Really important article from R. Scott Clark (based on his book, RRC), especially good on reading the likes of Calvin in context to see exactly what they were arguing against. Read the comments for plenty of examples of people missing this exact point – and Clark’s responses.
Some quotes:
The unstated assumption behind this way of writing and speaking is that there were (and are) two distinct traditions, the European (mainly Dutch) and the British (and American). Such ways of speaking and thinking would have been foreign to the classical Reformed writers in the 16th and 17th centuries
…What typically happens is that writers appeal to a passage or two from the 1559 Institutes and then call it a day. This way of reading Calvin is deeply flawed. The only way to understand Calvin properly is to read him the way he intended to be read. One must start with his biblical commentary, then go to a treatise (the Institutes or some other), and then to go to his sermons. When one reads Calvin holistically, in context, his view of the Sabbath is quite difficult to distinguish from what is alleged to be a distinctly (and harshly) British view.
And his conclusion:
Yes there is some diversity within classical Reformed theology on the Sabbath but it is diversity within unity. There is a Reformed view of the Sabbath. There is a fundamental unity that God has established a 1 in 7 pattern in creation. To that creational law was added typological and temporary Mosaic legislation but the Sabbath was not grounded in the Mosaic law and covenant but in creation, i.e., in the nature of things. The Sabbath principle, then, remained in force in the New Covenant. The day was transformed from the last day to the first by the bodily resurrection of the Son of God and the inauguration of the new creation but the Sabbath principle and practice remained.
Related articles by Clark:
– The Practice of the Sabbath in Calvin’s Geneva
– The Synod of Dort on Sabbath Observance
Chris Coldwell has also put paid to the myth that John Calvin bowled on the Sabbath in the following essay: http://www.fpcr.org/blue_banner_articles/calvin_bowls.htm
Having read Martin Bucer, Henry Bullinger, Johannes Wollebius, and Calvin himself on this issue, I see no evidence that the Continental Reformed perceived of the Sabbath as either a) ceremonial in substance, or, b) a day for recreation. Indeed, I have just started reading Francis Turretin’s section on the Sabbath in his Institutes and he emphatically denies that it merely belonged to the Mosaic ceremonies. In view of the evidence, I suspect the Continental Sabbath is probably a myth invented for those, especially in the sub-confessional American Presbyterian churches, who want to watch NFL and other sports on the Lord’s Day.