Calvin, Weekly Communion, and the Scottish Reformed Tradition

Are those who advocate weekly communion simply following the desire of John Calvin? Was communion in Scotland only celebrated less frequently due to a lack of ministers? Many would answer ‘yes’ to both those questions – but despite what we’re often told, the facts don’t seem to back that up. Adam Kuehner of Southfield RPCNA (Michigan) has written a booklet (30 pages) on the issue which is today available to download as a free PDF. In it, Kuehner shows that for both Calvin and the Scottish Reformers (and those who followed), proper fencing of the table was more important than the frequency of the celebration. In fact, delaying the Easter communion in order to properly fence the table was what got Calvin and Farel banished from Geneva. While exiled in Strasbourg, Calvin pastored a local congregation and opted for monthly communion, even though the city council allowed Bucer to serve it weekly.

All that being said, none of this provides historical precedent for only having communion a few times a year. Kuehner (whose congregation celebrates communion 6 times a year) points out:

It should be noted that Scottish communion frequency is too often viewed in a simplistic manner. Some rural Scottish congregations celebrated the Lord’s Supper only once or twice per year, while others kept a quarterly schedule. Nevertheless, the common practice of parishioners communing in adjacent parishes meant that many were able to commune more frequently than four times per year. This fact is often overlooked.