Thomas Houston – Divine Psalms against Human Paraphrases and Hymns
Tuesday, August 28th, 2007Not wanting to major on the minors, but I had a bit of this pamphlet by RP minister Thomas Houston typed out for my diss, so I thought I might as well finish the thing off. It was written in 1861, in response to a sermon by the Rev. William Johnston of Townsend-street Presbyterian Church. Hymns were illegal in the PCI at the time, however this didn’t stop some congregations introducing them. Johnston preached his sermon as a result of several months of controversy over the subject in his own congregation. Houston didn’t even think it worthy of a reply, but he wrote a response from Knockbracken because of the widespread ignorance about the subject. And if things were bad back then, they’re even worse now! Writing in his Introduction, Houston stated:
Of all that we have read in the shape of objections against the use of inspired psalms, or in favour of hymns and paraphrases, we have found nothing so futile and inapplicable as this brochure. We would not have considered it worthy of a formal reply, but for the reason that we have already stated – the prevalence of much ignorance and misconception on the subject. The cause of inspired psalmody is assuredly very safe after this assault. That a production so weak and irrelevant should have emanated form a man of Mr. Johnston’s acknowledged talent and standing, we can only ascribe to the circumstance, that he had a lurking feeling, that his case was indefensible; and that he was, to some extent, conscious that he was contending against a fundamental regulation of the supreme judicatory of his own church, and vindicating a practice which is directly opposed to the order of the church of God, under the Old Testament–to the worship, sanctioned by our Lord and His Apostles, and uniformly observed by the Primitive Christian Church, and followed by the Presbyterian Church in these lands, in her purest and best times.

















