The Completion of C. S. Lewis

The Completion of C. S. Lewis: From War to Joy, 1945-1963
Harry Lee Poe
Crossway, 2022

There are very few people I’ve read more than one biography of. When it comes to C. S. Lewis I’ve now read three across six volumes, not counting Lewis’s own autobiography and Humphrey Carpenter’s The Inklings. The fact that three biographies can equal six volumes is due to Harry Lee Poe’s contribution. 2019’s Becoming C. S. Lewis was originally intended to be a standalone volume, but Crossway agreed that Poe could write a follow-up on Lewis’s journey from atheist to apologist if he would also write a third which would take us to the end of Lewis’s life. Volume 2 duly arrived in 2021, and the third and final volume is now here, completing a delightful series of books.

So why read more than one Lewis biography? And what advantage do Poe’s volumes have over the others?

I’ve enjoyed all three Lewis biographies I’ve read and would recommend all of them.

First there was George Sayer’s Jack (also published by Crossway, back in 1994), then Alistair McGrath’s C. S. Lewis: A life (Hodder, 2013). Sayer’s has the advantage of being written by someone who knew Lewis personally. McGrath’s was the first biography to make use of the publication of Lewis’s letters by Walter Hooper (in 3 volumes containing over 4,000 pages). Poe makes even more use of these letters, along with other resources that remain unpublished.

In summary I would say that Poe’s work is exhaustive but not exhausting. If you just want an overview of Lewis’s life it might be overkill, but for the Lewis fan, they’re a joy to read. Poe is clearly sympathetic to Lewis, and takes the hostile biography of A. N. Wilson to task on a number of occasions. Occasionally, too much of Poe’s unrelated opinions come through (such as his promotion of big bang cosmology, vol. 2, pp 326-7), but mostly he takes a back seat. He leaves no stone unturned, even having managed to track down a record (like, an actual record) of a previously unknown talk Lewis gave to be broadcast in Iceland following their invasion by the British in 1940.

Like all good books, the biggest disappointment about Poe’s biography is that it eventually it has to come to an end!