Me and Strob went down to see the first showing of the Narnia film at the Movie House at 11am this morning. It was hard to believe that after all the hype and all the build up we were finally watching it! The film was great. Maybe not just as great as I expected, but still brilliant. The only downsides were when they needlessly changed what was in the book. Although one of the best bits in the film is where they play…spinnies!!!!!!! Me and Strob went mad at that point. Edmund’s first attempt at batting was a shamblés, and on his second attempt he got put out for aggression.
So anyway the film – brilliant. I was probably just expecting them to take the dialogue and stuff word for word from the book, so if you’re not that familiar with the book you might have less reservations. There are a few things that are just bad about the film. Firstly, both me and Strob thought that Tumnus took God’s name in vain near the start – but maybe he said girl. Surely they wouldn’t have put in blasphemy?!! Also, they’ve removed the best quote of the film (unless I missed it). The children have just found out that Aslan’s a lion and that ‘if there’s anyone who can appear before Aslan without their knees knocking, they’re either braver than most or else just silly.’ Then it comes:
“Then he isn’t safe?” said Lucy
“Safe?” said Mr Beaver; “don’t you hear what Mrs Beaver tells you?” Who said anything about safe? ‘Course he isn’t safe. But he’s good.”
(p75)
Also, when Edmund is reunited with his brother and sisters, instead of saying sorry like he does in the book (and it’s blatantly obvious that he should), they have him just stand and awkwardly say ‘hello’. Update: I’ve just read Tim Challies’ review and he says ‘I suspect it was a concession made to avoid the Christian theme from coming across too strongly’. The other changes aren’t that important – although the White Witch’s wand is very disappointing – it’s more like a cattle prod and most of the time she jabs people to turn them into stone, as if it really were a cattle prod, rather than using it like a traditional wand. Not that she turns many people into stone – she even keeps Tumnus in prison a while before turning him into stone. It’s just a pity when some New Zealandish director thinks he has a better idea of what the story should be like than C.S. Lewis.

This is turning into a bit of a rant, and it really shouldn’t be cos it’s a great film, but one more complaint is about Peter. He looks and sounds exactly as he should, like a mini Prince William, but most of the time he goes about being, I think the technical term is, a woofter. In a bit that wasn’t in the book, they’re all crossing a rapidly thawing river and a wolf has Mr. Beaver in his mouth, with another wolf beside them. Instead of swiftly killing the wolves, Peter just looks at them for ages (with Mr Beaver shouting at him to run them through the whole time) and then eventually uses his sword to break off the bit of ice they’re standing on. Also, at the bit where Aslan tells Peter to win his spurs (by fighting the wolf attacking Susan), he again stares at it until it eventually leaps at him, and it ends up just sorta landing on his sword. A far cry from the book:
‘Peter did not feel very brave; indeed, he felt he was going to be sick. But that made no difference to what he had to do. He rushed straight up to the monster and aimed a slash of his sword at its side’.
One last gripe is when the witch seeks an audience with Narnia to discuss the punishment for Edmund’s treachery. Well, that’s what happens in the book – the dwarf goes and asks Aslan, and then returns and tells her she can come. However in the film she just bombs on into the camp, being carried by some weirdos on a big stretcher thing. And of course, for the brilliant bit when she asks Aslan as she’s leaving how she knows he’ll do what he said and he just turns and roars at her – she can’t run away terrified so she just sits back down on her stretcher. Shamblés!
So just a few things that weren’t perfect, but they don’t ruin your enjoyment of the film. It’s one of those films you need to see a few times. I’m going again on Tuesday with Renwick and friends.
Liam Neeson was brilliant as the voice of Aslan – although not as good as the voice in the animated version (which I have a strong suspicion that Adamson borrowed a fair bit from for his film). Steven Thorne was Aslan in the animated version. I’ve just discovered that the animated version (which I paid silly money for in the summer off ebay) has been released on DVD (Amazon, Play) and you can buy it, with free delivery, for £11! I’m still glad it’s been properly released though.
A few other especial highlights: Lucy – they’ve nailed her. Perfect. Mr Beaver was hilarious and his jokes with Mrs Beaver are brilliant through the film. Aslan’s brilliant. The bit with him willingly laying down his life is amazing – such a powerful creature, the very Creator of Narnia, letting himself be tied and muzzled by the witch and her army. It’s just really powerful and really clear that he is choosing to be killed – to pay the price for Edmund’s treachery. And when he rises, and comes to join the battle, it makes the hairs on the back of your neck stand up when he roars. The whole thing about him sacrificing himself – I don’t think anyone’s going to be able to watch it and not think about Jesus, no matter how hard they try.
Time to start looking forward to the next film!
Related Posts:
reviews aren’t meant to tell u everything that happened in the film, just a breif description on all its bad points. Good thing ur not doing a course such as film studies.
You and I must be close to kindred spirits on this one. My review is quite similar. The movie Peter and the movie Aragorn could stand to attend assertiveness training together!
Pete, where did I say it was meant to be a review??!
I went to see it this afternoon with CY – Tanfastic! It’s well worth going! Gonna have to root out all the books now and get stuck into them. I think that’s going to be my revision avoidance for the exams in January.
Steve.
Don’t try and tell me that wasn’t a review.
i know one when i see one and that was one.