In Episode 10 of Life and Books and Everything, DeYoung, Hansen and Taylor choose 5 desert island books. You’re allowed English, Greek and Hebrew Bibles on top of your 5 (and surely a psalter!). You’re allowed multi-volume books, but not someone’s complete works.
In their version, you’re going to get off the island again in 6 months. I think that would change the equation a lot for me as in that case I would probably bring all new stuff (and maybe include a novel)! But if it was for the rest of your life, here’s my five:
- Andrew Bonar (ed.) – Memoirs and Remains of Robert Murray M’Cheyne.
Includes one of my favourite biographies, and also plenty of devotional content in terms of sermons etc. - John Owen – Communion with God.
Haven’t read it, but I’ve heard enough excerpts and read enough Owen to be fairly sure I’d like it. And a pretty relevant topic when you’re stuck on an island! - Calvin – Institutes
A toss up between Calvin (which I’ve read) and Turretin (which I haven’t). - John Newton – Letters
Not sure which collection, but I’m sure we could work out the finer details. Probably Wise Counsel – almost 400 pages, so fairly substantial, and really well edited by Grant Gordon. - C. S. Lewis – Essay Collection and Other Short Pieces
When thinking if there was anything in the 20th century or after I would choose, Lewis was the one who immediately came to mind. I might go for The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe (or the whole Chronicles if they just counted as one), but with Essay Collection you get about 900 pages, sermons (eg Weight of Glory), Essays, Letters and Short Stories. Here’s Tony Reinke’s synopsis of it.
Runners-up:
Samuel Rutherford – Christ Dying and Drawing Sinners to himself
Have only read part of it, but don’t imagine it would disappoint. Looking forward to getting in to Rutherford as RHB bring out their critical edition of his works over the next ten years.
Life and Letters of J. P. Struthers
My hero. Probably top of the list of RP authored books to bring. Symington on Atonement and Intercession wouldn’t be too far away either. Or Symington or Houston’s journals, if anyone ever publishes them!
James Durham – Collected Sermons (2 vols)
Again, haven’t read, but I have read Durham.
Andrew Bonar – Christ and his Church in the Book of Psalms
Would be nice to have something on a particular part of Scripture. Maybe even Carson on John.
Bunyan – Pilgrim’s Progress
I’d also make a strong argument to get Banner’s edition of the Westminster Standards (the whole lot, including the Solemn League & Covenant) there by default!