“Why do you only sing psalms?”

It may be a question that would have sounded strange for the majority of church history but it’s one that those who exclusively sing the songs of Jesus today invariably face.

It’s also a question that was clearly, biblically and graciously answered as part of the 3rd talk of Senior Camp 2014 by Philip Moffett. I’ll be uploading all the talks (along with psalms and readings) shortly but in the meantime here’s the one on worship with just the talk and closing psalm left in. Some at camp expressed a desire to be able to share it with their non-RP friends, so I’ve put it on SoundCloud to make that simpler.

A Kist o Wurds on the Psalms

The latest BBC programme to feature RPs and Psalms was their Ulster Scots radio programme A Kist o Wurds (Series 34 – Episode 13)

“Not so long ago, every service in an Irish Presbyterian Church featured the singing of at least one “metrical Psalm” – Psalms rewritten into poetic verses to make them more singable – and often sung in four part harmony. It’s a musical tradition going back to the reformation – but these days, Presbyterian churches are more likely to be singing modern Christian songs. In a special programme Kist o Wurds will be looking at where the Metrical Psalms came from – and where they’ve gone.”

It features Prof Norris Wilson and members of the Northern Presbytery Choir. It covers a lot more of the reasons for exclusive, unaccompanied psalmody rather than just focusing on the practice.

“Christ himself said the psalms all speak of him, so we should see Christ in every psalm.” – booyah!

It will be available on iPlayer for 5 more days, but for posterity here’s an mp3.

Related posts:

Make a Joyful Noise: The Metrical Psalms (2003 BBC TV Programme)
An Independent People (2013 3-part BBC series on Ulster Presbyterianism)

The backbone of Christian worship for 2,000 years

There’s been a bit of a debate over whether it’s wise to quote heretics or not. But you can’t really argue with NTW’s historical take on the place of the psalms:

Well, it surprises me that one need make a case for the Psalms, but in a great many contemporary churches, something very odd has happened….they often simply forget the Psalms. You can go to many churches where if you attend week after week after week you will never ever sing or read the Psalms.

There’s something very peculiar about that because in pretty well every branch of the Christian tradition for 2,000 years, the Psalms have been the backbone of Christian worship. Certainly in all traditional denominations, but in many non-traditional ones, as well, it’s assumed that the Psalms are the heart of worship.

One of the staplines that the publisher has been using is “what would Jesus sing?” which I really like, because the Psalms were the prayer book that Jesus Himself used, and we can see in the Gospels and in the New Testament how Jesus and the early Christians used them, and it seems to me extraordinary that we would ignore that resource in our own worship.

And here’s one on why our culture is so quick to give up Bible reading and relationships:

Part of the problem in our culture today is that people don’t like working at anything. That’s why relationships are so difficult. People think either it’s perfect or it’s rubbish, so as soon as it stops being perfect “oh, it must be rubbish,” so we throw it away. Most things that are worthwhile in human life, you actually have to work at them and only then does the real fruit come.

Calvin on believers appealing to their own righteousness

What are we to make of it when we’re singing a psalm about believers appealing to their own righteousness? Do we just apply it to Christ? After listing such references in Psalms 7, 17, 18 & 26, Calvin gives a few pointers:

“…Yet the saints, while they appeal to God’s judgment to approve their innocence, do not present themselves as free from all guilt and faultless in every respect; but while they have fixed their assurance of salvation in his goodness alone, they still, trusting in him as avenger of the poor afflicted beyond right and equity, assuredly commend to him the cause in which the innocent are oppressed.

“On the other hand, when they hale their opponents with them before God’s judgment seat, they do not boast of an innocence that under strict test would correspond to God’s own purity; but because, in comparison with their adversaries’ malice, dishonesty, craft, and wickedness, they know that their sincerity, righteousness, simplicity, and purity are known and pleasing to God, they are not afraid to call upon him to act as judge between themselves and their adversaries. ”

Institutes, III, xvii, 14.

A little later, on Psalm 82.6 (‘Preserve my life for I am godly’) he writes:

“By such expressions they mean nothing else but that by their regeneration itself they are attested as servants and children of God to whom he promises that he will be gracious.”

Similarly, when we’re told that God hears the prayer of the ‘righteous’ (Ps 34.15):

“In these statements he does not set the value of prayer according to the merits of works, but he is pleased to establish the assurance of those who are duly aware of guileless uprightness and innocence, as all believers ought to be. Indeed, what the blind man whose sight was restored says in John’s gospel—that God does not listen to sinners [John 9:31]—has been drawn from the very truth of God, provided we understand “sinners” in the customary usage of Scripture, as all persons who slumber and repose in their own sins without any desire for righteousness. For no heart can ever break into sincere calling upon God that does not at the same time aspire to godliness.”

Institutes, III, xx, 10.

David Murray: 10 helps on the Imprecatory Psalms

Taken from a mix of the latest Connected Kingdom podcast and his chapter on ‘Christian Cursing?’ in Sing a New Song, summarised here.

1. In the first gospel promise (Gen 3.14-15), God promises a curse on the serpent and his seed. Prayers in the psalms for God to curse are really a prayer for that first gospel promise to be fulfilled.

2. David was not a vindictive person – in fact he was a very forgiving character. So this is not not personal vindictiveness. The Bible portrays David as a merciful and gracious man who often prayed for his enemies. The imprecatory psalms he wrote, then, sprang not from a vindictive temper, but from a heart on fire for God’s glory.

3. The king represented God. God’s reputation was tied up with the king. Offending the king was offending God’s anointed. And David was God’s anointed in a particularly special, Christological way.

4. There are multiple NT quotations from the imprecatory psalms. 35, 69 and 109 are the most frequently quoted Psalms in NT after 2, 22, 110 and 118. So clearly the NT is not embarrassed about these psalms.

5. The NT has its own imprecations. Jesus himself pronounced curses on the Jewish leaders in Matthew 23. Also Gal 1.8-9 and famously 1 Cor 16.22: “If anyone has no love for the Lord, let him be accursed.”

6. The imprecatory psalms are based on the justice of God. The theme of the imprecatory psalms is that justice be done and the innocent righteous vindicated. Furthermore, the foundation of biblical justice was retribution: “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth”—a principle to which the psalms often appeal (“Let the net that he hid ensnare him,” Ps. 35:8). If the idea of retributive justice is lost or devalued, then the imprecatory psalms will never be properly understood.

7. The Psalmist is really praying “Thy kingdom come” – which involves not just the upbuilding of God’s kingdom, but the destroying of competing kingdoms. Preferably by conversion, but if not, by removal.

8. The eighth help is a reminder that “vengeance is the Lord’s.” To pray the imprecatory psalms is to deny one’s own right to vengeance and leave it to God’s wisdom. It’s hard in our context to relate right away to these psalms, since we live easily in a land with no imminent persecution. But God’s Kingdom is still at war, and these are war psalms.

9. An imprecatory prayer will often have the good of the sinner at its heart, because God will often use judgments to bring sinners to himself.

10. Finally, the imprecatory psalms point us to Christ, who at the end of time will return to punish the wicked and vindicate his people. Ultimately the imprecatory psalms will be answered and fulfilled in the return of Christ and the last judgment.