Bit of tension on Reformation 21…

After the pigeons ignored the cats he previously introduced*, Carl Trueman is back giving it some for Exclusive Psalmody:

OK, I’ll rise to the bait: Wot, no psalms? Shows how disconnected from the history of the church the modern ecclesiastical scene is. The psalms remain the only universally accepted hymn book; yet so rarely get sung. Etc. etc.
If the topic really is hymnody, I’ll take the blog equivalent of a Trappist vow for the next week.

He only broke his self-imposed silence to state that “The major distinctive of a good hymn is that it is a psalm” and then give 5 reasons why Psalms are superior to (man-made) hymns and choruses. He closes:

All the church really needs in terms of praise is already there in scripture. Most critics of unaccompanied psalm singing have very limited experience of what it is like, little exposure to the arguments, and are unaware of the kind of piety which it engenders

As Calvin wrote, “Now, what Augustine says is true, namely, that no one can sing anything worthy of God which he has not received from him. Therefore, even after we have carefully searched everywhere, we shall not find better or more appropriate songs to this end than the Psalms of David, inspired by the Holy Spirit. And for this reason, when we sing them, we are assured that God puts words in our mouth, as if he himself were singing through us to exalt his glory.”

*Sorry for the Cantona-esque sentence.

2 thoughts on “Bit of tension on Reformation 21…”

  1. No, that’s his worst contribution! He was doing so well….Psalms, slagging off American ‘football’ – and then he starts talking about egg-chasing!

Comments are closed.