The Theology of the Westminster Standards (book review)

The Theology of the Westminster Standards: Historical Context and Theological Insights
J. V. Fesko
Crossway, 2014

fesko theology of the westminster standards

Those wanting to study the Westminster Standards in their historical context are living at an exciting time. The publication of Chad Van Dixhoorn’s monumental Minutes and Papers of the Westminster Assembly, 1643-1652 has been accompanied by 3 new series of books from Reformation Heritage: The Westminster Assembly Principle Documents series, Studies on the Westminster Assembly Series (the initial publications of which are by Wayne Spear and John Bower of the RPCNA) and The Westminster Assembly Facsimile Series. Making use of those, along with many of the primary sources now so easily available online, comes John Valero Fesko’s The Theology of the Westminster Standards (released just a month or so before Van Dixhoorn’s own Confessing the Faith).

Fesko’s thesis is that while there is still a lot of use made of, and commentaries published on the Westminster Standards, much of this study is divorced from their seventeenth century historical context. Even having the minutes is not enough as ‘the Westminster Assembly was part of a broader ongoing conversation with Patristic, medieval, Reformation and contemporary’ theologians. Fesko contends that there is no way one book could properly contextualise every part of the confession, so he picks out ten key themes such as the Doctrine of Scripture, Justification and the Church – and aims to inspire others to do more. His thesis serves as an important reminder not just to read the Standards and assume that how we use certain terms, or understand certain concepts, is the same way the Divines used them and understood them. The negative side of this is that if certain statements are unpalatable to the modern reader, Fesko can just write them off as an inevitable result of the historical context. This doesn’t happen much, but repeatedly comes up in regard to the teaching that the Pope is the anti-Christ, and at the expense of Fesko discussing any of the exegesis that got them there.

Rather than being the straitjacket they are often portrayed as, Fesko also does a good job of showing how Confessions of faith were ‘typically written to define truth and fence of heterodoxy and heresy while allowing a degree of doctrinal latitude within the boundaries of the confession’. Some of these are so obvious that they don’t really need much context to explain, but it does helps to see not just what we do believe but what we don’t.

The chapter on ‘Worship’ contains a couple of disappointments. Firstly, while Fesko includes some quotes as to the divines’ belief that the Lord’s Day is permanent and moral, he doesn’t give any of their arguments and rather brushes over a topic sorely needing more attention in a book written primarily for a North American audience. His sections on Psalmody and Instruments are particularly poor. He seems to list Calvin as an advocate of uninspired songs (unsupported by the footnotes he provides). He also fails to provide much support for his contention that while ‘At first glance the Confession appears to support the views of exclusive psalmody’, it actually doesn’t. While quoting David Dickson arguing for exclusive psalmody, he doesn’t reference any divine who didn’t, and the only scholarship he can point to is Nick Needham’s attempt to prove the divines weren’t against hymns and instruments, which has been refuted by Matthew Winzer. When it comes to instruments, Fesko can only muster a paragraph, which claims that the issue of musical instruments was ‘apparently avoided’ by the Standards! Again the only ‘scholarship’ he can cite is Needham, and the only theologian he can list in favour of instruments is the Jesuit Robert Bellarmine. Finally, Fesko’s section on ‘two kingdoms’ in his section on ‘The Church’ should probably be read with caution, not just because he comes from Westminster Seminary California, but because of his reliance on the work of his colleague David VanDrunen.

For all the recent resources Fesko has utilised, he seem to be unaware of the newer Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (2004), but relies on its predecessor which was published over a century earlier, leaving him unnecessarily scratching his head occasionally (eg p. 59, n. 73). While his annotated bibliography mentions the fact that PDFs of primary sources can be downloaded to your computer or tablet from the PRDL, he doesn’t mention that a number of works he lists can also be downloaded in a much more readable and searchable format from Logos Bible Software.

Those caveats aside, Fesko succeeds not just in providing an illuminating book for those with an interest in historical theology, but in showing that any serious study of these important documents must be done with the historical context in mind. Thanks to the resources that have become available over the last few years, it has never been easier to do so.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

2 thoughts on “The Theology of the Westminster Standards (book review)”

  1. Thanks for this review. I noticed that he made a real point of relying on an early edition of the WCF, as opposed to the 19th century edition that FP Publications reprints. He seemed to think that grammatical changes to the later editions obscured some significant theological points, such as the Confession’s affirmation of the imputation of Christ’s active obedience in chapter 11.

    Having got the Chad Van Dixhoorn book out of the way, I look forward to getting this one finished in the near future. My initial impression is that John Fesko’s book is superior to CVD’s, though I do hope that the latter author will eventually publish his thesis or some other monograph on the Westminster Assembly.

    Have you had a look at Wayne Spear’s monograph yet?

  2. Yeah he does make a big point out of that – and also makes a point of leaving all quotations in the original spelling to force the reader to read them more slowly and thoughtfully.

    I have Spear pre-ordered on Logos, looking forward to reading it.

Comments are closed.