Ruined Sinners to Reclaim: Sin and Depravity in Historical, Biblical, Theological, and Pastoral Perspective
David Gibson and Jonathan Gibson (eds)
Crossway, 2024
Over a decade ago, the Gibson brothers compiled From Heaven He Came and Sought Her: Definite Atonement in Historical, Biblical, Theological, and Pastoral Perspective. It wasn’t intended to be part of a series, but four more books to fill out the other five points of Calvinism are now on the way, beginning with this one on Total Depravity. Or at least, the books will be loosely based around the five points – the editors say that ‘the project is not a presentation of the five points of Calvinism’. Indeed, Michael Horton’s foreword to the book criticises both the TULIP acronym (which starts with the Fall, rather than Creation) and the term Total Depravity itself (‘Originating as a term no earlier than the twentieth century, it is not a particularly good one’).
The Brothers Gibson begin with a chapter showing what’s at stake. A popular-level Christian Focus book by John Stevens (director of FIEC) claims to take a middle path between Keswich holiness on the one hand, and Ryle, Packer, and ‘the more traditional puritan approach’ on the other. For Stevens, temptation itself is not sin. In making this claim,
‘without engaging with it at all, and seemingly unaware of it, Stevens’ treatment of temptation wades into the deep waters of concupiscence…and thereby, in an evangelical Protestant book, actually presents a Roman Catholic position’.
(A later chapter presents ‘A Protestant Assessment of the Doctrine of Concupiscence’ by Steven Wedgeworth.)
The book is arranged in the four sections spelled out in the subtitle. The Biblical section is 250+ pages with 7 chapters covering Genesis – Revelation. Personally, I can’t see too many people trawling through such detail and wondered if it could have been more concise. It certainly wins points for thoroughness – but maybe not usefulness.
One big omission in my view is a chapter on the law. Douglas Sean O’Donnell’s chapter on sin in the Synoptical Gospels and Acts does categorise sins under each of the Ten Commandments. However, if ‘sin is lawlessness’ (1 John 3.4), not having even one chapter that directly addresses the subject of law seems curious in the extreme.
Personally I most enjoyed Garry Williams’ two chapters on ‘Total Depravity and God’s Covenant with Adam’. Some of the chapters on pastoral practice (‘Evangelising Fallen People’ by Anderson, and ‘Preaching to Sinners in a Secular Age’ by Mohler) look like they will be helpful.
Overall this is sure to be a useful resource. I’ve thought of preaching a sermon series on sin, but never quite pulled the trigger. If I do, this will be one of the first books I turn to.