EXCLUSIVE: “For Christ’s Crown and Covenant” DVD Review

title_monument

The long awaited DVD is finally here, so I thought I’d give you some screenshots as well as my thoughts on the production. (The DVDs have left the North West and will be reaching outlying areas of our province, such as Belfast, soon.) The DVD is actually split into 2 completely separate parts. The first lasts 54 minutes and is about the history of the church, from the build up to the Scottish Reformation in 1560 to the present day. The second part looks at the Covenanters today and lasts for 27 minutes. Maybe its because I watched it quite late at night, but the history section seemed a bit on the dull side, especially early on – and if I’m thinking this as someone who likes history and is into Covenanter history, then what is the average member of the church going to think, never mind those outside it?! A lot of the history is done by the Rev. Sinclair Horne, who no-one young has ever heard of. It would have been far better getting someone a bit younger and who we know. Sir Andrew Quigley would have been best of course – he’s done videos before and would have done it with a lot more passion. Squigs is probably too busy for such things now though.

part1

Talking of SAQ, he would be the first to complain that the ‘The Covenanters fought for civil and religious liberty’ myth was peddled once again by James McClelland, the producer only a few seconds into the production – and it even says it on the back of the DVD box. The Covenanters were interested in civil liberty as far as it would have meant they would have stopped getting slaughtered all the time, but they were firmly against toleration – they were not for ‘religious liberty’ in any shape or form. In Scotland, monuments from the time usually say something along the lines of that the people died ‘In defence of the Covenanted Reformation’ while monuments that have been erected since the 18th century try and claim our forefathers as champions of ‘religios and civil liberty’. Another blatant error from McClelland at the start is that he says the Covenanters were around in the 16th Century – obviously forgetting that the 1600s were in fact the 17th Century. But it’s not a big point. Another factual inaccuracy later on is when some boy starts talking about ‘Andrew’ Peden rather than Alexander. A bit shoddy. Just to get it all out of my system, there’s a bit where they’re talking about the Covenanters being executed and some rare looking boy puts one of them chains round his neck – the ones that were outside churches for discipline – as if they were used for executions.

banner_over_inscription

Most of the DVD is done in the form of interviews with people who know what they’re talking about. Knox is the main man and comes across really well (I cracked up listening to him say ‘Now the interesting thing about Knox…’ but that’s probably just me) as did Trevor McCavero and Strobert’s namesake.

knox

strobert_snr

One big downside of the historical part is when they interview some guy who works with Christian books. At the start, he’s great – great accent, really passionate, brightens the thing up – and then they start asking him should the Covenanters have taken up arms. At this point you just KNOW that he’s gonna turn out to be a dirty liberal and sure enough he trots out some wee line about Peter being told to put away his sword and that pacifism is the only way forward. Knox and the Rev. Prof. immediately cautiously refuted him but the damage had been done – it’s OUR DVD – what are we doing giving a platform to the views of this boy?!!! Did he expect the Covenanters to just roll over and die as their conventicles were attacked and as the Stuart monarchs tyrannised the nation??!!!!! The Covenanters declared WAR on Charles II – and for war it’s traditional to use weapons. Was the rest of the nation in the wrong also when it overthrew James II 8 years later? In the Sanquhar declaration, the Covenanters:

disown Charles Stuart, that has been reigning, or rather tyrannising, as we may say, on the throne of Britain these years bygone, as having any right, title to, or interest in, the said Crown of Scotland for government, as forfeited, several years since, by his perjury and breach of covenant both to God and His Kirk, and usurpation of His Crown and royal prerogatives therein, and many other breaches in matters ecclesiastic, and by tyranny and breach of the very leges regnandi in matters civil. For which reason we declare, that several years since he should have been denuded of being king, ruler, or magistrate, or of having any power to act or to be obeyed as such. As also we, being under the standard of our Lord Jesus Christ, Captain of Salvation, do declare a war with such a tyrant and usurper, and all the men of his practices, as enemies to our Lord Jesus Christ, and His cause and covenants; and against all such as have strengthened him, sided with, or anywise acknowledged him in his tyranny, civil or ecclesiastic; yea, against all such as shall strengthen, side with, or anywise acknowledge any other in like usurpation and tyranny

The 2nd part of the DVD is of course the most interesting as it gives lots of opportunity to try and spot yourself. Senior Camp volleyball is the first such opportunity and so we have great action shots of Joelerz and Steven McC:

joelerz

stevie_mcc

They gave Rich Ganz a lot of airtime, and if you didn’t know you’d probably think he was some sort of charismatic:

ganzer

They also got some class slow motion stuff going. Here’s a pic of Jonny McClure running madly at the camera. Wait a minute, he’s not even an RP!

jonny

The film then switches to the more mature members of camp who are apparently inside in heated debate at the time. Here’s Peter in 2 poses:

peter_debating
Debating

peter_pointing
Pointing

After the frivolity of camp, they take us to the opening of the new College.

collegeopening_boys

As was noted at the time, they videod Ted through the window. Rare boys.

ted_thruthewindow

They also did closeups of various members of the audience:

harry_f_stow
Harry F Stow

philip_beard
The even managed to capture Philip with his beard! I reckon my readers from Cyprus will be shocked at that photo!!

david_valeriemckay
David McCullough along with Renwick committee member Valerie McKay

Then they have the actual opening by Professor Leahy. It sounds like somebody shouts ‘Woohoo’ when it’s done. Don’t think it was me, as my line was ‘Hope you like ‘er!’

college_opening
Ted shares a joke with big JH

blair
Blair with a crazy look on his face

We also get some shots of the students at work – Ted giving it some as Tim works studiously and Philip looks bored.

ted_college

college_students

ted_college_pictures

Then of course there was the highlight of the whole DVD – Faughan!

faughan_outside_sign

vlcsnap-27194

robert_hanna

And, the highlight of highlights, saving the best till last, ME!!!

me

So overall it’s ok. I still don’t know what the real purpose of the DVD is. The bits about camp and the new college were the best parts I think – they had life about them! The rest seems pretty irrelevant. Hardly anything’s mentioned about evangelism. And of course, the second bit, about what were are like today, immediately starts on about Psalms. GET OVER IT!!! Most of the DVD is about Psalms. A film about this part of Christ’s Church and they spent part of it discussing whether it’s alright for Christians to read hymns?!! But that’s the price to pay I suppose if you don’t do the whole thing yourself. How is a resigned Free P minister expected to understand what the Reformed Presbyterian Church is all about? We’ll know for the next time!

It’s still an enjoyable thing to watch like. As a DVD it’s very professionally done and the filming of the different meeting houses is lovely. Our boys all speak very well, and it’s great to have events such as the College Opening, the Ulster Hall and Camp preserved on video. I’m just less forgiving on things I care about ig Narnia.

Related posts: This DVD
“For Christ’s Crown and Covenant” DVD

11 thoughts on “EXCLUSIVE: “For Christ’s Crown and Covenant” DVD Review”

  1. Good work Steve!

    In light of recent comments, I’m not sure if that qualifies as a review or not – but I enjoyed it! It was nice to get a bit of a sneak preview – and nice to be warned in advance that I’ve been portrayed as some finger-waving maniac!!!

    And … I am so pleased that the appearance of Philip’s “beard” has been preserved for posterity. I was beginning to wonder if I’d imagined it!!!

  2. Stevo – what an insightful review! Good work once again! A very enjoyable read, and as it seems probably better than part 1 of the dvd. Clearly the pic of me at college is one of me being in deep thought (probably why did I not shave the goatie off before the college opening!) Keep up the good work steelo. This is definitely better, and more interesting than anything else on t’internet, including my hotmail account.

  3. Thanks Philip, I’m honoured!

    Baus: I’ve updated the post to include a link to related posts – the bottom link has more details on the DVD. It is only available from the Covenanter Bookshop in Belfast. Their telephone number from outside the UK is +442890814110.

  4. I’m glad I haven’t put people off getting it anyway! The DVD makes perfect post-Ballyclabber party viewing, especially when watched alongside Knox and Dr. McCavery Junior!

  5. Good review Stephen. I am sad to see the old myth that the Covenanters were in favour of the unbridled religious toleration, which this nation presently endures, is being pushed in a DVD which should be accurately portraying their beliefs. How anyone can believe that is beyond me; after all one does not have to be a scholar to know that the Solemn League and Covenant binds the state to extirpate(uproot) ”Popery, Prelacy…heresy and schism’ – hardly a manifesto for toleration?

    A while back I gave a talk at Dromara’s CY on ‘Josiah: the Old Testament Covenanter’ in which I explained, that just as Josiah destroyed idolatry in his day, so it is the duty of Christian civil magistrates nowadays to suppress false religion, Popery, Prelacy and dangerous heresy with the sword. In case anyone objected that man has a civil right to be an idolater, I pointed out that this is not thaught anywhere in Scripture. What do we go by the Bible or the ungodly ideas of the American and French Revolution’s?

    Also it is worth mentioning that the Cameronian Covenanters did not wage war on the Stuart’s as a Church, but as the representatives of the Covenanted nation of Scotland. So the reference to Peter taking up the sword is a misnomer. Regrettfully, what you have told us doesn’t surprise me because what do you expect when you leave the production to our Paisleyite friends?

  6. Oh sorry man dont worry it was all in jest im now looking at it on the web page and it does look quite aggressive(my post) sorry about that! Col 1vs2

Comments are closed.