ESV Preaching Bible Review (2025 ESV text)

For the last five years, I’ve preached each morning service in Stranraer from the ESV Preaching Bible in Truetone over Board (effectively a hardback). I have been very happy with it, but can no longer recommend it — for the simple reason that it’s out of print! And so I was glad of the opportunity to receive a review copy of the Black Goatskin version, which is still available, and has recently been updated with the 2025 ESV text.

Background

What makes this a Preaching Bible? Apparently it’s the result of Crossway surveying over 1000 pastors. The result is a single column text block, with a generous 10-point typeface, extra-wide margins, and “enlarged, bolded verse numbers, surrounded by extra space to easily locate verses on the page”.

You can’t please everyone however, and this edition was quickly followed by a “Verse-by-verse Preaching Bible”, which maintains the single column format, but with each verse starting on a new line.

Premium but not Heirloom

After being (controversially) produced in China for a while, Crossway’s top-of-the-range Bibles are now once more printed and bound in the Netherlands. The ESV Preaching Bible lacks the “heirloom” monicker, and is still produced in China. It still very much has a premium feel to it, however, with a (fairly thin & very flexible) goatskin cover, red under gold art gilt page edges and four raised spine hubs.

Thankfully — and as with all of Crossway’s premium Bibles — the words of Christ are in black.

Text changes

Note the difference at Genesis 3:16 – but the same page number

My Truetone ESV Preaching Bible has the 2016 ESV text. This caught me out a few weeks ago when I was reading Genesis 3 and came to the part where the 2016 text says “Your desire shall be contrary to your husband”, which was widely considered too interpretative. The 2025 text restores this to “Your desire shall be for your husband”. They have managed to make these changes while retaining pagination.

Comparison

Legacy (top); Preaching Bible (bottom)

The Bible this is most similar to is Crossway’s Gloria Dei (formerly Legacy), which has similar margin space (with slightly more at the top and particularly the bottom) but a 9-point font instead of a 10-point. However the extra writing space is somewhat negated by the section headings in the margin. The Preaching Bible has them in the more usual position in line with the text. The 10-point font is definitely nicer for public reading.

Veritas/Heritage (left); Preaching Bible (right)

Another alternative would be the Heirloom Vertias, formerly Heritage (The same text block is available in non-Heirloom editions). It has 9.25 font but without a ton of margin space, giving you a smaller footprint. Fewer words per line and more spacing means that I actually find it more readable — it’s my favourite Crossway text block — but it also means less content viewable at any one time, and so requires a bit more flipping pages.

The Heritage/Veritas is much more portable

Wide Margin Alternative?

The ESV Preaching Bible is actually taller — and only very slightly narrower than my Cambridge “Eagle” Wide Margin. There’s much more space to write on the right-hand side of the Preaching Bible than the left, but that isn’t really an issue in a single-column format. Sadly Crossway’s Heirloom Wide Margin remains out of print.

There’s no reason why the Preaching Bible couldn’t be used by a non-preacher — other than it being a bit unwieldy to carry around.

Conclusion

Can 1000 pastors be wrong? Undoubtedly — but not when it comes to this Bible. In my view Crossway got it right the first time, and the paragraph format used here is much preferable to verse-by-verse, which is an artificial way to lay out a Bible.

In some ways it’s a pity that the (much cheaper) Truetone version is no longer available. Owning both would mean you could keep one on your desk, and one in the pulpit. Or if — like me — you preach in a different location morning and evening, you could keep one on each lectern.

It’s not really the sort of Bible you want to carry about a lot — but it is the sort of Bible I’ve been happy to read and preach from for the past five years, and plan to continue doing so, now with the 2025 ESV text and in a much-nicer package.

The Goatskin ESV Preaching Bible would be the ideal gift for a minister’s ordination — or for someone starting seminary and wanting to fill their Bible with notes.