BNI

Good points:
– The traveling was actually quite fun.
– Seeing people.
– Stuart. Who declared himself to be an honorary RP.
– A free book. Even though they forgot to actually bring them. But they said they’d post them out.
– The evening thing might have been good, but I’d a boat to catch.

Bad points:
(I know it looks bad that the bad points take up a lot more space than the good points, but there are actually more good points and it was a really good day!)
– Getting up at 04:30
– Shocked and horrified to see Roj selling out.
– Their decision to use hymns. Like, even if they do genuinely believe that Banner favourites such as the Westminster Divines, John Owen, Thomas Watson, Thomas Manton etc were wrong and that ‘Psalms, hymns and songs’ (as the BNI booklet was called) mean man-made compositions, surely in the interests of Christian unity we could just have sung psalms? Especially seeing that at least 22 out of the 60 or so there were RPs (making us easily the best-represented denomination). Stick to the psalms, and everybody can sing them. Use hymns, and a lot of people can’t in good conscience join in. (For the record, out of the 12 songs in the booklet, one and a half were psalms).
But good playing from Tim. If I ever decide to revert to “a silly delight in that worship of the Old Testament which was figurative, and terminated with the Gospel” (Calvin), I’ll give him a shout :-P
– The end of the drive back, approaching 20 hours of being awake.

Pictures

me larne
We arrived in NI after taking the secret passage from the Stranraer church to the Larne church, which brings you out in the middle of the shrubs.

carla larne
Carla

strob giving it some cut
More would’ve come if they’d advertised the fact that Strob was speaking

Image003
Not Happy

boat
Boat!

13 thoughts on “BNI”

  1. see what a morning, gloriously bright,
    B^*(T”% (for your own safety) has left the light on again,

    …. man steve, u didn’t enjoy the last part of the ride home, i sure did, yer a funny boy, i’d hate to see what alcohol wud do te ye!

  2. “Shocked and horrified to see Roj selling out.”

    What does this mean? Who is Roj?

    “For the record, out of the 12 songs in the booklet, one and a half were psalms”

    Yes, its strange that “psalms hymns and spiritual songs” is usually applied as 90% uninspired hymns. If these terms are not synonomous descriptions of Biblical songs, then what is the difference between a “hymn” and a “spiritual song”.

  3. in the interest of Christian unity, why dont the RPs try not to whinge? in my experience of interdenominational weekends they only seem to accept it as genuinely united if everyone else dances to their tune (so to speak). so on the one occasion when they do not get to dominate proceedings (and by my calculation 22 is still only one third of the assembled congregation) might they not just be able to hold their peace and not sound off about it?

    is it not ever so slightly typical that a SWS report about a day’s Bible teaching intended to encourage and edify young Christians from a variety of reformed churches manages not to mention said teaching (not even the topic) and instead gets all huffy about the mathematical breakdown of the “psalms hymns and songs” on a printed brochure.

    my beloved RP brethren, wind yer necks in

  4. My dearest Anglican,

    1. It seems quite simple to me. Either sing psalms (which every Christian not only can, but is commanded to, sing)
    OR sing hymns and exclude people. The ratio surely doesn’t matter. Why exclude anyone? I don’t really care how many hymns there were in the booklet – I put it in brackets and said ‘for the record’.

    2. Your experience of interdenominational weekends would be the P&R and nothing else? And how exactly do RPs dominate? Numbers on the committee – don’t think so? Maybe it’s just that Christian unity prevails?

    3. Is it typical for SWS to report a time of Bible teaching and ignore said teaching? Really?

    4. FYI the topics were all on my preview post here: http://www.shallwesingasongforyou.co.uk/?p=342. Also, I did mention the teaching above, I said Stuart was good. And would you not rather fire off an email to AC the B and acquire the talks yourself rather than depend on whatever I thought of them?!

    5. The cynical might ask that if the day was solely intended to encourage & edify, why, after worship has been an ‘issue’ at other recent Banner Conferences, was the Conf originally advertised as having a seminar on worship (pretty much guaranteed not to support the position of the WCF and just generally annoy people) – which was mysteriously pulled with no explanation before the conference actually happened?

    6. I heard you were speaking well at the Christian Stute meetings there, keeper lit.

    Give my love to the Archbishop,
    Steelo

    PS: I invite responses to the above (or similar statements written on the official feedback forms) from anyone at Banner – I don’t want to be accused of being a ‘keyboard warrior’ here.

  5. “The cynical might ask that if the day was solely intended to encourage & edify, why, after worship has been an ‘issue’ at other recent Banner Conferences, was the Conf originally advertised as having a seminar on worship (pretty much guaranteed not to support the position of the WCF and just generally annoy people) – which was mysteriously pulled with no explanation before the conference actually happened?”

    Yes, I sent someone an e-mail – who was going to the conference – that this would probably be an attack upon exclusive psalmody. If Banner of Truth really want to encourage Christian unity among those who differ on secondary issues then why don’t they just not mention certain contentious issues (which is what they have done on baptism for the last 50 years), rather than annoying people needlessly? Such an approach is hardly Christian maturity.

  6. Mr Disappointed

    [though, considering the searing cynicism, brutal bluntness and thinly-veiled-anti-RP stance of the post, I think you may have blown your anonymity – as only one person I know would write like that!!!]

    Let’s remember what blogs are. Contrary to the esteemed and revered position many of us (myself included) mistakenly afford to it, we must bear in mind that the weblog entitled “Shall We Sing a Song for You” contains the personal ramblings and opinions of the enthusiastic yet occasionally insane Mr Stephen Steele. It is not the definitive stance of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of Ireland on any given topic. Instead, for a better idea of the beliefs and doctrines of said denomination, please consult the following documents:
    A) The Bible
    B) The Westminster Confessions and Catechisms
    C) The Testimony of the Reformed Presbyterian Church

    The same applies to blogs by Daniel Ritchie, the James McCullough and Ali McCollum show, Mark Loughridge and any other RP crackpots who know how to work this box of tricks they call the internet ;-)

    Your post seemed unaware of this when it appealed in the plural to “the RPs” and to your “beloved RP brethren” (beloved brethren who, by the way, you had just accused of whinging and exhorted to wind their necks in … all apparently in the “interests of Christian unity”)

    However, that is not to suggest that I disagree with what Stephen said in the above post. It is clear though from your response that you have been left “disappointed” by it. What was your main complaint with the post?

    – That an RP published his opinions on a personal blog?
    See opening comments

    – That Steelo’s report of BNI was overly negative?
    I quote: “I know it looks bad that the bad points take up a lot more space than the good points, but there are actually more good points and it was a really good day!”

    – That an RP dared to hope that at an event such as this, AS IN THE PAST AT MANY SUCH EVENTS, the organisers would use the psalms which everyone can sing and is commanded to sing? Thus avoiding secondary contentious issues and so focusing on what we have in common.
    See responses by Steelo (Point 1 – though he was most un-RP by having 6 points!) and Daniel

  7. The gloves have really come off in this discussion! I suspect Mr Disappointed has the initials M.J.?

    Let me just say though (I can’t speak for all RPs only myself) but I do not have a problem with going to a meeting in another denomination where uninspired hymns are used (I would not sing them, but it would not annoy me); nor do I object to preachers in other churches defending their position from Scripture if that is what they believe the word of God is teaching (I disagree, but fair enough).

    However, what does annoy me is that an inter-denominational conference (such as Banner NI) would deliberately arrange things in order to annoy many of the people their by: a) singing uninspired hymns which one third of the people can’t sing. b) organizing a seminar on “worship” that was only going to cause unnecessary annoyance and division.

    Banner of Truth was originally started to publish Reformed doctrinal and devotional literature, while my interests are somewhat broader (i.e. it includes Christian world view issues, which they have largely ignored), they have done great service to the church of Christ. Moreover, they have either avoided contentious issues (i.e. not publishing MLJ’s on John Owen’s arguments for and against exclusive psalmody) or publishing books which give both sides of the argument. So then, why have they adopted such an antagonistic approach to worship in recent years, when they are supposed to be promoting Christian unity?

  8. “in the interest of Christian unity, why don’t the RPs try not to whinge?”

    “my beloved RP brethren, wind yer necks in”

    Let me add a little more in response to these points. Readers should note that a certain Reformed bookshop refused to sell any copies of my book, simply because it argued for exclusive psalmody (remember it is a book about the Regulative Principle of worship, with a chapter on exclusive psalmody, not a book about exclusive psalmody itself).

    Now, as a free-market capitalist, I respect the right of the business owner to sell what he wants (so I did not argue). Yet is it not strange that the same shop has no problem selling stuff that argues for believer’s baptism, John Frame’s distortion of the RPW, books by NT Wright (who denies the Protestant view of Justification), poor paraphrases of the Bible (the Message etc), and various other works which are not even Reformed, yet, when it comes to exclusive psalmody, even a shop which represents such a broad spectrum of opinion suddenly resorts to censorship?

  9. Emma – im worried as the issue is starting to become quite complex and theres something about debating/arguing on the internet is wrong, that i think this issue should be dealt with face to face not behind computer screens. i hope to see an honest and clear conclusion.

  10. Emma: Yeah, I was starting to feel a bit sorry for Matt with Richo keeping firing at him without reply! However surely it’s not a contradiction that a debate over a contentious issue involves a bit of negativity?

    Bob: It would be hard to have a face-to-face discussion with Matt in N’Castle, me in Scotland, DR probably holed up in a room somewhere surrounded by pictures of RJ Rushdoony (:-P) writing his new book on theonomy and Peter just started into final year…

    And, interesting as it would be, the ‘Mr Disappointed’ who has the initials MJ, attends St. James’, Gateshead and works for the Christian Stute is not a certain Banner employee…

    Comments are now closed, 2 and a half weeks is long enough on this one!

Comments are closed.