Systematic Expository Challenges

Interesting from Geoff Thomas, looking back and questioning his own approach. He famously began his ministry preaching on Genesis 1:1 in the morning and Matthew 1:1 in the evening.

(Though on that he says: “Looking back, I think I should have given them a taste. “Do you like this?” Then another taste, for example, of some New Testament preaching for those who came only on Sunday mornings. I would preach on the Beatitudes and on the life of Elijah or the life of Joseph. Give them more variety. I have twice preached through the book of Genesis, and the second series thirty years later was far more balanced and lucid than the first time when I began my ministry”)

“I do want to challenge my own singular commitment to systematic expository preaching. It can make us lazy in our wrestling with God for His will on which text we should take on a given Lord’s Day. It can dull the appetite of God’s people for the Word by simply continuing the next Sunday where we left off the Sunday before. Doesn’t preaching from different texts demonstrate well that all Scripture is given by inspiration of God? We must never give the impression that we have “done” a gospel, or an epistle, or a prophetic book so that we will never preach on it again. Have you “done” London if you have thoroughly seen some of its biggest attractions? Finally, by preaching through a book of the Bible, we may well end up giving an extended commentary on Bible passages.”

“…I am challenging my own approach, questioning whether I became a slave to a certain methodology. I took up a style that was prevailing in the evangelical circles in which I moved. I did not have sufficient role models in what I have called the Spurgeonic tradition. Great profit can be reaped from systematic expository evangelistic preaching, but the danger to be avoided in that approach is making a sermon a plain Bible study lacking pathos, passion, and pleading. Even Lloyd-Jones himself did not avoid that in some of his Friday night sermons on Romans. One can significantly benefit from preaching on isolated texts and be touched, in one’s daily devotions, by a passage that speaks to your condition and convinces you that preaching on this particular text will help the people.”

But on the other hand:

“Isolated texts need to be found week after week. Isolated texts do not capture the flow of redemptive history. They also can become hobby-horse texts for preachers who are obsessed with certain themes.”