Driscoll on The job of church leaders & the Regulative Principle


(whole sermon)

“I hate religion. Religion assumes that you don’t want to do certain things and so we have to make you do them…Religion assumes that you want to do evil, and we’re going to MAKE YOU do good. That’s not what we believe as Christians. We believe that God gives us new hearts so we want to obey him. Therefore Christianity, the church, Christian friends, Bible teachers – our job is not to make you do something you don’t want to do, but to help you do something that you want to do…It means you don’t have to do new things, it means you get to do new things. It doesn’t mean that religion is about what you don’t get to do, Christianity is about what you do get to do…It’s about following your deepest and strongest desires, in your new heart that Jesus gave you.”

“For the desires of the flesh are against the Spirit, and the desires of the Spirit are against the flesh, for these are opposed to each other, to keep you from doing the things you want to do.” Galations 5:17

“The Christian doesn’t want to lie, doesn’t want to steal, doesn’t want to commit adultery, doesn’t want to lust, doesn’t want to believe error, doesn’t want to walk in darkness. Doesn’t want to. You need to know that. Now your flesh, your Adamic rebellion in you (that will be dealt with finally once and for all at the end) is still there giving you conflicted desires, but your deepest desire is to do the things you want to do. God gives you His desires.”

And on the Regulative Principle
(I didn’t mean this to be this long. This is not an attack! Mark still rocks my world!)


(whole sermon

And then last Sunday he did his long-awaited (from me and John G anyway) sermon on the Regulative Principle. It was the final question in a series (originally) called ‘Ask Anything’. People were allowed to submit questions and vote on them on his church website, and he preached on the top 9 in descending order. And number 1 was the Regulative Principle. So with a due sense of dread and foreboding (because I didn’t expect him to be in favour of it, because if he did a lot of things at Mars Hill would have to change) I listened to it. Also foreboding cos I thought he might fall of the list of my favourite people afterwards! However he’s still right up there. As expected, he didn’t have much time for it (especially things like psalms-only and instruments, which in most places outside Scotland are RP distinctives), but it was still pretty funny and still had some good things it in. For example, he explained the difference between the Regulative Principle and the Normative Principle very well: with the RP (can’t be bothered typing ‘Regulative Principle’ multiple times, hopefully you’ll not all be confused) you have a red light until you see a green light (ig find something in the bible); but the normative principle you assume you have a green light until you see a red light.

However considering how many people voted (thousands like) for that question to be number 1, and how many in church history (including most of his religious heroes) believed in the regulative principle, he could of put in a bit more effort.

The first bit was great. (Apart from him saying that it was an important question cos millions of people worship God – whereas I would say it is an important question because God is important). He basically preached in favour of the RP in the first while. Nadab and Abihu and all that. An RP (as in Reformed Presbyterian) minister would have been proud to preach it! But then he says that he believes in both the Regulative Principle AND the Normative Principle. Which is just silly, because they’re mutually exclusive. But by the end of it he was basically in favour of the normative principle. And then he started going on about a ‘hard’ and a ‘soft’ regulative principle (legalists like us who don’t believe in instruments and hymns would be ‘hard’) – but of course you either have the RP or you don’t. Either it is commanded in the Bible or it’s forbidden. No in between.

His 3 main problems with the RP were:
1. Worship is all of life. This separates it. As soon as you walk in the door of the church everything changes. You don’t get up in the morning and say ‘I can’t brush my teeth cos it’s not in the Bible’.
2. “It doesn’t answer all the questions like technology, announcements and seating” – and it leads to legalistic applications (that’s us he’s pointing at).
3. People who hold to the RP tend not to be biblical. Ig people don’t say amen (1 Cor 14:16), people don’t lift their hands in worship (Ps 63:4, Ps 134:2), men don’t lift their hands in prayer (1 Tim 2:8), and people don’t clap their hands in worship (Ps 47:1, 98:8)

To which I would respond:
1. Well, I’ll actually let John Knox answer it. From his first public debate (1547), right at the start of his ministry. Very similarly to Driscoll, he was asked if people couldn’t even ask for a drink without a direct command from God. Here is the 2nd part of his response:

“The question was not, nor is not, of meat or drink, whereunto the kingdom of God consists not (Rom. 14:17); but the question is of God’s true worshipping, without the which we can have no society with God. And, here it is doubted, if we may take the same freedom in the using of Christ’s sacraments, that we may do in eating and drinking. One meat I may eat, another I may refuse, and that without scruple of conscience. I may change one with another, as oft as I please. Whither may we do the same in matters of religion? May we cast away what we please, and retain what we please? If it be well remembered, Moses, in the name of God, says to the people of Israel, ‘All that the Lord thy God commands thee to do, that do thou to the Lord thy God: Add nothing to it; diminish nothing from it’ (cf. Deut. 12:32; 12:8). By this rule, think I, the kirk of God will measure God’s religion, and not by that which seems good in their own eyes.”

So if all of life is worship then we could do whatever we wanted in communion and it would still be worship – obviously no-one’s going to argue for that…
And it’s all very well saying ‘all life is worship’ (which always sounds very convincing) but it clearly wasn’t in the Old Testament at least. If it was, Nadab and Abihu could just have said ‘Ah well, all of life is worship’. If all of life is worship (in that sense) then verses such as Deut 12:32 make no sense.

2. Announcements are not worship. Duh. You should try going to an RP service. Seats & technology: The Westminster Divines made an important distinction between elements and circumstances of worship. You’re a smart guy. Go and look it up.

3. He’s got (most of) us on the amen bit. If you don’t say Amen at the end of prayers, you’re not biblical, you’re not keeping to the regulative principle and you’re therefore (surely?) sinning. Lifting hands – anyone want to explain that one? Clap – well the second verse is about rivers, and we’re not rivers. And if you take Ps 47:1 literally it means you have to shout as well. Not saying you shouldn’t, just pointing it out…

And finally, his arguments against what’s closest to home:
Psalms: Other people sang songs in the Bible. The psalms say sing a new song. You can’t sing the name of Jesus. ‘Breakfast, lunch and dinner’ doesn’t mean ‘breakfast, breakfast, breakfast’.
Instruments: Instruments are in the Bible (all over the psalms) therefore instruments are Biblical. When you get to Heaven, Jesus is going to hand you a harp. Then people that hold a ‘hard’ Reg Principle will have a bit of a dilemma. They’ll say to Jesus ‘We don’t do bands’ and he’ll say ‘Well you do me, so strum!’

None of his arguments for psalms are new, so no need to reply to them. They’ve all been covered by others before. Suffice to say that in the funny but cheap dig at our interpretation of Eph 5:19 and Col 3:16 he’s also getting at the Westminster Divines, John Owen etc etc. And while ‘breakfast, breakfast, breakfast’ doesn’t mean the same thing, for example ‘in his law and in his statutes and in his testimonies’ (Jer 44:23) do. (Of course, those aren’t the main reasons for why the 3 words mean what we call psalms)
Music: Well yes the bit I quoted is of course hilarious, but saying that something is ‘biblical’ just because it’s mentioned in the Bible is the worst argument for anything I’ve heard in a long time! Yous will be reintroducing sacrifices and incense next week then! How silly of the Reformers, the Puritans and Spurgeon not to notice that there were instruments mentioned in the Bible…

Oh, and finally, no-one who’s church claims to believe in the WCF (ie any subscribing Presbyterian of any sort) can sit back and laugh at the RPs getting a kicking from Driscoll, cos at least he has the guts to come out and say that he thinks the Puritans were wrong whereas yous try and say you believe what they taught while your practice would suggest otherwise.

But a closing thought for RPs to take on board, based on one of his (well-founded) digs: If our worship isn’t enthusiastic and full of joy then it’s never going to make anyone sit up and say ‘this Regulative Principle thing might make sense after all’. And it won’t be glorifying to God either.

12 thoughts on “Driscoll on The job of church leaders & the Regulative Principle”

  1. This comment has nothing to do with the regulative principle. It’s just to point out that you wrote “could of put more effort in”. Could OF?! Come on Steelo, teachers everywhere are having heart attacks!

  2. Nice post, Steele. I’ve only recently discovered Driscoll and have listened to a couple of the sermons in this series ‘Religion Saves and Nine Other Misconceptions’.

    Whitla said he’s called the ‘cussing pastor’. I haven’t heard any swears in the few sermons that I’ve listened to, but I guess he believes that he can use colorful language because it’s in the Bible; another example of the “it’s in the Bible, so it’s biblical!”-argument.

    I want to hear his sermon on the emergent church. Guys like Rob Bell are getting big around Geneva with non-RPs.

  3. He doesn’t swear in sermons. He got labelled the ‘cussing pastor’ ages ago, but has since repented, I’m sure somebody can find the link and post it.

    Sure Geneva could introduce a ‘Major’ on the Emergent Church to go with their one on Youth Ministry :D And their hymns…

  4. The reference to “lifting up holy hands” in 1 Tim. 2 refers to ministers pronouncing a benediction. Hence, in the closing prayer you often notice that the minister raises his hands.

  5. a few things
    cussing pastor came about from Don Miller – Blue Like Jazz – it happened while he was younger, he does not do so as much now. Piper has sworn too (Grudem wrote and chastised him). Scripture does give a very earthy sense by using words that are only expressed in English as swear ones. This shows that God is here to save us even when our garments are clothed in human feces (Zechariah 3). Dale Ralph Davis shows this well too in judges.

    a few things about the sermon.
    1. Driscoll raised some issues, even if they received answers ages ago, we do have a brotherly duty to ask the question why is this brother not heeding this truth? We should pray and beg ourselves not to reply, “it is hardness of heart.” We need to take his objections seriously- if we are satisfied by them fine, but we need to ask.

    2. about the raising hands, clapping, etc. those are biblical, and yes they are associated with charistmatics, but hey we are not perfect and we are not the only brothers and sisters out there. We have a lot to learn from one another. (Frame makes this point in Evangelical Reunion)
    For an explanation on the physical expression in worship I refer you to Bob Kauflin’s Worship Matter’s blogsite. (worshipmatters.com under must reads)

  6. “whereas yous try and say you believe what they taught while your practice would suggest otherwise.”

    There are lots of WCF people that don’t hold to Accapella Psalmody. Infact the major of the people that hold to the WCF would disagree with the RP’s when in comes to what we can play and sing in church.

  7. Hi Sam

    As I tried to comment on your blog yesterday (but it wouldn’t let me due to some anti-spam word? – no idea what that could be!! will try and post what I don’t cover here later):

    Those who wrote the WCF and who framed the Regulative Principle in the confession understood it to mean psalms only and no instruments. This can be shown from their practice and other writings, as well as what the WCF actually says (ie it lists the parts of worship, and includes ‘singing of psalms with grace in the heart’ (with Col 3:16 and Eph 5:19 as proof texts) but doesn’t include hymns. And the very idea of Puritans using instruments in worship is just unthinkable.

    So many may SAY the hold to the WCF, but if they aren’t acappella psalmody they aren’t holding to it, as it was understood by those who wrote it. Driscoll understood this – which was why he targetted acapella psalmody and not mainstream Presbyterians today.

  8. It seems odd that you pick and chose who you like. The Puritans and the Divines are not synonymous. It is true that the WCF says that we are to sing psalms with grace in the heart, yet that alone does not mean that they were arguing for Exclusive Psalmody. Should we take the WCF statement of what we can sing here as our sole instruction about congregational singing? If I were to sing the Psalms with love rather that grace would I be in sin?
    Frankly it is ungracious to suggest that any church that does not singing Psalms to the exclusion of everything else, doesn’t hold to the WCF.

  9. “It is true that the WCF says that we are to sing psalms with grace in the heart, yet that alone does not mean that they were arguing for Exclusive Psalmody. ”

    Brother, the Westminster Divines also produced a Directory for Public Worship, which only indicates that the psalms were to be sung in worship. Moreover, they themselves translated a Psalter which became the famous Scottish Metrical Version; this version does not include anything but the 150 psalms.

    “Frankly it is ungracious to suggest that any church that does not singing Psalms to the exclusion of everything else, doesn’t hold to the WCF.”

    We are not saying that those of differing opinions are completely against the WCF, but just inconsistent with its teaching on this single point.

Comments are closed.