The Reformed Pastor
Richard Baxter (updated and abridged by Tim Cooper)
Crossway, 2021
The Reformed Pastor is a more controversial book than some of us may have realised. Carl Trueman has apparently called it ‘one of the most depressing, almost psychopathic books on pastoral ministry’. Many of the book’s critics trace its problems to the fact that in the words of R. Scott Clark, Baxter ‘denied the Protestant doctrine of Justification’.
Clark says that Baxter’s works are ‘sprinkled with arsenic’ and should come with the warning: ‘the contents of this volume may be both spiritually useful and harmful. Use only under the supervision of your minister’. Some of the concerns with The Reformed Pastor are highlighted in an article by James Renihan entitled ‘Reforming the Reformed Pastor’.
That being said, The Reformed Pastor has never been lacking in commendations, whether from Spurgeon in his day or Mark Jones in ours (‘I need to read and reread this classic’ he says in his endorsement). Joel Beeke describes it as ‘the type of book you want to read once a year’.
If it is a book to be read regularly, the 600 pages that the book takes up in Baxter’s collected works is a bit of a stumbling block. The Banner of Truth ‘Puritan Paperback’ version is itself an abridgement of around 250 pages. This edition by Cooper is 150, whittling down Baxter’s 160,000 words to 30,000.
Out of all the contenders to do the abridgement, Cooper may well be the most qualified to do it, having been one of the co-editors of Baxter’s mammoth autobiography (5 volumes, only £472.50 from OUP). As Van Dixhoorn says in the foreward: ‘He has so engaged the pastor of Kidderminster’s theological and practical writings that he is able, if I may use the phrase, to think his thoughts after him’.
Baxter’s most famous work will remain controversial – but it’s now a lot more accessible.