very helpful. Some of the strongest parts of the book are where Ortlund disagrees with Edwards, and in some of them I would agree with Ortlund (at least on the basis of the evidence he cites). However the annoyances were just too frequent to properly enjoy the book. There’s too much Ortlund and not enough Edwards to recommend someone spending their time reading this. Normally I would feel bad about such a negative review, but seeing as Ortlund writes off Steve Lawson’s recent work on Edwards as ‘hagiography’, let’s hope he can take it as well as give it out.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

Another BBC programme on the Psalms

Then Sings My Soul (Episode 1) is the latest BBC programme to feature the psalms and the RPCI – this time focusing on Trinity RPC. Marie-Louise Muir traces the history of hymn singing, with the bit on psalms starting about 16 minutes in.

abi - psalm programme

joel psalms

A few quotes from the presenter:

“It made me feel that while I may have been raised a Roman Catholic, inside in my heart, having sung these Psalms I think I must be a Covenanter”.

“What I absolutely did not miss was any accompaniment”.

“Hearing the Reformed Presbyterians singing breathed new life into the psalms for me”.

gmo psalms

warren psalms 2

nelsons psalms

Previous Programmes:

Make a Joyful Noise: The Metrical Psalms (2003 BBC TV Programme)
An Independent People (2013 3-part BBC series on Ulster Presbyterianism)
A Kist o Wurds on the Psalms (2014 BBC Radio Ulster Programme)