
In December my response to Aaron Denlinger’s rehashing of long-disproved arguments against exlusive psalmody on Reformation 21 received a link from everyone’s favourite London Welshman. Ref 21 however declined the opportunity of posting the response of a leading Wode Psalter scholar to Denlinger’s claim that the uninspired songs the psalter includes were sung in public worship.
Dr Timothy Duguid, author of Metrical Psalmody in Print and Practice: English ‘Singing Psalms’ and Scottish ‘Psalm Buiks’, c. 1547-1640, has therefore made his response available online. He concludes:
‘Denlinger admits, “I’ve never been hugely impressed by the biblical and/or theological arguments for exclusive psalmody…†That is where the discussion should have ended, but he instead insists on finding rest and comfort in a suspect historical precedent. Neither Calvin nor the early Reformed Scottish Kirk promoted the singing of any non-Scriptural texts in their respective liturgies. Therefore, Denlinger is errant in his concluding remarks: “I’m comforted, then, to think that as I worship this Sunday and join my fellow Reformed believers in singing uninspired hymns, I’ll do so in the company of those Scottish Christians who peopled the Reformed Kirk in its earliest decades.†There is no spiritual comfort to be had in any extra-Biblical historical precedent, let alone one that never existed.’