Old Light on New Worship – John Price [Book Review]

“Musical instruments and the worship of God, a theological, historical and psychological study”

(Simpson Publishing Company, 2005)

Dear readers who haven’t yet seen the light: I’ll try and not bash you too hard! (Incidentally, Price writes in a very winsome way so if this post comes across as harsh that’s my fault rather than his!)

At Termonfeckin, David McC told me to read this book. I protested that I already believed in it, but, of course, I read it anyway. In the mass of writing that follows I will attempt to sum up the author’s arguments in this very important book.

As the subtitle of the book suggests, the book is divided into 3 main sections. Rather strangely for a book on such a subject, the book ‘assumes a basic understanding of the regulative principle of worship and makes no effort to provide the biblical support for it.’ Instead, Price recommends a few on the subject. Most of these however are written / edited by those who are in favour of musical instruments, so you would wonder just how good the books are if they ignore one of the applications uses of the principle they’re writing about! But, seeing that the regulative principle is taught by the Westminster Confession of Faith (and the Baptist equivalent), I suppose we can assume that anyone with their head screwed on (and many without) does actually accept it.

Price then launches into the theological section of the book, where he goes through every use / institution of musical instruments in the Bible (well, the OT seeing there aren’t any mentioned in NT worship!) and clearly shows that ‘there is no record in Scripture of a musical instrument ever being used in public worship without an explicit divine command’. The third part of the book is the longest section – on ‘The History of Musical Instruments’, it’s basically one big long ‘Easy!’ chant. Price shows how instrumental music was unknown to the church up till the 13th century, it didn’t receive general acceptance till the 14th and 15th centuries – and it was promptly wiped out again by the Reformation! Although we don’t believe things because of who has believed them in the past, the fact that just about anybody who was anybody in church history was against musical instruments may help us somewhat – and Price quotes from many of them.

The third main section is on ‘The Psychology of Music’ where among other things Price quotes from the Church Fathers and Reformers speaking against even certain types of tunes, worrying about their ability to affect the emotions and distract the mind from the words of the psalms. For example, Calvin: ‘Songs composed merely to tickle and delight the ear are unbecoming of the majesty of the church, and cannot but be most displeasing to God’ (Stutes, III. xx. 32.)

There are a few shorter sections at the close of the book. In ‘Arguments in Favor (sic) of Instrumental Music Considered’ he faces some key arguments for instrumental music head on. Those who claim to hold to the regulative principle but want to have instruments may try and claim that instruments are one of those circumstances of worship ‘which are to be ordered by the light of nature and Christian prudence’ (WCF I. VI). (Price is a Baptist so he’s quoting from the copycat 1689 Baptist Confession). However this argument can easily be shown not to be an argument at all as:
– Those who wrote the confession were against musical instruments
– ‘A circumstance must be something necessary (or essential) to the performance of the commanded element in worship. In other words, the circumstance must be of such a nature that if it is not carried out the element of worship cannot be performed’. And as the majority of church history has seen unaccompanied singing, no-one can claim that instruments are essential to singing.
– Circumstances ‘must be such as are not determinable by Scripture’ (George Gillespie). The issue of musical instruments is determinable by Scripture (things such as what time to hold church services aren’t).
Next (after spending FAR too long chatting about circumstances!) Price counters the argument that we need to use instruments as the Greek noun ‘psallo’ and verb ‘psalmos’ in Eph 5:19 both refer to playing musical instruments (as if the Holy Spirit would communicate to us in such a veiled way that we are to use musical instruments!). Price quotes reems of lexicographers to show that by the time of the NT these words had come to refer exclusively to singing without musical accompaniment. The author notes that the Church Fathers, some of them masters in Greek, clearly didn’t understand this word to refer to musical instruments as they vehemently rejected them. Pricer then has a bit of a laugh at the expense of those that advocate this view, inserting the earlier meaning of the words in the places where they are used in the NT. For example, Eph 5:19 becomes ‘speaking to one another in psalms, and hymns, and spiritual songs, singing and playing on a stringed instrument with your heart to the Lord’ and 1 Cor 14:15 becomes ‘I shall pray with the spirit and I shall pray with the mind also; I shall play on stringed instrument with the spirit and I shall play on stringed instrument with the mind also’. All English Bibles translate psallo every time as ‘to sing’. Furthermore, the command is to everybody, no select group is mentioned, so everyone without exception would have to play a stringed instrument!
Penultimately in this section he deals with the harps mentioned in Revelation as use in the worship in Heaven. This argument too is quickly rejected as:
– The descriptions of harps also involve a temple, golden bowls full of incense, a golden altar before the throne and 24 elders clothed in white garments with golden crowns on their heads – to be consistent, you’d need to include all them as well.
– Revelation is filled with figurative language (the Puritans, for example, often interpreted these harps as being the hearts of the saints filled with the Holy Spirit).
– Even if the harps are actual instruments in Heaven – ‘what the saints may do in their perfectly sanctified state in heaven is no rule for what we may do in our state of remaining sin on earth. We must obey the clear commands and examples of His Word for worship on earth.’
Finally, he moves on to the old chestnut ‘we are not to squander our musical gifts but to use them for the glory of God’ and quotes from Girardeau to disprove it:

“The use of instrumental music in the church is justified upon the scriptural principle that we ought to consecrate every talent we possess to the service of God. This argument is also futile, because it proves too much. It would prove that the sculptor should install his statues in the sanctuary, that the painter should hang his pictures upon its walls, that the mechanic should contribute the products of his skill as “object-lessons” for the elucidation of gospel truths, and that the architect should, by massive piles, express the greatness of God, and by the multiplicity of their minute details the manifoldness of his works. Avaunt! The argument is suited only to a Papist.”

Price concludes that although he has written the section as if the burden of proof depended on us – but he points out that a proper view of the regulative principle places the burden of proof on those that would bring instruments in. Too right! (And the same goes for psalms too Pricer, let’s hear ya!)

So that’s a summary of the book, here’s a few highlights:

– a capella comes from the Italian for ‘in the style of the church’ (p14)

– Samuel Mather writes of ‘ministers of music’ (who would surely be called ‘worship leaders’ in our day):

“This cathedral music introduces to the Church of God a rabble of church-officers which the Lord never appointed, and which never came into His heart, the choristers and singing-men, and that is a very great evil. It is not in the power of men, but it is the great prerogative of Jesus Christ to appoint officers in His church who has appointed none but pastors and teachers, elders and deacons” (The Figures or Types of the Old Testament, p. 439)

– Only two of the whole Reformers and Puritans were for instruments (Luther and Richard Baxter, neither of whom believed in the regulative principle)

– Price goes out of his way to show that the Puritans did not have an aversion to music in general.

“They often enjoyed musical instruments in the privacy of their own homes, and many of them were accomplished musicians. But they refused to bring their own personal desires, including their musical instruments, into God’s worship without specific divine command.”

– Amazingly, despite only 2 of the hundreds and hundreds of Reformers and Puritans being for musical instruments, Price says that sometimes the rest are misquoted as being in favour of them, ig they are talking about music in general, but they are quoted as if they’re talking about it in worship, or they are talking about ‘music’ in worship as in the singing. Price quotes 2 examples in 2 recently published books, firstly a book by Joe Morecraft and then one edited by Don Carson (‘Worship by the Book’). In the latter, an article by Timothy Keller claims that Calvin took a ‘middle course’ between the Lutherans and anabaptists, and ‘Calvin’s theology does not preclude instrumental accompaniment’. Keller provides absolutely no support for these nonsense views! This will have to be pointed out to Big DC the next time we see him:

strob_doncarson2

– Here’s a quote for my baptist readers, of which I’m sure I have none! It’s from New England pastor and historian David Benedict (1779-1874), who gives 1820 as the date for the first organ in a baptist church:

“Staunch old Baptists in former times would as soon have tolerated the Pope of Rome in their pulpits as an organ in their galleries”

Leading baptist theologian of the 19th century Andrew Fuller also wrote against musical instruments as ‘utterly unsuited to the genius of the gospel dispensation’. And everybody who has read The Communicant’s Class knows that the greatest Baptist ever (apart from Olyott), Charles Spurgeon, was against them. Price quotes him a lot. For example:

“If you want the sensual gratification of music’s melting, let me commend to you the concert-room, there you will get the enchanting ravishment; but when ye come to the house of God, let it be to “sing unto the Lord” (Sermon 2850, Met Tab Pulpit)

– Even Isaac Watts, whose hatred of the psalms saw him making comments that were near enough blasphemy, was against instruments! Incidentally, Price sets the record straight that the dubious honour of the first ‘Puritan’ to write hymns of human composition was the Baptist Benjamin Keach (who was also against instruments), and not Watts (so baptists are to blame for this too!). Price quotes what Keach felt was his justification for singing these man made songs – and it is pathetic! He writes that the phrase a new song, found in various psalms, ‘shows other spiritual songs may be sung besides David’s psalms in gospel days’. So what did it mean in ‘non-gospel’ days?!!

– It seems the aul Anglicans were on the bottom of re-introducing all this instruments nonsense. John Spencer Curwen wrote in 1880:

“Men still living can remember the time when organs were very seldom found outside the Church of England. The Methodists, Independents, and Baptists rarely had them, and by the Presbyterians they were stoutly opposed.”

– Even Martin Llyod-George (who Price says didn’t oppose the use of an organ) can be called on:

“Nothing is needed more urgently than an analysis of the innovations in the realm of religious worship in the nineteenth century – to me in this respect a devastating century. The sooner we forget the nineteenth century and go back to the eighteenth, and even further to the seventeenth and sixteenth century, the better. The nineteenth century and its mentality and outlook is responsible for most of our troubles and problems today. It was then that a fatal turn took place in so many respects…Quite frequently, and especially in non-episcopal churches, they did not even have an organ before that time. Many of the leaders were actively opposed to organs and tried to justify their attitude from Scripture” (Preaching & Preachers, pp. 265-6)

The Psalms issue

The author hasn’t yet seen the light as regarding exclusive psalmody, which seems quite strange after conducting such a study. Obviously, I can’t let him away with it! Just a few observations:

– He quotes so many people from church history saying they’re against instruments, who state they sing their PSALMS unaccompanied. He even seems to recognise that for most of the history of the church, people have only sung psalms. He devotes most of his book to arguing from church history – because, as he himself states:

Can we ignore this massive evidence from church history? Do we believe that we are more enlightened than the Reformers and the Puritans? (p149)

Price quotes from the Church Fathers and Puritans about their only singing psalms – and he surely knows the position of Calvin (“No-one is able to sing things worthy of God except that which he has received from him.”) etc too:

Eusebius, Bishop of Caesarea (ca. 260-ca. 339), was the leading historian of the early church. If musical instruments had existed in the worship of the church, he surely would have recorded their use. But Eusebius states that it was the universal practice of the early church to sing unaccompanied psalms. (p77)

“When the Westminster Assembly prepared their Directory for Worship, the situation in England was such that the singing of psalms unaccompanied by musical instruments prevailed almost universally” (p118)

However, now church history doesn’t just have the same weight for Pricer! And what of his regard for the regulative principle?! Fair enough, he was writing about instruments, but remember Pricer, if you want to sing hymns, the burden of proof (as you said) is on you to show your authorisation! But maybe singing only psalms would seem a bit radical. Well, to quote Price again:

“A no-[hymns] position will surely seem radical to most modern Christians. We have become so accustomed to the use of [hymns] in church that we simply assume they should be there. We cannot possibly imagine anything else. Many in our generation will dismiss a no-[hymns] position as “extreme” and “austere” and “rigid”. But those who say such things must place these very same labels on the greater part of the Christian church. When one looks back over the history of the church, it is not the no-[hymns] position that is surprising, but the fact that so many of us have willingly accepted the use of [hymns] in our own generation.”

In conclusion: (and for those that have skipped the guff above)

Yeah it’s a good book. Very good. In fact, the best book I’ve read on instruments. Brian Schwertly has a very good book on the subject entitled ‘Musical Instruments in the Public Worship of God’ (available here) which is a good bit shorter, even with him taking time to set out the regulative principle. But apart from that it follows nearly the same formula. Schwertly, however, has probably never been called ‘winsome’. I really don’t see how you could read either of those 2 books and still be in favour of instruments. For those not convinced – read one of them and prove me wrong!

Related links: – Instrumental Music in the Public Worship of God (pdf), by John L. Girardeau (1888): An older book on the subject that Price draws on quite heavily.
– Psalms and Hymns and Spiritual Songs

Note to self: Look up ‘concise’ in the dictionary

25 years of Piper audio, and other stories

– Desiring God have finally launched their new website. Among other things it offers 25 years of John Piper audio sermons (with videos for some of them as well!). There is reams of stuff on the site, here’s Piper telling us how he memorises Scripture. There is a section of Essential Piper resources and lots of Piper’s books available free.

– If Bebo doesn’t already waste enough of your time, Facebook (like, the original bebo) has finally opened up to allow Queen’s students to register (unlike bebo, you need to actually be at one of their listed universities or schools to sign up). Pam was on the case first and has already set up a Renwick group. A few interesting photos:


Sharon and random yanks


Tony Mastris with no hair after losing a bet!

– This is one of the funniest posts on Ref 21 for a long time. You’ll only get it if you’ve been reading Ref 21, and if you haven’t, you should be!

– Strobert is back. And is using words like ‘cellphone’ in normal conversation, while defying all expectations by looking exactly the same.

Update: The new DG site took an amazing $70,000 dollars to complete. They say it cost them $200 to convert EACH Piper audio tape to mp3 format (digitally mastering it and removing distortion). The other week I converted 25 David McCullough tapes to mp3. So, if he was John Piper, it would have cost him $5,000!

Faughan GO Team 2006

100_1850

I thought for a change I would approach this report my doing a mini-report on each of the GO team members.

Rob Pink: All of our previous GO team leaders are now RP ministers – no pressure, Pinky!
Cromie Robert: Seemed somewhat embarrassed by his new-found celebrity status. Soon recovered however and wrote a song about a certain Presbytery, which sadly can’t be shared. It may be a hidden track on his forthcoming album.
Amy:This was the 3rd week in the last 5 we’d spent together – we haven’t come to blows yet!
Deco: Nothing could follow his comments on the poor man’s Saw Doctors, but he did voice his intentions to preach from the Good News Bible last Sunday – which is funny when you know where he was preaching…
David Duly: According to Dave, the following were Bangin’:
Derek Petrie, walking to Bob & Georgia’s, the bookstall at guest night, the quiz at guest night, The Southern Presbytery Song, The Word Today, Richard Magee getting attacked through a letterbox by a dog, Tesco, receiving a cup of coffee, reading the Institutes, Stute Orange Juice
The following people were ‘The man’:
Fergus, Deco, Marcus McCullough, Graham, David Silversides, Sammy, Rennie, Peter F, Cromie Joel, Cromie, me, Pinky, the apostle Paul, Timmy McFarland, Bob Robb, big Bob, Schaffer, RC Sproul, Davy Sutherland
Christine: Concurred with Cromie’s song.

And a few obligatory snaps, although we were far too busy for too many photos!

01church_projector
That thing up at the front of the church is a projector! – Bob was using it for his sermon points

02churchfromhazelbank_leafletdist
It’s pretty cool doing distribution this close to the church

03teatowel
Amy was rather traumatised by one of the tea towels in our church hall

04_1_nevermindthedog
This always cracks me up – a wee dude with a shotgun with the inscription “Never mind the dog, beware of the owner!”

05stuteorange
Bangin’ – too right Dave!

10debs_christine
Debs and Christine

11amy_mallet
Timmy Mallett

15ahsawooh
The locals are introduced to ah saw ooh!

Some Youth Club socca action – played at intense speed, hense the blurring!

12john_cromiejoel

13footballaction

14john

And on to the HBC:

P8230013
Letitia

P8220045
Cromie

P8210077
Andrew and Colin

P8210064
Matthew

P8210036
Andy

P8210033
Richard

P8210013
Pinky and the Brain!

P8210009
Dave and Cromie

P8230030
Cousins

P8230015
Samuel

The End of an Era: Renwick 2004-06

I’ve been meaning to do this post for nearly 3 months now, finally I have some time on my hands :-P

For the last two years I lived in Renwick, and before I move on to living in Ulsterville, I thought I would mark the occasion (I’m not going to do a round up of all we did, because it would take far too long!). It all seems a long time since September 2004, meeting the new people, playing off-the-ground tig in the common room, working out how to get around Belfast – never mind doing Computer Science!

One of the most traumatic things about leaving was having to dismantle my Northern Ireland shrine (which I started before the start of term this year and continually added to all year).

Image002
In full glory

100_1206

Image003

Image004
The destruction starts…

Image019
Man that’s grim

Image017
‘Give that man a ladder!’ – for the last time :-‘(

Further depression was generated by the starkness of the ‘On End of Tenancy’ notice. However, the line “Committee will take all necessary steps to ensure arrears are paid” is quite ironic in view of the fact that the committee owe me 35 notes for a BBQ, eh GMO?!

Image018

But anyway, all of this depression is only because of what a great time I had in Renwick! If you are going to be a student in Belfast, apply for Renwick! If you are a student in Belfast and not in Renwick, get round there! If you’re intending to leave Norn Iron for uni, take a long hard look at yourself! My advice would be to choose the university (Q, Q, QUB!) before the course. And I’m deadly serious.

Another reason for this post is to show pictures of the t-shirts that were made during our last day or so, as not all the residents will have seen theirs! The stuff on the back should be easily understood to Renwick residents (and unofficial residents!) of the past year. Except the green blob, which is meant to be a ball, and represent sports in general. Looking at the tshirts has also reminded me of one of the best things about Renwick, the Bible Studies! Great times! Anyway, here they are:

Image009

Image008

Image014

Image015

Image005

Image016
Some people can’t spell!

Image011

Image010

Image007

Image013

Image012

Image006

And here’s a photo from our last ever night in Renwick:

last night in renwick at qub

Good Times

This post has been slightly overshadowed however by recent developments on the admissions front. You may be all set for going into Renwick, having been told you’ve been given a place, having paid your money since June – when, 4 weeks before term starts (having turned down all offers of other accomodation), you may be told that because you haven’t got the grades to go to Queen’s (but while you’re still quite happy to stay in Renwick and go to Jordanstown, getting the bus at the top of the road to any day you have the misfortune of being in class), you’re being kicked out. The term, I believe, involves the royal family going down mines.

U Who?

PETRIE DENIES KNOWLEDGE OF IRELAND’S MOST FAMOUS EVER BAND

08cromiedeco2

DRUMAHOE, LONDONDERRY (Reuters / SWS) – RPC Theological College student Derek Petrie this evening claimed that he’d never heard of U2 before last week. Donegal music legend Cromie Robert didn’t know whether to laugh, or sadly shake his head – so he did both. Seconds previously, ‘Deco’ had revealed that he’d never heard of Westlife until 2 weeks ago. In this case however, Cromie’s response was “Ignorance is bliss”. Completely unperturbed at never having heard of a band that have sold over 170 million albums worldwide, Petrie returned to talking about Martin Llyod-George.

——-

GO Team going well. Should send out another prayer request I suppose (do LK not need prayer Mark?!). Today was like the busiest day on a GO team ever!! Getting through the leaflets well. Help from some of the young people in the church has been encouraging. Pray God would use the leaflets. Children at HBC / Youth Club have listened well – pray they’d be saved.

Offy completes double signing

I was going to post this before TF, but didn’t get time to get it finished, so not quite so breaking news anymore…

David Officer has returned to former club Dundela, while also signing for Amateur League side Islandmagee, after 2 years at Bangor. Speaking exclusively to SWS, Officer revealed that he was still on a downer after that penalty miss in the final of the recent Ballyclabber tournament and is looking to get back to winning ways.

After a long spell with the Duns, Offy attracted the attention of Bangor in the summer of 2004 by standing on chairs and talking into microphones, and a big money soon move followed.

100_0250

Offy’s biggest moment for Bangor came in April of this year when they faced Linfield in an Irish Cup Semi-Final. Despite about 1700 fans turning up specifically to support him, Offy was left on the bench. He came on in the second half and hit the bar, but Bangor were left ruing the decision not to start him and the game finished 1-3.

By the end of the season, Officer was showing signs of mental strain at not starting as often as he would have like. He briefly experimented with levitating, but soon found that it clashed with his RP beliefs:

In July he reached his lowest point, wandering about Armagh dressed as Doctor Who. (Brian, on the other hand, was behaving perfectly normally)

offie brian
Who are ya? (Geddit?)

Offy appeared to be back to his best at the Ballyclabber Tournament, getting a brace for Mick’s Muckers in their opening game thanks to some generous Bready goalkeeping.

19offievringers

The Muckers got all the way to the final, and enjoyed huge support as the only RP representatives left in an RP competition. A 1-1 draw took the match to sudden death penalties. Offy took first – and missed! However their opponents also missed, much to young Officer’s relief. His relief didn’t last long however as the Galacticos held their nerve to win the trophy and Offy had to accept a runners-up medal.

25runnersup

All that is in the past however, and Offy has been welcomed with open arms to his 2 new clubs. Islandmagee’s most ardent fan, a Mr. Paul Gibson, said:

“David should come and play on the finest grass surface the province has to offer, and forget about playing for that lot at Dundela and stay with us for the season, because we’re a great bunch.”


Paul (on the right) has been to more RP churches than Gary

Having been to Wilbourne Park (and even written a report of it!) I can actually confirm young Paul’s statement. I’ve even watched them away! (Incidentally, on the same day they signed him, the Islanders also signed a boy called Joel Lough. True fact!) The Duns are just as delighted to have him back. His squad profile reads:

DAVID OFFICER – Midfielder: This much-liked player with Dundela fans, should never have been away from the ‘Park’. Having spent a recent interim period at Bangor where he also tasted some success, David re-joined his beloved Dundela at the start of this season.

So the future looks bright for Offy – but just wait till the Duns play Stute…