Olyott on Headcoverings


Not required for Public Worship

I’ve heard many arguments for wearing headcoverings over the years, but basically never heard an argument for not wearing them, even though it is the position our church holds. However I can’t say that anymore as Daniel Ritchie has pointed out a sermon by Northern Ireland winger Stuart Elliott on ‘The Role of Men and Women’ from 1 Corinthians 11:2-16 which refutes headcoverings. Lionel summarises Stuarty’s main arguments why this is not a biblical doctrine:

1. The passage refers to what prophets/prophetess’s do while speaking; it has no bearing on how those who remain silent adorn themselves.
2. It is not specifically referring to public worship as at v.17 Paul addresses the issue of how the ‘church’ is to keep the Lord’s Supper.
3. A covering must cover the whole head, excluding the face, while a hat merely decorates it.
4. In 1 Tim. 2:9 Paul calls for women to have respectable hairstyles when attending public worship; how could this be relevant if their hair was covered?
5. Paul’s argument is grounded in the light of nature – yet in creation their was no clothes – so Eve could not have been wearing a hat.
6. Hats were actually part of the preistly dress in the Old Testament (Ex. 39:28); therefore they cannot be distinctly female and to enforce the wearing of such garmets would appear to be a return to ceremonial bondage.
7. Does the idea that a woman needs Christ + a hat not seem somewhat unPauline in light of what he wrote in Galatians and Colossians?
8. The early NT Church didn’t have a problem with men wearing hats – nor did the Reformers and Puritans.
9. The Westminster Confession and RP Testimony don’t consider ladies hat-wearing to be a regulative principle of worship.
10. Can it be shown from anywhere else in Scripture that ladies wore hats as a principle of worship.

If anyone else has links to any other resources on the subject, you could post them in the comments.

Update:

Wow, 2 posts in a row with 6 comments! Daniel has added links from a hardline denomination in America that used to be in favour of headcoverings, but changed their position. One of the documents he links to shows how the Reformers and Covenanters etc DIDN’T hold headcoverings – a very valuable resource featuring George Gillespie, among others. Also, here is an introduction to the topic, more based on biblical arguments.

10 thoughts on “Olyott on Headcoverings”

  1. His church wasn’t sponsored by them anyway.

    PS: Surely spinnies is spelt ‘spinnies’? And did you know you linked to a real site there?!

  2. Good work Stephen. While I would say that I do respect people who meekly affirm the position that has been refuted; it is my view that the doctrinaire hat wearers have had it too easy for too long. If we are not clear on such matters should we be surprised if our young people defect to the Free Presbyterians? They need to be aware that the historic Protestant and Reformed position on this subject is at odds with the religion of Paisleyism. Isn’t it strange that this denomination has a congregation on the Shankill Road called ‘John Knox Memorial’ yet they would not have allowed Mr Knox to preach or to come to the Lord’s Table because he wore a hat!

    Apparently in the 19th century the American Covenanters brought out an anthology of Protestant and Reformed literature on the subject quoting from Calvin, Knox, Rutherford, Gillespie, the Westminster Divines, the Synod of Dort, the Geneva Bible etc. proving that hat wearing is not part of the Reformed faith. I will try to track down the name of this work ASAP.

    One question – are those, in the RP Church, who are contentious about this subject in breach of their membership vows to show a teachable spirit to the Testimony which does not affirm that hat-wearing is a regulative principle?

  3. Back again. I have also managed to locate a smaller introduction to the subject on the same website called ‘A Brief Introduction to Headcoverings’ by Greg L. Price. This also can be printed off from the address:
    http://www.reformedpresbytery.org/books/headcvr2/headcvr2.htm

    This seems to deal more with purely Biblical arguments and clearly demonstrates that female head-dress is not a regulative principle of worship. I recommend that everyone should at least read this.

  4. I just wanted to mention that the abovementioned presbytery is an unusual presbytery in that it only has one minister.

Comments are closed.