What is Covenant Theology?

What is Covenant Theology?
Ryan M. McGraw
Crossway, 2024

I was pleasantly surprised by this book. I assumed it would simply follow a standard pattern of going through the various administrations of the Covenant of Grace, with a chapter on each. However there is nothing routine or formulaic about it.

After a somewhat biographical introduction, the first chapter introduces us to the covenant of works and the covenant of grace, asking: ‘Do we not see a collapsed world under a broken covenant of works in hard jobs, painful childbirth, illness and death, broken families, war, natural disaster and a host of opinions about religion? (19-20). This is followed by a chapter which traces the covenant of grace throughout the Bible: ‘if we want salvation in Christ today, then we need to have the “blessing of Abraham” (Gal. 3:14)’ (34). ‘Paul taught good OT theology when he argued that a true Jew is not one who is a Jew only outwardly’ (36). Rather than being a republication of the covenant of works, the Mosaic covenant ‘greatly expanded the blessings of the covenant of grace’ (37). The section on the Davidic covenant begins with a great illustration involving Aragon (41-2).

A chapter on ‘Covenant, Testament and Joyful Bible Reading’ compares the old and new covenants. Particularly helpful was the section of how we underestimate the trauma it would have involved for Jewish Christians to move from the old covenant to the new – and then he makes a powerful application: ‘…when we arrive to church Sunday morning tired, with frying or fighting children, wondering whether we have to talk to the awkward visitor, in an old building, with no smells, bells, and whistles, we should never lose sight of the glory of God’s covenant presence among us’ (51).

A fourth chapter on ‘Covenant Theology and the Triune God’ was more on the Trinity than covenant theology. The next chapter, ‘Covenant Theology and the Christian Life’ was very helpful.

The book closes with some questions and answers about covenant theology. There is a good section on republication, as well as on how Jesus advances human nature. McGraw doesn’t provide much evidence for his surprising suggestion that ‘the Spirit changed hearts in the old covenant without dwelling within believers’ (114). I also found it interesting to read that children are not members of the church until their baptism (120) and wonder whether that can be squared with LC 62: “The visible church is a society made up of all such as in all ages and places of the world do profess the true religion, and of their children.”

Finally, maybe I’m being thick, but I’m struggling to make sense of the following sentence, particularly the word “but” – maybe someone can help! ‘the KJV translates the Greek word for covenant as “testament” in 9:15 (and 9:18), but “testament” and “Testator” in between’ (110).

Overall, it’s a great introduction to covenant theology, and I’d probably recommend it just after (or along with) Jonty Rhodes to those new to the subject.

Did the Spirit indwell Old Testament believers?

Probably the most common view today – boosted by James M. Hamilton’s 2006 book God’s Indwelling Presence – is no.

John de Hogg (lecturer in OT and Hebrew at RTC Australia) sums it up:

‘Michael Green in his book I Believe in the Holy Spirit presents a rather common view. “On the whole you had to be someone rather special in Old Testament days to have the Spirit of God. A prophet, a national leader, a king, perhaps some specially wise man (Prov 1:23) or artistic person (Exod 31:3) – in which case you would be beautifying the Lord’s Tent of Meeting or enunciating the Lord’s wisdom. But the Spirit of God was not for every Tom, Dick and Harry… The gift of God’s Spirit was on the whole to special people for special tasks. It was not generally available, nor was it necessarily permanent.” This common view says that OT believers were not indwelt by the Holy Spirit and that OT believers did not experience the active, internal, personal ministry of the Holy Spirit. These blessings came as a result of Pentecost.’ – Vox Reformata, 2012

However, de Hogg then goes on to refute that position. While his article is fairly helpful (and interacts specifically with Hamilton), there’s an absolutely storming one by Walter Kaiser, also taking a contrary view:

“…How could all of these old covenant persons have believed and been enabled to live sanctified lives if the Spirit of God did not dwell in them? Must we say that an Old Testament believer was able to please God spiritually and to be sanctified in the presence of God without the indwelling presence of the Holy Spirit? Did not Enoch please God (Heb 11:5)? Was not Noah one who walked with God and who was righteous and blameless (Gen 6:9)? Did not Joseph resist temptation (Gen 39:9)? Was not Job one who turned away from evil, one who feared God and was blameless and upright ( Job 1:1)? Did not David pray, do not ‘take your Holy Spirit from me?’ (Ps 51:11). Did not the prophet Isaiah teach that the people ‘rebelled and grieved his Holy Spirit’ (Isa 63:10), the same Lord who had ‘set his Holy Spirit among them?’”(Isa 63:11). – Evangelical Quarterly 82.4 (2010)

Both articles deal with verses in John which would seem to be the strongest arguments against such a position.

Kaiser also deals very helpfully with the broader question of ‘What is new in the New Covenant?’, and specifically, what is new at Pentecost (including a very helpful quote from Thomas Goodwin, also cited in Smeaton’s classic work).

This 1976 letter by John Piper is also pretty helpful.