The Trinity

The Trinity
Scott Swain
Crossway, 2020

If you take even a passing interest in the Christian blogosphere, twittersphere, or podcasts, it would have been hard to miss that there has been a Trinitarian controversy raging in recent years. Although it had died down a bit recently, the publication of the second edition of Wayne Grudem’s Systematic Theology has brought it to the fore again. Although not written as a response to recent controversy, this latest contribution to Crossway’s ‘Short Studies in Systematic Theology’ series appears at a good time, and does interact with the debate over Eternal Functional Subordination (EFS). Devoting a chapter to ‘The Simplicity of God’ is also helpful in light of recent debates. A fuller and punchier response to these debates sounds like it will come in March with Matthew Barrett’s Simply Trinity: the unmanipulated Father, Son and Spirit, for which Swain has supplied the foreward.

The book is certainly short (at 133 pages – especially compared to Barrett’s 368), has a devotional thrust, but is still pretty technical. It’s not the first book I would give someone on the Trinity. A 9-word glossary is a help, but could have been expanded. The brevity of the series also means that some important questions have to be left out. As another reviewer has noted, most Christians have questions such as ‘How come Jesus doesn’t know the day or the hour?’. Those looking for a treatment of whether / in what sense the Son was forsaken by the Father on the cross will also have to look elsewhere.

Overall though, this looks like an excellent contribution to a series that is filling an important niche.

The Expulsive Power of a New Affection

The Expulsive Power of a New Affection
Thomas Chalmers
Crossway, 2020

This 70-page booklet is one of the first in a new Crossway series entitled ‘Short Classics’, aimed at introducing famous sermons from the past to a new generation. Each book comprises a forward by a modern writer, a short biography, and then the text of the sermon itself. Spelling and punctuation have been lightly updated and Scripture references added, along with occasional footnotes to help explain archaic words.

It’s a great idea for a series, and the paperback format means they are only about £5 each.

The 250-word biographical sketch of Chalmers drops a bit of a clanger when it says that he was Free Church Moderator until his death – maybe they’re mixing him up with Ian Paisley.

Piper’s introduction is very helpful, and the sermon itself is powerful, and it’s clear to see how it has impacted the likes of Piper and Keller. The historian in me would have liked them to note when the sermon was first published (even if, as Piper says, we don’t know when it was first preached).

The two other ‘Short Classics’ currently available are ‘Heaven is a World of Love’ (Edwards) and ‘Encouragement for the Depressed’ (Spurgeon). Here’s hoping they are the first of many!

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book.

Covenant Theology

Covenant Theology: Biblical, Theological, and Historical Perspectives
Guy Prentiss Waters, J. Nicholas Reid and John R. Muether (eds)
Crossway, 2020

2020 looks like it will be a good year for books on Covenant Theology. First came The Fulfilment of the Promises of God by Richard Belcher (Christian Focus), which may end up replacing Palmer Robertson as the ‘go to’ book on the topic. The next month or so will see the publications of Harrison Perkins’ Catholicity and the Covenant of Works and The Covenant of Works by J. V. Fesko (both OUP).

In between those three, and most exciting of all, Crossway have released this collaboration by the faculty of Reformed Theological Seminary, weighing in at almost 700 pages. The aforementioned Belcher and Robertson each contribute to the twenty-seven chapters.

The comprehensive nature of the book can be seen in the titles of its three main sections. Part 1 covers the Biblical Covenants, Part 2 is on Historical Theology and Part 3 on Collateral and Theological Studies, which includes chapters on ‘Israel and the Nations’, ‘Dispensationalism’ and ‘New Covenant Theologies’. The Federal Vision is dealt with in ‘The Covenant of Works in the Old Testament’ where Belcher concludes ‘This approach modifies the traditional understanding of Christ’s work as a basis for our justification…A reworking of the covenant of works changes how one understands the work of Christ and the basis of justification by faith’.

The annotated bibliography at the end is very helpful, and gets bonus points for mentioning De Graaf’s Promise and Deliverance (original title ‘History of the covenant’). Patrick Gillespie’s books are only mentioned in passing, but he is quoted frequently in Guy Richard’s chapter on the Covenant of Redemption.

While this is not the book for someone merely wanting an introduction to or ‘popular’ treatment of covenant theology (see Rhodes, Belcher or Robertson for that), it is a great resource for ministers to have, whether to read through slowly or use as a reference work.

Unsurprisingly for a volume with many authors, there isn’t complete agreement. For example, Ligon Duncan’s ‘Foreward’ reminds us the Westminster Confession doesn’t identify the covenant of works as ‘grace’, deliberately using the term ‘voluntary condescension’ instead. Whereas Kevin DeYoung’s ‘Afterward’ (adapted from a sermon) quotes the same section of the WCF and says ‘this is a fancy way of saying that for God to enter into any kind of agreement with man – even one based on works – was an act of grace’.

Overall I’m delighted to see this in print, and I’m sure I will refer to it often – just as I do to its companion volumes, the Biblical Theological Introductions to the Old and New Testaments, also from the RTS stable, and published by Crossway in 2016.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book.

An Introduction to John Owen

An Introduction to John Owen: a Christian vision for every stage of life
Crawford Gribben
Crossway, 2020

Do we need another book about John Owen on the Christian life you might ask? Sinclair Ferguson did it way back in 1987. Matthew Barrett and Michael Haykin did it as recently as 2015. To be honest, I was dubious – but watching an interview Crawford did with the Evangelical Bookshop in Belfast (above) convinced me.

Crawford is quickly becoming the world expert on Owen, and this book follows his 2016 John Owen and English Puritanism. He draws not only on Owen’s published works, but on manuscript sources, including notes of sermons – which give us gems like ‘Some say God kist his soule out’ (commenting on the death of Moses). An appendix includes a ‘Primer’ Owen published for children that wasn’t republished by Goold/Banner.

The main part of the book divides into four sections – Childhood, Youth, Middle Age and Death & Eternal Life. It gives a mix of biographical information on Owen (where we have it), as well as his teaching on each stage.

I always have a question mark as to whether I should read a book like this, or just read Owen himself. But this is the sort of book that gives you a taster of the broad sweep of someone’s writings and leaves you wanting to read more. One thing which might have helped familiarisation with Owen’s corpus was footnotes that referenced the title of the work cited, rather than simply what volume of his works they are found in. Curiously for books with the same author, one footnote (p. 128) reads ‘Quoted in Crawford Gribben, John Owen and English Puritanism‘.

At just over 150 pages long, the book is a quick and very enjoyable read – even if Crawford clearly enjoys trolling Presbyterians (especially on the section on baptism – including a couple of Owen’s very strong quotes in favour of paedobaptism from his Hebrews commentary might have provided a bit more balance).

The book serves as a fitting introduction to the forthcoming 30-volume critical edition of Owen’s works being prepared by Crossway (which Crawford says will have modernized language!)

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

Living for God

Living for God: A Short Introduction to the Christian Faith
Mark Jones
Crossway, 2020

I’ve been looking forward to reading Mark Jones’s latest book for a while and it doesn’t disappoint. Advertised as a ‘short’ introduction to the Christian faith, it’s no mere pamphlet (230 pages not including endnotes etc), nor is it simplistic. So while it is the type of book I’d like to see people in our congregations reading, don’t think of it as something you would hand a brand new Christian, unless they’re fairly academically-inclined.

The book is well structured, around the fundamentally import topics of Trinity, Christ, Spirit, Church and the future. There is plenty of scope for ministers to follow the same general structure and amend the material, eg for a sermon series, bible class, theological foundations course or perhaps a membership class.

As usual with Jones’s books, there are frequent quotations from church history, especially Puritans and Church Fathers. This is not theology that is historically adrift – rather it is done consciously in line with the Great Tradition of Christian thought.

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.

The Whole Counsel of God

The Whole Counsel of God: Why and how to preach the entire Bible
Tim Patrick and Andrew Reid
Crossway, 2020

Someone posted a quote from Lloyd-Jones recently saying that Christians should be ashamed if they don’t read the whole Bible every year. I have a number of problems with such an assertion, but I think the authors of this book would respond by saying that Lloyd-Jones shouldn’t expect his congregation to value the entire Bible if he didn’t model that in his preaching ministry. The ML-J recordings trust lists 366 sermons on Romans, 262 on John, 232 on Ephesians, 120 on Acts and only 133 on the whole Old Testament (taken from just 15 books). And of course examples like that could be multiplied.

The authors of this book are concerned that in most evangelical churches, perhaps the majority of the Bible is never preached to the people of God, resulting in ‘the church being underfed and the Lord being only partly honoured’. They ask how can God’s people know God without knowing his word – and how can they know the fullness of God’s word unless it is systematically explained to them. It’s not just the Old Testament in view – the authors assert that many churches have never heard one of the gospels preached right through in living memory.

Their argument is based on more than simply all Scripture being God-breathed; examples of God’s entire word shaping God’s people are cited from Deut 17:18-19; 31:9-13; Josh 8:34-35; 2 Kings 23:1-3 and Nehemiah 8:1-8. They ask ‘How can it be that sincerely committed Bible-believing Christians who now have mostly unhindered access to the Scriptures – and whose spiritual forebears saw no greater priority than providing that access to the Scriptures – can still have relatively thin biblical knowledge?…Perhaps their piecemeal reading and studying of Scripture is just a reflection of what they have seen modelled by their ministers of the word’. And what does it say about about our doctrine of Scripture? If your church has never heard an expository sermon from the book of Jeremiah, ‘might that indicate that for some reason your church does not think that God has anything particularly important or relevant to say through his words inscripturated in that biblical book?’.

Their solution to all this is to call pastors to aim to preach through the entire Bible over the course of 35 years (ideally in the same congregation if possible), without resorting to ‘overview series’ or ‘highlights packages’. They have a helpful diagram where they show that the Bible divides fairly evenly into Torah (17%), Former Prophets (22%), Latter Prophets (22%), Writings (15%), Gospels (10%) and Other NT Books (13%). In light of that they would advocate that the preaching ministry in a local congregation should reflect that split, ideally over a 2 or 3 year period and certainly over the long term.

In general it’s a position I’m already convinced by, and they make it well, even if there’s much to quibble with in terms of how to actually go about it. My main criticism is they don’t envisage the minister preaching more than one sermon a week. As well as being historically adrift, they seem to be really shooting themselves in the foot in trying to achieve their goal, and have to outlaw preaching on any chapter you’ve ever preached on before, and restrict all topical series to church weekends etc. It also means that while not averse to preaching on single verses, they also suggest one sermon on the Ten Commandments (or I guess two if you preach Deuteronomy as well as Exodus) and one on, for example, Ezekiel 40-48 and Psalm 119 (Struthers style). If something unexpected happens in the life of the congregation, you are allowed to preach something different but the preaching programme is still so rigid that you should preach the ‘missing’ sermon separately by video. There’s also a fair smattering of crazy suggestions, like vary your sermon length depending on the passage, so five minutes for Psalm 117, twenty-two for Psalm 118 and an hour for Psalm 119!

The book could really have been improved with real-life examples of people who have actually preached through the Bible. Examples that come to my mind are Stuart Olyott (who gives his rationale and ten-year plan here) or David Silversides – and I’m sure they could have found others by asking around. That would also have let them show how different preachers have achieved the goal in different ways and at different speeds; as it is, the impression you’re left with is that their way is the only approach.
[2021 update: Struthers preached through the whole Bible in 20 years at his prayer meeting – at the pace of a chapter per week (sometimes two), excluding the Psalms and only preaching one sermon on the Song of Solomon]

Overall though I’m hugely excited to see this book in print, and think that ministers need to wrestle with its core message. I would set it as a core text for training preachers if I had the opportunity.

May we not have the same regrets as one RPCS minister who said at an ordination in Stranraer in 1932:

“Give them the whole Bible. After more than forty years of attempts to preach I regret to have to confess that there still remain large and fertile tracts of Bible material which I have never tried to expound. I have, of course, taken many texts from the great Prophets of Israel, but I have not yet tried to travel right through Isaiah, and Jeremiah, and Ezekiel, and Daniel, to bring to my hearers some of the rich and luscious fruit of the linked thoughts of those grand, inspired men with their living and creative messages.”

Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book through their Beyond the Page review programme.