“…It is not necessary to prove that a continuous Divine blessing on the ordinary means of grace is likely to promote a healthy religious condition. The Head of the Church alone has authority to institute ordinances, and He alone can make them effectual. He has appointed the ordinary means of grace, and the Sabbath as the time when public ordinances are to be dispensed, and our attention wholly given to spiritual things.
The Apostles embraced every opportunity of preaching the Gospel on week-days, and we find Paul disputing daily in the school of Tyrannus, and yet it is remarkable how often we read of him addressing the worshippe[rs], in the synagogue on the Sabbath, and then of a whole week intervening before the people again assembled. And when he reached Troas on one of his journeys, though he was hastening to Jerusalem, he tarried seven days that he might join the disciples there in their communion on the Christian Sabbath.
There are several circumstances which seem to render occasional series of continued services less desirable than a faithful plying of the ordinary means of grace. When they are frequently employed as the means of producing an interest in religion, people come to regard them as the only seasons when conversions need be expected, and they do not look and pray for conversions and an abundant blessing at the ordinary services of the sanctuary. They do not value these services as they ought, and neglect to make self-application of the truth preached in them. Ministers get into the habit of being more pointed and searching and earnest at the special services. They cease to expect a blessing at the ordinary services, and do not aim directly at immediate results. Thus the ordinary services are allowed to become perfunctory and uninteresting. They lose their hold on the people, and lukewarmness and deadness spread slowly, but surely, among them.
…If we expect that the world will be converted by great movements, produced by the labours of great evangelists, an injurious result is very likely to follow. It is easier for ministers to cherish the idea that many conversions are only to be looked for under the preaching of such evangelists, and to bring them, and crowd round them, than to put forth constant and strenuous efforts in the cultivation of their own personal piety, in manifesting on all occasions a Christ-like spirit, in prayer and preaching, and thus to constrain success. And it is easier for the people to make spasmodic effort when such evangelists are among them, and loll in spiritual indolence all the rest of the time, than to stir themselves up continuously to earnest prayer and self-denying effort. When occasional revivals occur and come to be regarded as the great means of quickening Christians, and converting sinners, the periods which intervene are generally seasons of great spiritual deadness when the coldness and declension which prevail are often in proportion to the excitement, which has gone before…”
Special Revivals v. Ordinary Means of Grace
“Should we look for Occasional Revivals in connection with Special Services, or for a Continuous Blessing on the Ordinary Means of Grace?†A paper read at a Clerical Club in Belfast, on 24th March, 1881.
Is trying to answer this question I do not meddle with the Sovereignty of God. He may, and sometimes doubtless does, bless different kinds of means and methods for extending His kingdom, and is not confined to those which are sanctioned by His Word. The mere fact that a particular kind of means has done real good is not a sufficient reason for our adoption of it. We are bound to use only those means which are Scriptural. We believe, for instance, that our simple Presbyterian worship is Scriptural, and that the more aesthetic and sensuous forms of worship, which are used in the Prelatic, and especially in the Romish Church, are un-Scriptural. And yet, in the use of those rites and ceremonies which have been introduced into the Episcopal Church, many of God’s children have been edified and comforted, and attained eminent piety; and even in the Romish Church some real Christians have made great advances in the Divine life while waiting devoutly on her superstitious services. The forms of worship in both these Churches seem to have a greater attraction for mere human nature than the more severely simple forms of our Presbyterian Church. But though that is so, we are not, for the purpose of drawing greater crowds to our sanctuaries, at liberty to employ them on the ground that they seem to have become channels of grace to some. And just in the same way the fact that occasional revivals and special continued services have often been made a means of doing real good does not prove that we should look to them as the only or principal means of promoting a revival of religion, and gathering souls into the fold of Christ, or as being preferable to the faithful and prayerful use of the ordinary means of grace.
Nor do I question the fact that occasional revivals and special continued services have often done great good, and may even be sometimes necessary. If through the unfaithfulness of her ministers and members, the Church has become lukewarm and dead, God may see it necessary to raise up sons of thunder, and employ extraordinary means for awakening both the Church and the world. In the natural world, thunderstorms and tornadoes, with all their destructive accompaniments, are sometimes necessary to purify a stagnant and pestiferous atmosphere. But we do not on that account, and for the sake of the good which they unquestionably do, desire them as ordinary or frequent agents in preventing disease and promoting good harvests. In the last century religion in England was so dead that the work of Whitfield and Wesley was useful and necessary, and their preaching every day of the week, and sometimes at daybreak, was abundantly justified and greatly blessed; but that does not prove that we should continue their methods, or regard them as the best for the Church always and in all circumstances, or suppose that we are not to expect saving results unless we employ them.
The real question to be considered is—Whether, admitting that occasional revivals have often done a vast amount of good, and that special services continued for a number of successive days or evenings are lawful, and have often been greatly blessed, and may sometimes be necessary, especially for rousing the carless and outlying, should we regard them as the great and most effectual means of awakening an interest in religion in a dead community, of quickening church-going but slumbering professors, and of winning sinners to the Saviour; or should we not rather look to the diligent and prayerful use of the ordinary means of grace, especially on the Sabbath, for producing these results. And will not the latter method be more likely to issue in a more healthful religious life, and a more unmixed and permanent gain to genuine religion?
It is not necessary to prove that a continuous Divine blessing on the ordinary means of grace is likely to promote a healthy religious condition. The Head of the Church alone has authority to institute ordinances, and He alone can make them effectual. He has appointed the ordinary means of grace, and the Sabbath as the time when public ordinances are to be dispensed, and our attention wholly given to spiritual things. The Apostles embraced every opportunity of preaching the Gospel on week-days, and we find Paul disputing daily in the school of Tyrannus, and yet it is remarkable how often we read of him addressing the worshippe[rs], in the synagogue on the Sabbath, and then of a whole week intervening before the people again assembled. And when he reached Troas on one of his journeys, though he was hastening to Jerusalem, he tarried seven days that he might join the disciples there in their communion on the Christian Sabbath.
There are several circumstances which seem to render occasional series of continued services less desirable than a faithful plying of the ordinary means of grace. When they are frequently employed as the means of producing an interest in religion, people come to regard them as the only seasons when conversions need be expected, and they do not look and pray for conversions and an abundant blessing at the ordinary services of the sanctuary. They do not value these services as they ought, and neglect to make self-application of the truth preached in them. Ministers get into the habit of being more pointed and searching and earnest at the special services. They cease to expect a blessing at the ordinary services, and do not aim directly at immediate results. Thus the ordinary services are allowed to become perfunctory and uninteresting. They lose their hold on the people, and lukewarmness and deadness spread slowly, but surely, among them.
Special services produce a taste for excitement and variety, and for something out of the ordinary course, which is an unhealthy feeling, and in fast times, like the present, likely to lead to disastrous results. Religious dissipation is promoted. The desire for sound and solid instruction becomes feebler, and gradually disappears. The people must have variety and excitement, and if we do not furnish them, they will be off to the Salvation Army, or any others who will keep them in a whirl of excitement, but who will certainly not build them up in the faith, or make them stable and steadfast Christians, with symmetrical and perfect characters, by instructing them thoroughly in the whole system of Divine truth.
Next to a general and abundant outpouring of the Spirit, the great want of the church at present is family piety. We can scarcely expect to have a revived Church unless religion is revived in our families — unless family worship is generally established in our households, family training attended to, family relations cultivated, and family enjoyments relished. If for a time we bring the people, and especially the young people, out of their own houses for a number of successive evenings, they will not be likely to settle in them afterwards. Nor will they be satisfied to sit down to the quiet study of the Scriptures, and of a healthful religious literature.
If we expect that the world will be converted by great movements, produced by the labours of great evangelists, an injurious result is very likely to follow. It is easier for ministers to cherish the idea that many conversions are only to be looked for under the preaching of such evangelists, and to bring them, and crowd round them, than to put forth constant and strenuous efforts in the cultivation of their own personal piety, in manifesting on all occasions a Christ-like spirit, in prayer and preaching, and thus to constrain success. And it is easier for the people to make spasmodic effort when such evangelists are among them, and loll in spiritual indolence all the rest of the time, than to stir themselves up continuously to earnest prayer and self-denying effort.
When occasional revivals occur and come to be regarded as the great means of quickening Christians, and converting sinners, the periods which intervene are generally seasons of great spiritual deadness when the coldness and declension which prevail are often in proportion to the excitement, which has gone before. In America occasional revivals have been frequent during the past century and a half, and have come to be regarded by some as the harvest times of the Church, when great ingatherings need be expected; and the history of religion there does not encourage us to desire that they should be regarded in the same light among ourselves. The revivals which occurred under the ministry of Jonathan Edwards were perhaps as pure and Scriptural as any such movements can be expected to be, and yet very soon after them such dissensions broke out in the church of which he was pastor that he was obliged to resign his charge. Notwithstanding all the good which was supposed to have been done in the United States by Moody and Sankey after their return from this country, the Presbyterian Churches are at present complaining that during the past year there has been scarcely an appreciable increase to the number of their communicants, and that great and general deadness prevails. A few years after the awakening of 1859, we ourselves had a period of great declension; and soon after Moody and Sankey left us in 1874, I noticed that for years the number of persons seeking admission to the Lord’s table in my own congregation kept gradually diminishing, until one year only five persons, and among them not a single young man, were received to the fellowship of the Church. For the last year or two we have been only beginning to recover and gradually return to our normal condition.
Another evil connected with occasional revivals is that some of those who regard themselves as converted during these periods of excitement too often manifest a self-sufficient and censorious spirit. They are pushed, or push themselves, into the position of teachers without having such an acquaintance with the system of Divine truth in its relations and due proportions, as qualifies them for it, and they occasionally manifest an unwillingness to submit to painstaking instruction.
There seems also to be generated a tendency to rush into the adoption of extreme views, and a liability to be led away by Separatists, and to join their narrow and sectarian conventicles. And of those who profess conversion, a very large proportion soon fall away, and those who do so, often become the most hardened and hopeless cases, with whom we have to deal. When Moody and Sankey were leaving this town, there was sent to me, as to the other ministers, a list of forty-three persons, who professed to be converts. Of these, five are dead—nine have disappeared—one had given as much evidence of conversion before the evangelists appeared in town as since—she had for years been a consistent member of the Church, and was then merely in a state of emotional excitement—and of the rest there are only twelve of whom I am hopeful that they are real Christians. Some of the young people, who, during and after the visit of Moody and Sankey, professed conversion, fell into gross and flagrant sins, and some are now among the most careless, and hopeless, and hardened, with whom I have to deal.
While, therefore, I believe it is our duty, when God sees it necessary to raise up men specially gifted as evangelists, and who work on Scriptural lines, to take part with them and help them; and while I believe that in periods of religious awakening we may have continuous special meetings to supply the craving of the people for religious instruction; and while such meetings may sometime be necessary for the lapsed and outlying; we ought to look far more to the ordinary services of the sanctuary, and the preaching of the Word at our stated meetings as the great means of the Church’s edification and the world’s conversion. We should make our Sabbath services lively and interesting and attractive to spiritual minds. We should aim directly at the conversion of sinners, and make our sermons pointed, and powerful, and pathetic, and look for immediate results in the winning of souls to Christ, and the growth in grace of believers. We should cultivate sedulously our own personal piety, and see that we are walking with God in conscious fellowship. We should take care that our example in the family, in the Church Court, in ordinary daily life, commends our religion to others, and attracts them to it. We should see that our whole nature is thoroughly saturated with the truth we preach. We should wrestle in agonising, believing, persevering prayer, in public and private, for a continuous outpouring of the Spirit of God. We should teach our people to expect immediate results from the ordinary means of grace, and to unite with us in prayer for a continuous and remarkable blessing upon them. We should inculcate upon them the absolute necessity of faithfulness in closet exercises, in family religion, and in the quiet, daily study of the Scriptures, and of a healthful religious literature. I believe that such a course would in the end produce results more glorious and permanent, and more free from the evils which seem to be incident to occasional periods of excitement and special continued services.
RP Witness, 1881, pp 347-51