As election day dawns in America, many evangelical and Reformed leaders have spent the past few weeks urging people to vote. Even Joel Beeke has said that his conscience won’t allow him NOT to vote for Romney.
In the midst of all the pragmatic madness, there have been some voices of reason from the RPCNA (whose testimony says they should “vote for civil rulers who fear God, love truth and justice, hate evil, and are publicly committed to scriptural principles of civil government”). Check out the following sermon from Dave Reese:
Nathan Eshelman, a former student of Joel Beeke, has also written this response to his article.
Not that many in Northern Ireland can point the finger when it comes to pragmatism in voting of course – but it’s interesting and sad to see on a bigger scale the consequences of failure to practically believe in Christ’s kingship over the nation.
“And ye peoples, to whom God gave the liberty to choose your own magistrates, see to it, that ye do not forfeit this favor, by electing to the positions of highest honor, rascals and enemies of God.” ~ John Calvin
See also: America Decides On A President; But She Can Still Pray To The King
And check out Phil’s article in the Messenger, due out in churches this Lord’s Day and online from next week.
I listened to this sermon on Sabbath night; it is heartily recommended. I think the errors of our friends flow out of two serious deficiencies within American Calvinism:
1) Failure to accept the establishment principle as it was originally confessed.
2) Failure to acknowledge that the Pope of Rome is THE antichrist.
As a result of the first, they adopt positions which are wholly at odds with Reformed orthodoxy concerning the civil magistrate, while all the time thinking they are upholding the Reformed position. This goes back to the initial compromise with the Enlightenment and the Constitution. More recently, owing to the influence of Neo-Calvinism/Kuyperianism they do not understand the two-kingdoms, and so they assume that the magistrate caring for true religion is a violation of “sphere-sovereignty”. Hence it should not come as a surprise that they take this notion to its logical conclusion and advocate voting for an antichrist to be their supreme magistrate. After all, if the magistrate is not bound to nourish true religion, then there can be no logical objection to voting for an idolater.
As a result of the second, “Reformed” Christians in the United States tend to see evil in overwhelmingly materialistic terms (which, ironically, is strangely similar to a Marxist definition of evil). They fail to realise that our greatest enemy is false Christianity, especially that embodied in the Papacy. When someone thinks that the antichrist is “big government”, a politician, or some middle-eastern ruler, then it should not surprise us when they go soft on spurious forms of Christianity such as Mormonism. Instead of worrying about the idolatry of the Mormons, the focus is all on abortion and homosexuality or other second-table issues (failing to recognise that our idolatry is the root of these second-table offences). Moreover, how exactly can you be Reformed without believing that the Pope is the antichrist? What are we “Reformed” from? Popery and Romanism.
The compromise we are seeing all around us should make us thankful not only for political dissent, but also for the original Westminster Confession. It should also remind us of the practical dangers of tinkering with such tried and tested standards. Ideas have consequences; if this election does not demonstrate that is true, then nothing does.