Share of the Spoils leaves Ministers more satisfied in Annual Showdown

by Joel and Phil

Renwick FC failed to overcome the RP Ministers XI for the second year in a row last Wednesday, with the sixth annual Jonny McCollum cup ending in a goalless draw at the Ozone. It was the third time Renwick have failed to overcome the motley crew, and means that Renwick are yet to win the cup this decade.

One year on from their famous victory, the transfers of legendary goalkeeper Lytle to FC Nantes and the loan signing of Peter Loughridge to the Scottish RPC Ministers XI had left the ministers in a weakened position. Stalwarts PMo, Aggers and Prof Bill Wilson were joined by the 2011 RTC intake (except Pual who was working on his Hebrew) and guest ministers Rev McCavery and Rev Dr McKelvey. Last year’s goal scoring hero Reuben Agnew also returned. As did Tim McCollum, another veteran of last year’s implausible victory. Due to a kit clash the Ministers turned out in the iconic Outer Fenn kits, which made their debut in the inaugural Jonny McCollum Cup. Mark complained that his number 9 shirt had been shrunk since he last pulled it on, and bizarrely, Cream Bun played the whole match wearing nothing but a skin-tight thermal top. Before kick-off Nigel led us in the traditional pre-match prayer, despite Renwick’s attempts to do away with the practice.

As a spectacle, the match was a mixed affair. Renwick started brightly and played to their strengths, with tidy passing and sharp runs off the ball. Though they threatened down the flanks several times in the opening exchanges, they were unable to provide any real fire-power in the final third, where Aggers and Mark were giving very little away. C Robert came closest for Renwick and perhaps should have at least hit the target when the ball dropped to him 12 yards out. While the Ministers were relatively untroubled in terms of clear shots at goal, they too were unable to exert much pressure on Renwick keeper J McCullough. Nathan, Nigel and Mark all had speculative efforts from corners but none troubled the keeper. As the game progressed the Minister’s organisation at set plays began to cause confusion and panic in the Renwick defence. The qatal and shalom balls in particular being executed to great effect. In contrast, Royston sent the Wellhausen ball straight into touch, right where it belongs. Cream Bun’s guided missiles also caused moments of worry in the student’s defence, and the students had B Hanna to thank for confidently dealing with many of these. With several substitutes to choose from, the Ministers’ in-game rotation policy tended to slow the game down, and perhaps disrupted Renwick’s game. Slowing the pace is a traditional tactic of the Ministers, yet perhaps the strangest incident of the first half was Joel’s warning for time wasting in the opening 10 minutes. Late in the half Ben Hanna Captain had a clear header from a corner blocked before skying the rebound, (which he apparently thought he had beaten the keeper with). But they were unable to break the deadlock, and cut a frustrated group when P Fallows slyly indicated the close of the half.

With Steelo urging on the nahars play got underway in the second half. Renwick once again threatened several times early on. Though the ministers held firm and tried to counter-attack (despite their ever decreasing pace and increasing tendency to hack the ball away), B Hanna and Spaniard R Abella were giving nothing away in their danger area. Renwick manfully persevered in trying to play the Barca way, building from the back, but they rarely made inroads to the sturdily guarded nether regions of the minsters’ defence of orthodoxy. With tension building, a few tasty tackles were handed out by both sides, and both had strong shouts for penalties waved away by referee and match sponsor Jonny McCollum. All day the students struggled to cope with playing in a man’s world and did plenty of whining about challenges. This even continued after the game when, with disgust, it was noted that one Renwick player even had scrapes down their leg! Who would have thought that in the modern era a player might carry some physical marks after a football match?

The minister’s probably had the better of the second half chances, and definitely finished the game the stronger side. An incisive pass played in Steelo with the sort of chance which he would have shinned/toe-poked/butted into the net back in his heyday, but he couldn’t latch onto it on this occasion. Phil had a quality free-kick palmed away by J McCullough, who recovered before Mark could drive it home. Cream Bun, master of hitting a ball hard in the right general direction, pinged one from 30 yards only for a slight deflection to push it off the far post and away. At the other end M Hawthorne, non-Rev P Murphy and P Aicken all had chances, but the clerics’ presuppositional defence proved too strong for the Renwick attack and we never really got to see if it was Royston or Maik in nets.

For the last five minutes, Mark went upfront for the Reverends, and B Hanna did likewise for Renwick. Mark’s presence had an instant impact and perhaps this could have been the game-changer if the ministers had made the switch earlier. With literally the last kick of the game Phil latched onto a loose ball and lobbed it beyond J McCullough. Fourteen ministers, would-be ministers, friends of ministers and brothers of ministers watched with bated breath, ready to go delirious with the victory, only to watch his effort bounce off the top corner of the woodwork. Moments later, in a moment of great poignancy, Jonny McCollum blew time on the Jonny McCollum cup. Eager to avoid further embarrassment Renwick declined the option of non-binding penalties. Emma Dunwoody, photographer extraordinaire for the afternoon, snapped the team picture.

Outstanding performers were B Hanna and P Aicken for the young lads. However the plaudits go to the Ministers, for whom the draw is as good as a victory. Aggers was outstanding as usual and pastors Mark and Andy put in great shifts also. Cream Bun and Pmo both deserve mentions for fine performances. But the man of the match accolade goes to Nathan. A tireless shift in the centre of the park involved plenty of tracking midfield runners and covering both flanks, where Renwick were particularly threatening. Credit also goes to Phil for his insight and tactical nous in his first year having over managerial duties from the exiled Peter Loughridge.

By and by the day was, in essence, another victory for the Clerics. If Renwick are like England – joyless and underachieving – the Ministers are like Man United – over achieving in recent years despite limited players.

The Jonny McCollum Cup is shelved for another year, but much to the annoyance of Renwick FC, it bears the name of the Ministers XI for the second year running.

Teams:

Minsiters XI (4-2-Peti-3): J. Loughridge – J. McCollum, N. Agnew, M. McCavery, J. Blair – A. McKelvey, N. Hawthorne, P. Baijko – P. Dunwoody, P. Moffett, S. Steele. Subs: R. Agnew, N. Wilson, T. McCollum.

Renwick (4-3-3): J. McCullough – L. Campbell, R. Abella, B. Hanna, A. McCollum – M. Hawthorne, G. Blackwell, I. Buchanan – P. Murphy, R. Cromie, P. Aicken. Subs: P. Fallows, A. Morrison, D. Lynch, P. Neilly

Photos to come when Ben gets back from Dubai!

Related posts: Battle Lines Drawn for Annual Epic

Battle Lines Drawn for Annual Epic

P. Dunwoody and J. Loughridge preview tomorrow’s big match:

The 2012 encounter between Renwick and the Ministers looks set to be the most exciting in the six year history of the fixture. Back when Joel Loughridge, along with Philip Dunwoody, Jonny McCollum, Stephen Steele and several other would-be clerics turned out for Renwick, they thumped the RP ministers two years in a row. Hammerings were the order of the day in this fixture. The ministers couldn’t believe the fact that they held on for a draw in 2009 but 2010 saw the Revs raise their game remarkably only for their fitness to cost them the match. Then that memorable first victory arrived last year, Renwick’s greatest ever player manager, Philip Dunwoody, slotting home the winner with 3 minutes to go.

DSC02346-1024

Most of the RTC class of 2011 have tasted victory in this fixture before, being part of the legendary Renwick teams and last year’s heroic men of the cloth. Loughridge said “Some of us have won this match several times before, we’re not under any pressure this year”. Another former Renwick player who will be turning out on the opposing side this year, Stephen Steele, added: “We may not have much match fitness, and we haven’t really played football for a year or more now but the odds are still fairly good for one going in off my knee.”

Professor WNS “Bill” Wilson himself added: “Those who are in goal are not the same as those who fly up the right wing”.

Ministers’ manager Dunwoody is keeping his formation, line-up, tactics and Systematic Theology Research Project a closely guarded secret this year, but he did hint that there might be a few surprises in the Ministers’ starting XI. “Thierry Henry and Paul Scholes got me thinking”, he said. Fascinating stuff. Such talk also begs the question as to whether any of Shaftesbury’s clergy will feature.

A year has passed since McCullough and Hanna became the first manager and captain to do the impossible and fail the only test that really matters. But they managed to weather that storm. One year on no win, no matter how big, can erase the painful memories. There can be no talk of revenge, only the restoration of the natural order. The Revs will simply be happy to know that last year they tasted glory. As the Saw Docs sang: “To win just once – that would be enough”. Job done.

Ministers 2 Renwick 1

– 1st ever Jonny McCollum cup without its eponymous hero. At his request it has been re-dubbed the Jonny McCollum Memorial Cup.
– 1st time 3 brothers have lined up in the same team in the competition.
– 1st father-son combination in a starting line-up
– 1st time the Ministers have ever won outright.

The Jonny McCollum Memorial Cup is in the hands of the Ministers tonight after they triumphed over Renwick for the first time in the five year history of the showpiece competition this afternoon. Unbelievably it was ex-Renwick supremo Phil Dunwoody who got the winner three minutes from time to hand victory to Peter Loughridge’s men and ensure that the current Renwick team will be remembered as the first ever team to lose the competiton.

Trailing 1-0 at half-time following a strike from Ali McCollum after 15 minutes, the Ministers got back into the match on 55 minutes thanks to junior Minister Reuben Agnew, setting the stage for Dunwoody to pop up in the 87th minute to grab the winner.

Full report to follow in next 364 days…


MINISTERS:
A Lytle; P Moffett; N Agnew (capt), P Loughridge, C Bun; P Dunwoody, S McCollum, R McCollum, R Agnew; T McCollum (kindly granted on loan), J Loughridge

RENWICK: J McCullough; L Campbell, C Carson, B Hanna, A McCollum; C Robert, M Hawthorne, P Fallows, P Aicken; C Joel, A Devenney
Subs: A Rolleston, A McKelvey, A Morrison, R McCaughan

Minister’s match report!

by our Special Correspondents

As part of the build up to the annual Johnny McCollum cup SWS presents official match coverage from last season…better late than never:

DSC02346-1024

The long-awaited day had finally come…college classes on Dispensationalism, Marx, Hegel, Feuerbach and Dialectical Materialism. Those RTC students who felt they had mastered these topics in the morning then made their way to the Ozone to be joined by ministers, short-term servants and RTC auditors past and present for the equally demanding task of facing a rampant Renwick House FC with 6 wins and 53 goals under their belts already in their league season.

The Ministers were even bigger underdogs than they are every year because of a squad severely depleted in the weeks running up to the match, with a variety of reasons offered for a large number of men being unavailable. The Ministers were deprived of 4 key players: the machine like winger Billy Hamilton; Simon Sweeney (who has been AWOL since he entered the Southern Presbytery); the endless running of Robb Robb (so good they named him twice like Eric Djemba Djemba); and the finest right winger in the denomination. Also, with David McCullough turning down the opportunity to be the first serving Moderator to represent the team, the captain’s armband went to the veteran Prof Wilson. Rev Bun, with more caps for the Ministers than most ministers, was joined on the left flank by new signing Jonny McCollum. Rev Cromie, qualifying through his maternal grandfather, signed up just before kick off after the late withdrawal of Rev Sutherland – who commendably pulled out in order to go and evangelise someone. Rev Cromie was a constant threat with his energetic running and honourably chose to keep the white shirt on for 90 minutes rather than exchange it for a black one at half time. Rev PMO’s Cullybackey-isation continued with him sporting a large beard, and was even heard to declare one pass “pure wick brilliant”.

DSC02151-1024
Donegal’s finest export since Daniel O’Donnell

With the crowd chanting “there’s only 2 Robert McCollums”, Strob Jnr let the students know immediately that they were in a man’s world – munching Andy Lynch in the first 5 seconds. Early on in the game Aggers asked Renwick talisman McCavery to get into his pocket and he duly obliged. The Ministers had the best of the early exchanges. Andy Lytle’s big kicks were asking questions of the Renwick back four and they can only hope they answered better in their January exams. Cromie Robert in particular was causing problems and had the first real chance of the match. Strob with a big tackle won possession back, then played an exquisite ball through the Renwick back four. Cromie’s excellent first touch took him past G Smith and the Donegal man fired off a shot, but the jungle-haired goalkeeper pulled off a fine full length save. The rebound fell to the lurking J Loughridge who closed his eyes and took a swing with his not-so-trusty left peg. The shot beat defender and goalkeeper, heading for the onion bag until Gareth Smith appeared out of nowhere and shinned it clear. An aStute clearance by the big man and a key moment in the match.

DSC02185-1024
Could have gone anywhere…but so close to taking the lead

Shortly after, and against the run of play, four or five Renwick players broke through the Ministers’ apologetic, with the ball eventually being slipped to an unmarked Ian Buchanan who calmly sidefooted home from 10 yards. The Ministers were still well in the game and had several half chances; including a fizzing, outside of the boot, half-volley by Jonny. Also, some weak refereeing turned down an opportunistic penalty appeal. Instead, young Carson followed many higher level referees by giving the goalkeeper an inordinate amount of protection following a totally fair tackle by Cromie.

DSC02189-1024
The falcon attacks

Right on the blow for HT the Ministers conceded a sloppy and disappointing goal. Poor marking at a corner allowed Tim McCollum to flick in a fairly tame finish at the front post, continuing a prolific scoring run for the finest of the three McCollum brothers. The half-time whistle sounded immediately as the ball rested in the back of the net, causing more than a few questioning glances from the Ministers team to the ref! Maybe a touch of ‘Fergie Time’ played?!

DSC02254-1024
Tim knocks in number 2 (in the 52nd minute of the first half!)

This goal was a massive blow to The Revs who had undeniably had the better of the first half yet found themselves 2 goals down. Big Lytle kicks were causing problems deep in the Renwick half. Jonny was out skillzing Skillz. Bun Delap’s big throws and Dowie’s flick-ons caused panic. Strob and Bajko were making the students’ midfield look petty. McCaughan would have been better off going to one of Prof Norris’ classes than taking him on down the flank and Aggers was typically taking no nonsense. All that was missing was a goal, thanks to G Smith’s go-go-gadget leg.

At half time Rev PMO finally succumbed to the injury he’d been struggling with all week. This was another big loss for the Ministers as the BDC attacking triumvirate of Moffett, J Loughridge and C Robert had been causing Renwick considerable problems down their left hand side. Rev Hanna donned the vacated no.10 shirt (but didn’t fill it) and went to left wing, with Jonny McCollum switching flanks from left to right to fill the ample gap left by his minister.

DSC02281-1024
Stevie plotting how to bag Cyprus for STS

Ben’s replacement for Renwick was Ali G and his first involvement in the game was to have dirt kicked in his eye. No mercy from the Ministers, even in a friendly. Though Ali G did recover and went on to make some key interceptions in the match.

Early in the second half the Clergy finally got the reward their pressure deserved. Rev Hanna floated over a lovely coconut and Peter stuck it in the bag with all the other nuts; the Ministers now very much back in the game.

The Ministers continued to have the better of the play and chances until mid-way through the second half, with constant hustle and bustle unsettling the students. However, around the 65min mark they conceded possession and allowed Mark Porter to run at the defence, who beat Lytle’s dive with a fine low strike from just outside the box.

Spurred on by younger legs and rolling subs Renwick took advantage of tiring legs in the Ministers team with two late strikes. Dunwoody’s shot was well blocked on the edge of the area but fell to McCaughan. Weary defenders allowed the young architect too much space, with which he designed a cool and precise effort curled into Lytle’s bottom left corner. It was a killer blow, particularly for the seasoned fullback who had shackled him so well earlier in the day (see the match highlights for his clear disappointment).

Retiring captain Phil Dunwoody was dying for a goal to end a fine career with. However, few chances came his way, apart from one through ball which, with the defence opened before him, he just couldn’t bring under control. However, it was fitting that he had a big hand in the final goal of the game. Chasing a lost cause down the right he somehow kept the ball in on the touchline, before bravely winning a 50-50 with Bunzilla and then supplying a delightful low cross into the six yard box for the waiting McCaughan to tap in (despite his best attempts to put it over from point blank range). The aged Renwick hero got the reception his service deserved when he was applauded off and given a standing ovation by both fans and players.

DSC02290-1024
Renwick legend

The game finished 5-1, the scoreline definitely not reflecting the game. This was probably the Ministers’ most accomplished performance, even better than their famous 1-1 draw. Had the Ministers got the first goal or not conceded at the end of the first half it could have been a different story. Renwick got quite a scare but eventually delivered no less than the bare minimum expected. Despite not playing their best football of the season, energy and experience shone through eventually. A great game, well played by both sides, and the photos show how much everyone enjoyed it, even if the spirit of Simon Curry was mysteriously channelled into them. So that makes it 3 from 4 Jonny McCollum cups for Renwick, and no defeats. A proud record indeed. The tension grows every year. Who will be the first Ministers team to win it outright? Who will be the first Renwick team ever to lose it?

DSC02414-1024
For Simon

RENWICK: J McCullough; A Morrison, S McCollum, G Smith, B Hanna; P Dunwoody, A Lynch, A McKelvey, R McCaughan; I Buchanan, M McCaverey

Subs: P Aicken, T McCollum, C Carson, M Porter, A Rolleston, D Smith

MINISTERS: A Lytle; N Wilson, P Loughridge, N Agnew, C Bun; J McCollum, R McCollum, P Baijko; P Moffett, C Robert, J Loughridge

More photos

Previous years:
2010 Preview
2009 Report: Renwick 1 – 1 Ministers
2008 Report: Renwick 6 – 0 Ministers
2007 Report: Renwick 9 – 4 Ministers

Call for Ministers

Update: The Renwick manager has been in touch to confirm that the match will take place at the Ozone, with kick off about 2:30pm. I realised last night that I’d done basically a whole post about Peter and forgot to slag off his age – sorry about that. Loughridge, 35, was also in touch today to note that “Your post doesn’t even mention the date you plonker!”. So yeah, it’s Wednesday 27th January! He also clarified that “‘Ministers’ is a loose term referring to ministers, mission workers, RTC students, RTC auditors past and present, Short-Term Servants past and present, or anyone with a general interest in theology!” Anyone interested in playing can contact Peter by email (peterloughridge at hotmail.com) or c/o RTC, Knockbracken most mornings of the week.

16norrislaughing
“Where have they gone?”

Just two weeks remain before the most anticipated football match in Ireland in 2010 so far (mainly as all the others have been called off), the annual match between Renwick and the RP Ministers, affectionately (and officially) known as the Jonny McCollum cup.

With the match approaching fast, and being eagerly anticipated by schoolboys and future Nant�s missionaries alike, ministers supremo Peter Loughridge has issued a call for ministers to contact him if they want to play.

2philtakenoutbygeorge

After humiliating 9-4 and 6-0 reverses, the ministers could have won it last year but in the end had to settle for a draw. However Renwick have been recording some very impressive results so far this season, so Loughridge, fresh from a successful trial last week, will have a big task on his hands to rally the troops.

6pmo_mckelvey

There was huge tension in the build-up to last year’s match, which hasn’t quite been replicated this year, although Loughridge has tried to stoke the flames by billing the clash as a SWS v AK on-pitch battle, and chose to advertise the need for ministers on here as “all serious thinkers favour SWS over other up and coming wannabe RP blogs”.

Last year’s late addition to the ministry, Pierre, will be unavailable due to Africa Cup of Nations duty. Meanwhile, last year’s minister’s joint manager, Joel Loughridge, got married in the intervening period and hasn’t been heard from since…

Previous encounters:
2007: Renwick 9 – 4 Ministers
2008: Renwick 6 – 0 Ministers
2009: Renwick 1 – 1 Ministers

The infamous profiles posts:
Ministers
Renwick

As SWS has secured exclusive rights to the ministers’ match and the annual awards dinner, you will be able to find a full report here afterwards!

Resurgent Ministers held to draw by Renwick

For the first time ever the Jonny McCollum Cup didn’t return to Elmwood Avenue after the Ministers shocked pundits to earn a battling draw with undefeated Belfast Super League outfit Renwick this afternoon. The Ministers, College Students and Short Term Servants XI were hit by the late withdrawal of star striker, Moderator and Captain, the Very (as he would be known in some circles!) Rev. D. Fallows, but pulled off a deadline day coup to secure the services of Renwick veteran Steelo on loan for the day. Ex-moderator Prof. Wilson took over the armband and the Ministers’ tacticians, the brothers Loughridge (excluding former blogger Jmark of course), sprung a surprise by sending their men out in a 4-3-3 formation. We suspect that Renwick may still not have realised.

The Ministers were made to work hard all over the pitch to quell the threat of their younger but less theologically astute opponents, with Andy Lytle pulling off a number of good saves. Renwick, already without the injured Sean, suffered another injury blow midway through the first half as Andy Lynch had to go off injured. Rumours that he only did it for the attention he got from the girls, or to get out of going nets, are surely false – and as they say on MOTD, we wish him well.

As the half drew to a close, Renwick were getting more and more frustrated, although the ministers had only tested Jonny with flick-ons and crosses and were still waiting for the first real shot on target. The ministers had their own injury concerns themselves, as the Kerrser pulled up with a tight hamstring while chasing a ball from Steelo down the right flank. He made it through to half-time however, when the ministers opened negotiations with a keen-looking French-speaking bystander about coming on in the second half in the case of the Knocbracken man being unable to continue.

At half-time the Ministers were rightly pleased to have put in easily the best ever half for a ministers’ side, but they went one better early in the second half as Joel swung in a corner that Jonny, obviously frustrated at not being allowed to come out, could only palm into the net, under pressure. The ministers managed to hold out for about 15 minutes before a great half-volley from that man Dunwoody struck from outside the box looped in just under the crossbar to finally beat Andy Lytle. Dunwoody soon had a chance to add to his tally, as Aggers was harshly ajudged to have been ‘all over’ a Renwick striker on the edge of the box and a free kick from a dangerous position was awarded. However Lytle pulled off a marvellous save to tip it over the bar. By this time, PMO had gone off to give Pierre, our bystander, a run-out, before coming back on for Andrew Kerr who finally called it a day. The ministers continued to threaten, with star man Pete winning loadsa flick-ons and causing all sorts of defensive confusion. The ministers also unleashed Rory de Bun (or Cream De Lap) on a number of occasions, with Steelo failing to make contact with a particularly dangerous offering at the back post. Jonny also saved from Strob with his legs. At the other end, Skills hit another dangerous looking free-kick, with Pete taking a bit of a battering as the tiring Renwick Ministers (I did that all day…) tried to scramble it away.

The ministers had a chance to win it at the end as Steelo slid in to poke the ball through to McEwen, but Jonny did brilliantly to come out and get just enough of a block on the ball to divert it away from goal and let his defenders scramble it away.

So ended the first ever drawn Jonny McCollum Cup. After the match we had a shoot-out just for a laugh (though that’s not what the Messenger report will be saying!), with the ministers scoring their 5 to leave Lytle to make the crucial save from Stevie before heading out into the rush-hour traffic back to Cloughmills.

So all in all a great afternoon’s craic, with the tighter match definitely making it more entertaining. Though hopefully Renwick will have me back!

RENWICK: J. McCollum; A. Morrison (C. Robert) S. McCollum, D. Smith, A. Lynch (A. McCluggage); P. Dunwoody, C. Hyndman, G. Blackwell, B. Hanna (r: A. Morrison); M. McCavery, I. Buchanan

MINISTERS: A. Lytle; Prof. N. Wilson (c), Rev. P. Mo, Rev. N. Aggers, Rev. C. Bun; R. McCollum, P. Loughridge, J. Loughridge; Rev. A. Kerr (Pierre), Steelo, Rev. T. McEwen

Photos


Strob defending


Norris keeping a watchful eye


Renwick attack


Norris on the ball


Game over for Lynch


“We can see you sneaking out”


Half-time


Gavin tries to distract the ministers


Aggers giving Mark a friendly push!


Ministers defend a corner


Pierre on the ball


Joel up for the header


Free kick


Defending in numbers!

Shoot-out


Bun goes for placement over power. Jonny gets out of the way just in case.


Mark squeezes in another one


Pierre – in off the post


Ben finally hits the target


Jonny lets his minister score


Spotkickwell


Prof Wilson on target


Joel scores


Championees

Previous years
2008: Renwick 6 – 0 Ministers
2007: Renwick 9 – 4 Ministers