Church Growth by Transfer

sheep stealing

“Increase of this sort isn’t church growth at all. It’s just a reshuffling of the same fifty-two cards.”
Jim Peterson (The Navigators), quoted in Os Guinness, Dining with the Devil, p. 82.

Anyone disagree?

6 thoughts on “Church Growth by Transfer”

  1. Numerically speaking the statement is right. However if sheep are starving and go to where better grass is growing the sheep will grow. Church growth surely isn’t purely numerical it is also spiritual. If the sheep are growing then the church is growing and therefore there is a flaw in the statement. Church growth by transfer is more important than “reshuffling” the pack.

  2. Church growth in grace is just as important as church growth in numbers. Providing meat to people who have previously only known milk is a blessed ministry.

  3. “Increase of this sort isn’t church growth at all. It’s just a reshuffling of the same fifty-two cards.”

    At one level, I would tend to agree that church growth should not be measured in terms of people moving from one congregation to another. However, if it is a case of someone leaving a scandalously corrupt church (mentioning no names) to a genuinely Reformed church, then I think we can say that is genuine church growth.

  4. yes with the quote… I did not know that Mark was in Scotland either…. shame and sadness. Though he has a few new sermons and lectures up at Resurgence.

Comments are closed.