
I don’t normally read history books for the craic, but I was persuaded to get Andrew Holmes’ The Shaping of Ulster Presbyterian Belief and Practice, 1770-1840 for Christmas. I found it highly interesting, despite the fact that RPs don’t get much of a mention. Most of it is about the Synod of Ulster (‘the great unwashed’) and the Seceders (RP wannabees) (these 2 groups united in 1840 to form the PCI) and the non-subscribers. Indeed, the worst thing about the book is probably having to read so much of the guff that the dirty non-subscribing / arian / unitarian / bring your dog to church / ‘New Light’ gypsies believed! But I suppose you can’t tell the publishing wing of Oxford University that you’re going to leave out a group just because they happen to be heretics…
So anyway, here’s some things I found particularly interesting (I’m not saying whether I agree or disagree with them, just saying they’re intrestin’):
– During this period no Presbyterians held services on Christmas Day (p 92). Of course, no-one did back in the day, but I assumed most Presbyterians had started it pretty soon after 1690. So it hasn’t been an RP distinctive for as long as I thought!
– Reading sermons was seen as at best patronising, if not a sign of heresy!
– The Marrow controversy (mainly involving the Free Offer of the Gospel) saw the Covenanters & Seceeders pitted against the rest. “Both Seceders and Covenanters freely offered the gospel of Christ to everyone, irrespective of their spiritual attainments. In the late eighteenth century, the Covenanter minister William James charged John Holmes of the Synod of Ulster with doctrinal error in not offering the gospel to sinners but only to those who had prepared themselves for salvation. Opponents argued that the free offer of the gospel repudiated the teaching of the WCF by expounding universal salvation and denying that Christ had died only for the elect.” (p 131)
– In the late 1700s a Seceder minister tried to hold a (open air) communion at Lylehill when “Crowds of dissolute or thoughtless persons came from Belfast” – no change there then!
– Also on the subject of communion: “Following Calvin, conservative Presbyterians held that Christ was spiritually present to those who were of the elect…Reflecting the influence of rationalism, non-subscribers held that the bread and wine were merely symbols or representations of Christ’s body and blood upon which the believer was to meditate.”(p 186)
– The first moves to get rid of communion tokens (predictably) came from non-subscribers, with Henry Montgomery (Henry Cooke’s arch-rival in the Arianism debate) arguing that the ‘only tokens God requires from sinners are penitence, faith and love’. Also “as early as 1826, at least one non-subscribing congregation had ‘laid aside many years ago’ the distribution of tokens.” (p 172)
– RPs disciplined people who voted in elections (yooooo), registered leases (?), served on juries (?), signed parliamentary petitions (?) or took oaths of allegiance. (p 174)
– AH sums up one of the rules of the 1815 Irish edition of the Short directory for religious societies in the Covenanting Church – “There were to be no gender-specific meetings to ensure that men were able to control female fancy and frivolousness.” (p 291)
Covenants:
– “The Seceders in 1744 made the renovation of both Scottish covenants…terms of Christian communion” (p 167)
– “Ulster Presbyterians saw themselves as a separate community and a covenanted people” (p 306) This refers to both Covenant Theology and the Covenants of 1638 and 43. Covenant Theology was big throughout the period. There was more attachment to the Covenants from your average Presbyterian than you might think (I thought they hated them!) but towards the end of the eighteenth century this was dying out:
“A commitment to the perpetual obligations of the religio-political convenants [ha! they can’t even spell Covenant in the PCI!!] of 1638 and 1643, for example, was not universally shared by Presbyterians and, indeed, became less important for conservatives from the 1780s.” (p 307)
However 60 years later when the PCI was formed they were once again slipping back in the direction of being wannabe Covenanters:
“The increasing evangelical character of Presbyterianism led to the union in 1840 of the Synod of Ulster and the Secession synod…The union was interpreted as a product of the ongoing revival of religion since the early 1800s…the list of principles underlying the union reflected a desire to return to the doctrines and practices of seventeenth-century Scottish Presbyterianism…It was agreed that these ‘principles claim the admiration of every lover of the ‘good old way’ which was trodden by the Church of Scotland in her days of Covenanted Reformation.’ ” (p 311)
Of course with the Covenants forming no part of their union despite their objectives being unfulfilled and never having been shown to be unbiblical (and so still binding on the nation), I think the only response to that last quote would be ‘keep telling yourselves that!’.








































































