Evangelicalism’s misconceptions on the Sabbath

Daniel Block interviewed on the Logos Academic Blog:

Let’s talk a little bit about Sabbath in Deuteronomy. Can you address common misconceptions in Evangelicalism today, or some helpful application that you’ve drawn out of your studies?

In my book on worship, coming out soon—I need to do a course with you guys on a biblical theology of worship!—I have a whole chapter on the drama of worship, in which I talk about the rhythm of life, the 6+1 or 1+6 pattern. The biggest misconception—and I keep finding this among scholars—the biggest misconception is that the seventh-day Sabbath is one of the cultic laws. That couldn’t be further from the truth! The Israelites were keeping the ordinances of the Sabbath long before there was a tabernacle and long before they had formalized Levitical Aaronic sacrifices. It’s in chapter 16 of Exodus, and by the time you get to 20 they’re already practicing it. And when God says “the manna will be six days and the seventh is the Sabbath,” nobody asks “what’s that?” It’s assumed.

The second thing is, if you tried to figure out what people did on the seventh-day Sabbath in the Old Testament—you can’t do it! There is nothing cultic about it. It isn’t tied to the tabernacle; it’s not tied to sacrifices. Now, there are “Sabbaths,” plural. Those are all tied to Israel’s experience of redemption and to the tabernacle. The Sabbaths: new moons, Passover, whatever. That’s a totally differing thing from the Sabbath.

That distinction is incredibly helpful for intertextuality of the Sabbath and New Testament Church application.

Absolutely! But few people pick that up. So you know in Romans when Paul says “some people keep one day, some another,” he uses the plural “Sabbaths” there. We’re not talking about seventh-day Sabbath, he’s talking about festival days. They’re liturgical. But the seventh-day Sabbath has only one function. It has several foundations, but it has one function, and that is stop. Stop your work. Trust God. You don’t have to work seven days! God has given this to you as a gift, and he said he’ll take care of you. And so, it becomes in Deuteronomy, in the Decalogue, a celebration that we’re no longer in Egypt where we worked seven days a week without rest. Don’t go back there! You were slaves in Egypt; now you’re free. But the other thing is, it becomes a day when we celebrate and declare our theological perspective on life. God made the world! We get to live according to the paradigm set by God.

I don’t think the Sabbath is something we have to keep; it’s something we get to keep [surely it’s both? – SS]. It’s an invitation to sabbath, not a command. We have all of that stuff twisted upside down. And I think that’s a huge misconception.

So when it comes to the Sabbath, we’re asking the wrong questions. It’s not “do we have to keep this,” but “do we get to”?

It’s a thing we get to keep, and like all the other laws in Deuteronomy, we shouldn’t be asking “do we have to keep this.” We should be asking “how does the Lord invite us to observe this in our context?” And you know, that’s a totally different issue. With the Sabbath, it’s commonly viewed that for the Christian every day is holy and in Israel one day was holy. Wrong! Every day in Israel was holy for an Israelite! One day is set apart as sanctified in a particular form. It’s not uniquely holy, but its holy-function is unique. I think that’s an important distinction.”

Check out Logos’ greatest ever sale bundle here.