Recent Criticisms of the Westminster Confession

That’s the title of a helpful article by Roland Ward which was part of the proceedings of the ICRC in 1993. Here’s a sample of what he has to say on a few issues which keep coming up:

Church and State

“The underlying principle [of the The American modification of the WCF] is at best that the state’s duty does not extend to anything but the encouragement of a lowest common denominator Christianity, and at worst that the state has nothing to do with religion but to protect people in the free exercise of it – The actual current practice in the United States. In other words, the vision of a thoroughly Christian state was somewhat dimmed by a pragmatic acceptance of the denominational ideal, and secularising influences since 1788 have contributed to a pluralistic view of the state with law derived from the will of the people.”

“…In 19th century Scotland the Voluntary controversy at root was concerned with the same issue: the sovereignty of God over the nation was downplayed or rejected and the modem secular state foreshadowed.”

“…The Confession in the form adopted in Scotland recognised the distinct government in the church but held that the nation living in the light of special revelation was accountable to God and had certain particular responsibilities in reference to the encouragement of the truth, and the provision of a framework of law, education and welfare agreeable to Scripture.”

The Claim that Inerrancy belongs only to the “Received Text”

“Whatever the superficial attractiveness of the logic of this claim, it is contrary to the plainest facts. It arises from a simplistic logic (not unlike that among some of the Anabaptists of the 17th century) coupled with a reactionary conservatism. Matthew 5:18 (the jot and tittle passage) is not referring to the transmission of the text of Scripture but to the authority of God’s claims upon us, The transmission of Scripture is not such that the sources have been preserved with exactness in any particular manuscript but, as Owen noted [see earlier in Ward’s article], in all the manuscripts. And we cannot say that providence has preserved only some manuscripts since providence extends to all events and thus to the preservation of all the manuscripts. Nor can we say that providence tells us which manuscripts are the best ones: only manuscript comparison and analysis can do that. In short, “pure” does not mean “without any transcriptional errors” but it means something like “without loss of doctrines and with the text preserved in the variety of manuscripts.” Thus, in affirming that “the original texts of the Old and New Testaments come down to us pure and uncorrupted” Francis Turretin (1623- 87) states:

“The question is not, Are the sources so pure that no fault has crept into the many sacred manuscripts …. ? For this is acknowledged on both sides and the various readings clearly prove it. Rather, the question is have the original texts (or the Hebrew and Greek manuscripts) been so corrupted by copyists through carelessness (or by the Jews and heretics through malice) that they can no longer be regarded as the judge of controversies and the rule to which all the versions may be applied? The papists affirm, we deny it … for besides being in things of small importance and not pertaining to faith and practice … they are not universal in all the manuscripts; or they are not such as cannot be easily corrected from a collation of the Scriptures and the various manuscripts.” [Institutes, II: 10: 3, 8 (pp. 106, 108-9 of 1992 edition]

The “jot and tittle theory” cannot produce the allegedly perfectly preserved text which is the ultimate standard of appeal. Even the “Received Text” is not the best (NT) text that can be constructed from the Byzantine family of manuscripts but, as we all know, is largely the text constructed from a few manuscripts of that family and the ingenuity of Erasmus.”

Ward also quotes William Ames who says:

“God’s providence in preserving the sources is notable and glorious, for neither have they wholly perished nor have they been injured by the loss of any book or blemished by any serious defect- though today not one of the earlier versions remains intact. From these human versions all those things may be made known which are absolutely necessary, provided they agree with the sources in essentials. Hence, all the versions accepted by the churches usually agree, although they may differ and be defective at several minor points. We must not rest forever in any accepted version, but faithfully see to it that a pure and faultless interpretation is given to the church.” [William Ames (1576-1633), The Marrow of Theology, I xxxiv, 27-33 (first edition, Latin 1623; English translations 1638; 1986).]

On the Pope as the Antichrist

“Taking account of the illustrative Scripture texts, the doctrinal positions of the Confession at 25:6 are (1) the Pope is not the head of the Church; (2) he exalts himself as if he were, which (3) proves him to be activated by the anti- Christian spirit which seeks religious veneration (Matt. 21:8-9), persecutes the godly (Rev. 13:6) and illustrates the predicted apostasy in the church (2 Thess. 2:3-4, 8-9). This does not seem unscriptural in any way.

The difficulties arise from erroneous inferences such as that there is no other application of the antichrist concept than to the papacy (contrary to 1 John 2:18; 4:3), or that the man of sin passage which refers to apostasy in the church is totally exhausted in the papacy, or that the Confession binds to details of unfulfilled prophecy. In fact the context is headship in the church not the interpretation of prophecy.”

For a fuller justification of identifying the Pope as the antichrist, David Murray has just finished a very helpful 3-part series:

1. If I were the Antichrist…
2. Seven Characteristics of the Antichrist
3. Who is the Antichrist?

The backbone of Christian worship for 2,000 years

There’s been a bit of a debate over whether it’s wise to quote heretics or not. But you can’t really argue with NTW’s historical take on the place of the psalms:

Well, it surprises me that one need make a case for the Psalms, but in a great many contemporary churches, something very odd has happened….they often simply forget the Psalms. You can go to many churches where if you attend week after week after week you will never ever sing or read the Psalms.

There’s something very peculiar about that because in pretty well every branch of the Christian tradition for 2,000 years, the Psalms have been the backbone of Christian worship. Certainly in all traditional denominations, but in many non-traditional ones, as well, it’s assumed that the Psalms are the heart of worship.

One of the staplines that the publisher has been using is “what would Jesus sing?” which I really like, because the Psalms were the prayer book that Jesus Himself used, and we can see in the Gospels and in the New Testament how Jesus and the early Christians used them, and it seems to me extraordinary that we would ignore that resource in our own worship.

And here’s one on why our culture is so quick to give up Bible reading and relationships:

Part of the problem in our culture today is that people don’t like working at anything. That’s why relationships are so difficult. People think either it’s perfect or it’s rubbish, so as soon as it stops being perfect “oh, it must be rubbish,” so we throw it away. Most things that are worthwhile in human life, you actually have to work at them and only then does the real fruit come.

Logos embraces the Covenanted Reformation!

Well not quite – but a week ago they made available the original Westminster Confession (previously they only had the American revision), the catechisms, and all the documents that went with it, namely:

Preface by Sundry English Divines
Mr. Manton’s Epistle to the Reader
The Confession of Faith
The Larger Catechism
The Shorter Catechism
The Sum of Saving Knowledge
The National Covenant
The Solemn League and Covenant
The Acknowledgment of Sins
The Directory of Public Worship
The Form of Presbyterian Church Government
The Directory of Family Worship

Notice the Covenants, National and Solemn League right in the middle – a nice reminder that we stand in the mainstream of Westminster / Second Reformation Christianity and aren’t some obscure sect, even though most Presbyterian churches have long since quietly forgotten about most of the documents listed above!

If you act fast you can get them all for $6.00 (and potentially even less). They were first listed on Logos’ Community Pricing scheme last Thursday at $10 and have already almost halved in price. Normally things are stuck on CP for a good while, sometimes years, so that’s impressive demand! After today they’ll cost $22.95.

If this interests you, check out the other Scottish Reformation & Covenanter resources in Logos needing a bit of help to make it into production!

Worship Services starting in Mexico City

A potential Reformed Presbyterian Church in Mexico City will take a step forward tomorrow with the commencement of evening worship services

The work is being headed up by Alejandro Moreno Morrison, who was at the YAW in 2012 and spent time in both Ireland and Scotland in 2013.

Alex

Please remember this work in your prayers – and spread the word!

Church of Scotland ‘deserves to die’ after Humanist Society alliance to remove worship from schools

These posts from David Robertson almost defy belief:

– Et Tu Kirka? Reflections on the Church of Scotland’s new alliance with the Humanist Society:

…Why?

The only answer I can think of, apart from sheer stupidity, is politics and self-interest. The clergy and bureaucrats who make these kind of decisions, know full well that their congregations are declining, that they are losing 20,000 plus members per year, that their finances are in severe trouble (with the pension scheme being tens of millions in debt and a significant number of the larger evangelical congregations leaving). But they don’t really care. There is enough silver to be sold off to keep them in jobs for a few years. What they really do care about is the fact that with the rapid secularisation of society, the nice cosy arrangement they have had with the secular state is under threat. What will they do if they are not allowed to be schools chaplains or other religious functionaries of the state? How can they maintain the illusion of importance and significance? When Secular Scotland began their campaign I thought it had no chance of succeeding just now, but I had reckoned without the spineless Machiavellian leadership of the C of S. In order to preserve their positions they have done a deal with the humanists (who in turn of course are aspiring to be humanist chaplains).

– Journeying Together? Further Reflections on the unequal marriage of the Church of Scotland and the Humanist Society.

– An Open Letter to C of S Evangelicals in the light of the C of S/Humanist Debacle

On Monday there was a change. The Church of Scotland realising that it was going to get a backlash from its own members began to retract and in an attempt at news management, issued a press release which in effect accused me of lying…

Paisley, Presbyterianism and Power

Some helpful comments on the recent Paisley documentary (Genesis to Revelation – Face to Face with Eamonn Mallie) (also on youtube: part 1 | part 2) by former Ulster Free Presbyterian, Rev. Gavin Beers (Ayr FCC). Posted by permission.

“1. An understanding of Presbyterianism would have saved both him and the church a lot of trouble. The whole context of the discussion about his being leader of the church and being ousted from it showed a failure to grasp this. There is no office of moderator per se – he is an elder among equals, chairing a meeting of presbytery. The only way you could think men wanted to take over the church by changing the moderator was if you thought as moderator you had control of it.

2. True desire for Christ’s glory and the good of the Church should make a man reflect on his ability to feed the flock in his latter years. The comment of being offended at being asked to stand down after 65 years as pastor says a lot. Not many men would think they could continue to properly feed the flock of God after so long a time. If the elders (co pastors, equal in authority and charged with the same responsibility to feed the flock) raise this for the good of the flock. It’s not time to put the lip out, it is time to say thank you brethren for pointing this out, I had not realised.

3. An application of the principles of the book of Proverbs would have helped him in relation to his time in power, a wise resignation from power, and not to air his grievances now in this way. There were so many sad contradictions in his accusations of ego and pursuit of power in others, when in the next breath he admitted his right to have the power and desire to hold on to it, together with his (and his wife’s) disgust that others would dare to take it.

4. If a man cannot receive the advice of his political party when they see their octogenarian leader unable to function as efficiently and quickly as before, but all he sees is a coup d’état: There is a problem. When 83% of them say there is a problem and the leader says there was no problem, the problem is even bigger than they thought.

5. A man’s family, especially his wife, should give him wise counsel, rather than indulge him out of personal offence and continue to flatter his ego.

6. Holding power is a dangerous thing at all times. Holding it as a young man is dangerous as Rehoboam shows us. Holding it as an old man is dangerous also.

7. In all the above, consider ourselves and pray that God gives us grace to grow old wisely and learn increasingly the grace of true humility.”