Covenant Theology: Biblical, Theological, and Historical Perspectives
Guy Prentiss Waters, J. Nicholas Reid and John R. Muether (eds)
Crossway, 2020
2020 looks like it will be a good year for books on Covenant Theology. First came The Fulfilment of the Promises of God by Richard Belcher (Christian Focus), which may end up replacing Palmer Robertson as the ‘go to’ book on the topic. The next month or so will see the publications of Harrison Perkins’ Catholicity and the Covenant of Works and The Covenant of Works by J. V. Fesko (both OUP).
In between those three, and most exciting of all, Crossway have released this collaboration by the faculty of Reformed Theological Seminary, weighing in at almost 700 pages. The aforementioned Belcher and Robertson each contribute to the twenty-seven chapters.
The comprehensive nature of the book can be seen in the titles of its three main sections. Part 1 covers the Biblical Covenants, Part 2 is on Historical Theology and Part 3 on Collateral and Theological Studies, which includes chapters on ‘Israel and the Nations’, ‘Dispensationalism’ and ‘New Covenant Theologies’. The Federal Vision is dealt with in ‘The Covenant of Works in the Old Testament’ where Belcher concludes ‘This approach modifies the traditional understanding of Christ’s work as a basis for our justification…A reworking of the covenant of works changes how one understands the work of Christ and the basis of justification by faith’.
The annotated bibliography at the end is very helpful, and gets bonus points for mentioning De Graaf’s Promise and Deliverance (original title ‘History of the covenant’). Patrick Gillespie’s books are only mentioned in passing, but he is quoted frequently in Guy Richard’s chapter on the Covenant of Redemption.
While this is not the book for someone merely wanting an introduction to or ‘popular’ treatment of covenant theology (see Rhodes, Belcher or Robertson for that), it is a great resource for ministers to have, whether to read through slowly or use as a reference work.
Unsurprisingly for a volume with many authors, there isn’t complete agreement. For example, Ligon Duncan’s ‘Foreward’ reminds us the Westminster Confession doesn’t identify the covenant of works as ‘grace’, deliberately using the term ‘voluntary condescension’ instead. Whereas Kevin DeYoung’s ‘Afterward’ (adapted from a sermon) quotes the same section of the WCF and says ‘this is a fancy way of saying that for God to enter into any kind of agreement with man – even one based on works – was an act of grace’.
Overall I’m delighted to see this in print, and I’m sure I will refer to it often – just as I do to its companion volumes, the Biblical Theological Introductions to the Old and New Testaments, also from the RTS stable, and published by Crossway in 2016.
Thanks to Crossway for a complimentary copy of this book.