Driscoll on The job of church leaders & the Regulative Principle


(whole sermon)

“I hate religion. Religion assumes that you don’t want to do certain things and so we have to make you do them…Religion assumes that you want to do evil, and we’re going to MAKE YOU do good. That’s not what we believe as Christians. We believe that God gives us new hearts so we want to obey him. Therefore Christianity, the church, Christian friends, Bible teachers – our job is not to make you do something you don’t want to do, but to help you do something that you want to do…It means you don’t have to do new things, it means you get to do new things. It doesn’t mean that religion is about what you don’t get to do, Christianity is about what you do get to do…It’s about following your deepest and strongest desires, in your new heart that Jesus gave you.”

“For the desires of the flesh are against the Spirit, and the desires of the Spirit are against the flesh, for these are opposed to each other, to keep you from doing the things you want to do.” Galations 5:17

“The Christian doesn’t want to lie, doesn’t want to steal, doesn’t want to commit adultery, doesn’t want to lust, doesn’t want to believe error, doesn’t want to walk in darkness. Doesn’t want to. You need to know that. Now your flesh, your Adamic rebellion in you (that will be dealt with finally once and for all at the end) is still there giving you conflicted desires, but your deepest desire is to do the things you want to do. God gives you His desires.”

And on the Regulative Principle
(I didn’t mean this to be this long. This is not an attack! Mark still rocks my world!)


(whole sermon

And then last Sunday he did his long-awaited (from me and John G anyway) sermon on the Regulative Principle. It was the final question in a series (originally) called ‘Ask Anything’. People were allowed to submit questions and vote on them on his church website, and he preached on the top 9 in descending order. And number 1 was the Regulative Principle. So with a due sense of dread and foreboding (because I didn’t expect him to be in favour of it, because if he did a lot of things at Mars Hill would have to change) I listened to it. Also foreboding cos I thought he might fall of the list of my favourite people afterwards! However he’s still right up there. As expected, he didn’t have much time for it (especially things like psalms-only and instruments, which in most places outside Scotland are RP distinctives), but it was still pretty funny and still had some good things it in. For example, he explained the difference between the Regulative Principle and the Normative Principle very well: with the RP (can’t be bothered typing ‘Regulative Principle’ multiple times, hopefully you’ll not all be confused) you have a red light until you see a green light (ig find something in the bible); but the normative principle you assume you have a green light until you see a red light.

However considering how many people voted (thousands like) for that question to be number 1, and how many in church history (including most of his religious heroes) believed in the regulative principle, he could of put in a bit more effort.

The first bit was great. (Apart from him saying that it was an important question cos millions of people worship God – whereas I would say it is an important question because God is important). He basically preached in favour of the RP in the first while. Nadab and Abihu and all that. An RP (as in Reformed Presbyterian) minister would have been proud to preach it! But then he says that he believes in both the Regulative Principle AND the Normative Principle. Which is just silly, because they’re mutually exclusive. But by the end of it he was basically in favour of the normative principle. And then he started going on about a ‘hard’ and a ‘soft’ regulative principle (legalists like us who don’t believe in instruments and hymns would be ‘hard’) – but of course you either have the RP or you don’t. Either it is commanded in the Bible or it’s forbidden. No in between.

His 3 main problems with the RP were:
1. Worship is all of life. This separates it. As soon as you walk in the door of the church everything changes. You don’t get up in the morning and say ‘I can’t brush my teeth cos it’s not in the Bible’.
2. “It doesn’t answer all the questions like technology, announcements and seating” – and it leads to legalistic applications (that’s us he’s pointing at).
3. People who hold to the RP tend not to be biblical. Ig people don’t say amen (1 Cor 14:16), people don’t lift their hands in worship (Ps 63:4, Ps 134:2), men don’t lift their hands in prayer (1 Tim 2:8), and people don’t clap their hands in worship (Ps 47:1, 98:8)

To which I would respond:
1. Well, I’ll actually let John Knox answer it. From his first public debate (1547), right at the start of his ministry. Very similarly to Driscoll, he was asked if people couldn’t even ask for a drink without a direct command from God. Here is the 2nd part of his response:

“The question was not, nor is not, of meat or drink, whereunto the kingdom of God consists not (Rom. 14:17); but the question is of God’s true worshipping, without the which we can have no society with God. And, here it is doubted, if we may take the same freedom in the using of Christ’s sacraments, that we may do in eating and drinking. One meat I may eat, another I may refuse, and that without scruple of conscience. I may change one with another, as oft as I please. Whither may we do the same in matters of religion? May we cast away what we please, and retain what we please? If it be well remembered, Moses, in the name of God, says to the people of Israel, ‘All that the Lord thy God commands thee to do, that do thou to the Lord thy God: Add nothing to it; diminish nothing from it’ (cf. Deut. 12:32; 12:8). By this rule, think I, the kirk of God will measure God’s religion, and not by that which seems good in their own eyes.”

So if all of life is worship then we could do whatever we wanted in communion and it would still be worship – obviously no-one’s going to argue for that…
And it’s all very well saying ‘all life is worship’ (which always sounds very convincing) but it clearly wasn’t in the Old Testament at least. If it was, Nadab and Abihu could just have said ‘Ah well, all of life is worship’. If all of life is worship (in that sense) then verses such as Deut 12:32 make no sense.

2. Announcements are not worship. Duh. You should try going to an RP service. Seats & technology: The Westminster Divines made an important distinction between elements and circumstances of worship. You’re a smart guy. Go and look it up.

3. He’s got (most of) us on the amen bit. If you don’t say Amen at the end of prayers, you’re not biblical, you’re not keeping to the regulative principle and you’re therefore (surely?) sinning. Lifting hands – anyone want to explain that one? Clap – well the second verse is about rivers, and we’re not rivers. And if you take Ps 47:1 literally it means you have to shout as well. Not saying you shouldn’t, just pointing it out…

And finally, his arguments against what’s closest to home:
Psalms: Other people sang songs in the Bible. The psalms say sing a new song. You can’t sing the name of Jesus. ‘Breakfast, lunch and dinner’ doesn’t mean ‘breakfast, breakfast, breakfast’.
Instruments: Instruments are in the Bible (all over the psalms) therefore instruments are Biblical. When you get to Heaven, Jesus is going to hand you a harp. Then people that hold a ‘hard’ Reg Principle will have a bit of a dilemma. They’ll say to Jesus ‘We don’t do bands’ and he’ll say ‘Well you do me, so strum!’

None of his arguments for psalms are new, so no need to reply to them. They’ve all been covered by others before. Suffice to say that in the funny but cheap dig at our interpretation of Eph 5:19 and Col 3:16 he’s also getting at the Westminster Divines, John Owen etc etc. And while ‘breakfast, breakfast, breakfast’ doesn’t mean the same thing, for example ‘in his law and in his statutes and in his testimonies’ (Jer 44:23) do. (Of course, those aren’t the main reasons for why the 3 words mean what we call psalms)
Music: Well yes the bit I quoted is of course hilarious, but saying that something is ‘biblical’ just because it’s mentioned in the Bible is the worst argument for anything I’ve heard in a long time! Yous will be reintroducing sacrifices and incense next week then! How silly of the Reformers, the Puritans and Spurgeon not to notice that there were instruments mentioned in the Bible…

Oh, and finally, no-one who’s church claims to believe in the WCF (ie any subscribing Presbyterian of any sort) can sit back and laugh at the RPs getting a kicking from Driscoll, cos at least he has the guts to come out and say that he thinks the Puritans were wrong whereas yous try and say you believe what they taught while your practice would suggest otherwise.

But a closing thought for RPs to take on board, based on one of his (well-founded) digs: If our worship isn’t enthusiastic and full of joy then it’s never going to make anyone sit up and say ‘this Regulative Principle thing might make sense after all’. And it won’t be glorifying to God either.

New Dromore site with bucketloads of sermons

dromore

DromoreRPC.org has now been redone, with about 80 new sermons by David McCullough (and a few public meetings) having been added to what was already there. The rest of David McCullough’s 5 years of sermons in Dromore will be added during the next few months, and weekly sermons will now be added, well, weekly. Also, the site is not yet completely finished so there should be a few more photos and things on it soon.

www.dromorerpc.org

Renwick 3 Derryvolgie 3

I feel your pain boys…
RENWICK STICKY PATCH CONTINUES AGAINST POUTING PRESBYTERIANS

Renwick’s indifferent start to 2008 continued this week at Ozone, in yet another edgy encounter with Derryvolgie, which resulted in a 3-3 draw. After defeat to The Monarchs and a tight draw with Union Theological College last week, the Boys from Brazil were keen to get back to winning ways this week, but couldn’t dig out a performance to do so. As has been the case in every match between these two teams so far, the match was marred somewhat by the attitude of the opposition when decisions went against them, which only added to the frustration of Renwick on a day when we simply failed to play to our best.
Both Conor Hyndman and Ian Dunwoody were unavailable this week – Conor for teaching placement and Ian for some rugger sport – but Peter Loughridge and Philip Moffett returned for another run-out. They made up this week’s midfield pairing, while Gavin started on the left wing, giving Andy Lynch the first half off to recover from a mile sprint earlier in the day. What an athlete. Mark McCavery once again moved heaven and earth to get to the match on time and played upfront.
The first half was a fairly dire one in all honesty. Renwick were in the ascendancy in the first few minutes, pushing on from midfield and putting some pressure on the DV back four without getting too many shots on goal. But against the run of play DV took an early lead, when a ball was played over the top from their midfield and gave their striker a one-on-one with Joel, who couldn’t get to the shot, which was well-hit. Frustrated with our lapse in concentration, we tried to attack with more urgency, but DV worked hard and turned it into a scrappy half. If we had been keeping count I’m sure we would have recorded more throw-ins in the half than in most of our previous matches put together. It all made for a disjointed, and ultimately poor game of football. We managed to equalise about halfway through the half, when P.Mo launched a throw into the box, and in the ensuing scramble the ball made its way to the far post where Ian Buchanan slotted in his twelfth of the season. We felt we’d been given our break and could start playing some football, but failed to register another goal in the half. We caused them problems at corners – Mark and Pete going close – but otherwise didn’t bother their keeper very much.
At half time Gareth Hughes and Andy Lynch replaced Pete McConaghie and Jonny McCollum at full back, Jonny taking the ref’s whistle despite the well-documented half he refereed last year between the two teams. We knew we weren’t at our best, and that we were a better team than DV. Our opening ten minutes in the second half were much better. We got a grip in midfield and played some nice football, feeding Gav and Phil on the wings and putting the ball into Ian and Mark’s feet more often. The next goal, however, came from a set piece. Phil launched in a corner from the left, which Pete met with a header into the top right corner of the net (though the usual suspects did try and claim a final touch on it!). The goal was a fair reflection of our start to the half, and once again we felt it would give us the boost to push on and put the match beyond DV. Once again we did not! After another scrappy period of play, in which Renwick failed to get tight to their men all over the pitch, DV went sniffing down the other end, and scored another scrambled goal, in a series of attempted clearances and deflections.
Then came our penalty. Up until then we had been surprised at this year’s DV side, since they had, for the most part, kept their mouths shut. But when Jonny, quite rightly, gave a penalty for a blatant hand ball in the area, they were up in arms for a good three or four minutes, complaining as loudly as possible about the decision. I could waste time explaining what they thought the rule was and what it actually is, but take my word for it, you’ve seen them given every week on Match of the Day and they had no grounds for complaint! So, despite shouts that we had ruined the match (a good attitude with twenty five minutes left to play and only one goal down), Steve McCollum stepped up and dispatched a great spot kick passed the keeper, his first strike of the season. DV managed to dry their eyes to restart the match, which saw neither side really gain the upper hand. Renwick did manage some nice passages of play now and then, none more so than when some good play by Pete and P.Mo in the middle put Gav through on the left wing. Gav got into a great position and put in a dangerous cross, with DV at sixes and sevens at the back. Unfortunately, the cross found only the Renwick number 7, who, in shocking Cristiano Ronaldo v Sheffield United-last-season-fashion, missed from about three yards, failing to keep the ball below the bar. As we say, that’s a mare.
So inevitably, having missed our chance to put the game to bed, and with Steve hobbling of injured with a bruised ankle, and DV desperate to take something from the game, our poor defending invited them onto us in the last ten minutes. Their number 10, needlessly wearing a pair of Edgar Davids goggles, was given far too much time and space on the edge of the box, and scored the goal of the game, a powerful shot straight into the top corner. He shouldn’t have been given the space, but it summed up our day really.
Always frustrating to lose to a team you know you could have beaten. Especially this team. Rumours are now abounding that the new kit is cursed, something team psychics are looking into. The only consolation we took was that, on the pitch opposite, World Eleven United, donned in our old kit, stumbled to a 5-3 defeat at the hands of Jordanstown. Yooo!

Team (4-4-2): J.Loughridge – P.McConaghie (for G.Hughes), S.McCollum (for P.McConaghie), A.McKelvey, J.McCollum (for A.Lynch) – P.Dunwoody (c), P.Loughridge, P.Moffett, G.Blackwell – M.McCavery, I.Buchanan

1

2

3

4

6

10

9

12

11

Galway Update Meetings

The best thing since sliced bread. Make sure and go to one. It’s in the West tonight, the South tomorrow night (I assume) and the North on Friday night, all at 8pm.

Including an update on the plan to present the Gaelic version of Ultimate Questions to the First & Deputy First Ministers. G!

In other Galway-related news, Billy Hamilton’s “Take a Risk” talk from the GO Rally in January is now available.

What is Reformed Presbyterianism?

(From the Defence & Exposition of Reformed Presbyterianism by Rev. Mark Loughridge at the installation of Rev. Blair McFarland in Bready, 29 December 2007. The audio of Stuart Olyott’s sermons from the installation and the next day are now available at www.breadyrpc.org. Video coming soon. The quality of it all isn’t great though.)

Renwick 2 – 2 Union

Steelo’s notes:
– First ever all RP team. Yooo!! If only we’d realised at the time!
– Given recent news reports, we were expecting Union to field an all-girls team. However it turned out that the only thing to worry Stafford was a guy with long hair and a bandanna.
– PS: Phil I’ll have you know my goal was from at least 3 yards!! :-P And you forgot PMO’s header! And mine cleared off the line!

Phil’s report:
RENWICK 2 UNION THEOLOGICAL COLLEGE 2

Renwick were held to a 2-2 draw this week, in a friendly against Union Theological College at Ozone. With the league organisers failing to update results or provide a fixture list for the week (worryingly, it was at about this stage last year that the organisation of the league went to pieces), competitors were left to their own devices if they wanted some football. Graham of Union sent round a circular text, and Renwick were the first to reply, and so here we are.
Once again there were some selection problems in midfield and attack for the RP lads – ALL RP lads, possibly for the first time… Ian Buchanan and Gareth Hughes were the earliest withdrawals, and were followed by Peter Henderson and Andy McKelvey, both of whom were ill. Desperate times call for Steelo and Philip Moffet, so we called them. Philip was delighted to make his Renwick debut, having played against us twice for the ministers (none of whom called to protest at the move). Gavin returned for another outing in a Renwick shirt, and this time started on the right wing. Mark McCavery, determined to maintain his record of most appearances for the team, made it from Bangor to Belfast in record time for kick off. With no Skills Buchanan or P10 McKelvey, Phil moved up front with Steelo, and Phil M subbed for the first half.
All the disruption, and the late arrival of half the team, contributed to a rather lame first half performance by the boys in yellow. Union had been ready to go for about twenty minutes, and had plenty of motivation to get one over their RP rivals, after we beat them 2-0 in the league earlier in the season. As a result they were by far the sharper team in the first twenty minutes. They created a number of half chances and played some nice football. Their first goal, however, was more a result of a mix up at the back coupled with a lucky bounce for their attacker. Renwick failed to clear and the ball was stabbed home from close range, to give Union what was probably a deserved lead. The second twenty/twenty five minutes of the half did not produce anymore goals. Renwick began to get more adventurous in attack, but the ball wasn’t sticking upfront and Union’s midfield worked hard to cut out our passes. Apart from a few shots from distance we didn’t really trouble their keeper. Despite this, Union did not press on and build on their lead, and seemed to think the game was already won. It was 1-0 at the break.
At half time Philip Moffett made his debut, as we changed things around to try and offer more in attack. He came on the middle, with Phil D going back to his usual place on the right and Mark going upfront to give their centre halves something to worry about. We knew if we got more physical Union would be frustrated and there would be greater opportunity to play our football.
Almost immediately the changes worked. Phil M had a great performance in the middle, and Phil D provided more of an outlet on the right. Mark was troubling the defence and the combination put us in the ascendancy in the first few minutes. Our equaliser came when Conor played a ball over the top which Phil D ran onto against the keeper, who missed the ball entirely and gave Phil a virtual open net to shoot into. We felt we’d been given our break and tried to push on for the lead.
Unfortunately this didn’t really happen. We were certainly playing better than in the first half but couldn’t get the final pass. At the other end our defence was playing well – Pete and Jonny gave great performances against two tricky Union wingers, and Steve and Ian were solid in the middle, closing down strikers and making clearances. It would take something special for Union to get another, but they stepped up after about twenty minutes. Their right winger got half a yard out wide and put in a cross which their forward met with a fantastic header which gave Joel no chance. It was a reminder to us that we still hadn’t played our best in the game, and we pushed on with greater effort as a result. Philip and Conor were fantastic in central midfield, working hard to feed the wingers and forwards. We had a couple of half chances and good shots, but the equaliser, again, was a combination of good pressure and poor goal-keeping. Phil D got the ball out wide, and thumped in a high ball towards the far post to put the keeper under pressure. He came to meet it but missed, with Andy Lynch and Steelo waiting to pounce. It was the latter who got the final touch, knocking it in from half a yard in typical fashion!
The last fifteen minutes saw the teams locked in stalemate; Union were dangerous on the counter and Renwick always looked dangerous in attack. Both teams had a number of corners and free kicks (there were a few minor skirmishes on and off the ball!) but neither were clinical in front of goal, and a draw was probably a fair result in what was a strange game, from a Renwick point of view.
Given the circumstances we weren’t entirely disappointed, and it was good to play a in a tough match ahead of our last few league matches. Some would say it is a little worrying that no difference could be found between the RPs and Union, but we can console ourselves with our league victory over them earlier in the year. Mention must be given to P.Mo, who told me he had been waiting a long time for his call-up, and did not disappoint when thrown into midfield. Same time next week Phil!

Team (4-4-2): J.Loughridge – P.McConaghie, I.Dunwoody, S.McCollum, J.McCollum – G.Blackwell (P.Moffett, ht), P.Dunwoody, M.McCavery, A.Lynch – C.Hyndman, S.Steele (r: G.Blackwell, 85)

Photos (thanks again to Bob P)

2
Steve diving header – wasn’t as good as their’s for the second goal

3
Similar to GO team t-shirts, Steelo couldn’t resist the opportunity to try out the new kit

4
According to James, this is called ‘hyperextension’. Looks painful

5
Gav about to get crunched

6
A Lynch Mob

10
Getting the tackles in

11
Dodgy

12
Nice wee blur thing going on there

13
Sporticus

15
Great shot of PMO!

16
Back on the wing

1
“It’s just like watching Brazil”